Limitations of ozone data assimilation with adjustment of NO x emissions: mixed effects on NO 2 forecasts over Beijing and surrounding areas

Xiao Tang, Jiang Zhu, Zifa Wang, Alex Gbaguidi, Caiyan Lin, Xin Jin, Tao Song, Bo HuAtmospheric 2016 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates a cross-variable ozone data assimilation (DA) method based on an ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) used to improve ozone forecasts over Beijing and surrounding areas. The research delves into the impacts of cross-variable adjustment of nitrogen oxide ($NO_x$) emissions on nitrogen dioxide ($NO_2$) forecasts during the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games. A mixed effect on $NO_2$ forecasts was observed: while the method improved forecasts over nearly half of urban sites (15–36% RMSE reduction), it caused significant deterioration at others (56–239% RMSE increase). Negative impacts were primarily concentrated during daytime. Ideal-data assimilation (IDA) experiments confirmed these findings, highlighting EnKF limitations under strong nonlinear relationships between chemical variables, particularly when large biases exist in a priori emissions.

Introduction

Chemical Data Assimilation (CDA) combines numerical models with real-world observations to improve air quality forecasts. A common strategy is "cross-variable" assimilation, where observations of one pollutant (e.g., ozone, $O_3$) are used to adjust the emissions of its precursors (e.g., nitrogen oxides, $NO_x$). During the 2008 Beijing Olympics, temporary emission controls introduced significant uncertainties into standard emission inventories. This study evaluates whether using $O_3$ data to adjust $NO_x$ emissions leads to physically consistent improvements in $NO_2$ forecasts or if it introduces new errors due to the complex, nonlinear nature of atmospheric chemistry.

Methodology

The researchers used the Nested Air Quality Prediction Modeling System (NAQPMS) and an Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) for Real-Data Assimilation (RDA). Hourly surface $O_3$ observations from 17 stations in the Beijing area (11 urban, 6 suburban) were assimilated to adjust $NO_x$ emissions. Additionally, Ideal-Data Assimilation (IDA) experiments with a chemical box model were conducted to isolate chemical drivers from meteorological factors. The study utilized the INTEX-B Asia inventory (2006) adjusted for Olympic control measures and meteorological forcing from the MM5 model.

Results and Discussion

The EnKF assumes a linear relationship between the observed variable ($O_3$) and the adjusted variable ($NO_x$ emissions). However, in urban environments during the day, this relationship is highly nonlinear.

Mixed Impacts on $NO_2$ Forecasts

The RDA experiments revealed a stark divergence in performance across different monitoring sites. While $NO_2$ forecasts improved at approximately half of the urban sites, the other half saw dramatic increases in error.

Comparison of $NO_2$ forecast RMSE between NonDA and RDA experiments at urban and suburban sites. Points above the 1:1 line indicate degraded forecasts after data assimilation.

Diurnal and Spatial Variability

The effectiveness of the assimilation was highly dependent on the time of day and the location's chemical regime. DA was generally successful at night and in the morning when titration chemistry is more linear. In contrast, daytime urban chemistry—characterized by strong nonlinearity—often led the EnKF to make "wrong-way" adjustments to emissions, especially when the initial emission guess was significantly biased. Suburban sites, having lower $NO_x$ levels and simpler chemical regimes, showed much weaker DA impacts.

Diurnal variation of $NO_2$ forecast RMSE for urban stations with positive/negative DA impact and suburban stations with weak impact. Note the significant daytime error spike in panel (b).

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that the EnKF is sensitive to systematic biases in prior emission inventories when dealing with highly nonlinear chemical systems. Bias correction is essential for maintaining physical consistency across variables in cross-variable data assimilation. Future work should explore nonlinear filters, such as Particle Filters, and multi-pollutant assimilation strategies to better constrain the system and avoid the "linearization trap" inherent in standard EnKF applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates a cross-variable ozone data assimilation (DA) method based on an ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) that has been used in the companion study to improve ozone forecasts over Beijing and surrounding areas. The main purpose is to delve into the impacts of the cross-variable adjustment of nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions on the nitrogen dioxide (NO2) forecasts over this region during the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games. A mixed effect on the NO2 forecasts was observed through application of the cross-variable assimilation approach in the real-data assimilation (RDA) experiments. The method improved the NO2 forecasts over almost half of the urban sites with reductions of the root mean square errors (RMSEs) by 15–36 % in contrast to big increases of the RMSEs over other urban stations by 56–239 %. Over the urban stations with negative DA impacts, improvement of the NO2 forecasts (with 7 % reduction of the RMSEs) was noticed at night and in the morning versus significant deterioration during daytime (with 190 % increase of the RMSEs), suggesting that the negative data assimilation impacts mainly occurred during daytime. Ideal-data assimilation (IDA) experiments with a box model and the same cross-variable assimilation method confirmed the mixed effects found in the RDA experiments. In the same way, NOx emission estimation was improved at night and in the morning even under large biases in the prior emission, while it deteriorated during daytime (except for the case of minor errors in the prior emission). The mixed effects observed in the cross-variable data assimilation, i.e., positive data assimilation impacts on NO2 forecasts over some urban sites, negative data assimilation impacts over the other urban sites, and weak data assimilation impacts over suburban sites, highlighted the limitations of the EnKF under strong nonlinear relationships between chemical variables. Under strong nonlinearity between daytime ozone concentrations and NOx emissions uncertainties (with large biases in the a priori emission), the EnKF may come up with inefficient or wrong adjustments to NOx emissions. The present findings reveal that bias correction is essential for the application of the EnKF in dealing with the data assimilation problem over strong nonlinear system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2016limitations,
  author = {Xiao Tang and Jiang Zhu and Zifa Wang and Alex Gbaguidi and Caiyan Lin and Xin Jin and Tao Song and Bo Hu},
  title = {{Limitations of ozone data assimilation with adjustment of NO <sub> <i>x</i> </sub> emissions: mixed effects on NO <sub>2</sub> forecasts over Beijing and surrounding areas}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-16-6395-2016},
}
Figure