Limit Your Consumption! Finding Bounds in Average-energy Games

Kim G. Larsen, Simon Laursen, Martin ZimmermannarXiv 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates "average-energy games," a type of game where players aim to minimize resource consumption (like battery life) while adhering to certain constraints. The authors establish new complexity bounds for determining if a player can win these games under various conditions, particularly when the bounds themselves are not fixed but existentially quantified. This work is crucial for designing resource-aware systems and controllers in scenarios with uncertain or dynamic environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of synthesizing controllers for reactive systems that must operate within resource constraints, specifically focusing on energy consumption. These systems interact with an environment, and their behavior is modeled as a two-player game. Player 0 represents the system being synthesized, aiming to optimize its performance, while Player 1 represents an antagonistic environment. The core challenge lies in determining if a system (Player 0) can achieve its objectives (e.g., keeping energy consumption below a certain average) while satisfying given constraints (e.g., maintaining a minimum energy level).

Traditional quantitative games assign weights to edges, representing costs or resources. "Average-energy games" extend this by focusing on the long-run average accumulated energy. A key difficulty arises when the bounds on energy levels or average energy are not fixed inputs but rather parameters that Player 0 seeks to find existentially. This means asking: "Does there exist a bound such that Player 0 can win?" This is a more challenging problem than simply checking if a given bound is sufficient. The paper also introduces "recharge games," where energy can be replenished to a certain capacity, adding another layer of complexity.

Methods

The paper introduces several key contributions:

  • Average-Energy Games (with fixed bounds): The authors show that determining if Player 0 can bound the long-run average accumulated energy while keeping it non-negative is solvable in doubly-exponential time (2EXPTIME). This is achieved by establishing an equivalence between bounding the average energy and uniformly bounding the maximal energy level, a problem known to be in 2EXPTIME. The core idea is to construct a strategy that, even if the energy level temporarily exceeds a threshold, guarantees it will eventually drop below it, allowing for a bounded peak.
  • Average-Bounded Recharge Games: For games where energy can be recharged to a fixed capacity, the problem of determining if Player 0 wins with a given average energy threshold and capacity is EXPTIME-complete. To overcome this high complexity, they consider a variant where the recharge capacity is existentially quantified. This problem, asking if there exists a capacity that allows Player 0 to win, is shown to be solvable in polynomial time by reducing it to three-color parity games.
  • Tradeoffs: The paper explores tradeoffs between different quality measures. They demonstrate that increasing the recharge capacity can sometimes lead to a lower long-run average energy, but this tradeoff is not always monotonic. They also show that memory requirements for strategies can be traded for better long-run average energy performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Equivalence of Bounding Average and Maximal Energy: A crucial insight is that for average-energy games, the ability to bound the average accumulated energy is equivalent to the ability to uniformly bound the maximal energy level. This connection allows them to leverage existing results for maximal energy bounding.
  • Existential Quantification Simplifies Complexity: While checking for a given bound in average-bounded recharge games is EXPTIME-complete, making the capacity existentially quantified (i.e., "does there exist a capacity?") reduces the problem's complexity to polynomial time. This highlights how existential quantification can sometimes simplify decision problems in game theory.
  • Non-Monotonic Tradeoffs: The paper reveals that the relationship between recharge capacity and long-run average energy is not always straightforward. Increasing capacity doesn't always guarantee a lower average; it can sometimes lead to worse outcomes, demonstrating a non-monotonic tradeoff.
  • Memory vs. Performance: A clear tradeoff exists between the memory needed by a strategy and the long-run average energy it can achieve. Strategies with more memory can potentially achieve better average energy performance, but this comes at the cost of increased memory footprint.

Key Results

  • Average-Energy Games: Deciding if Player 0 can win an average-energy game with an existentially quantified average energy threshold is 2EXPTIME-complete.
  • Average-Bounded Recharge Games:
    • With fixed capacity and threshold, the problem is EXPTIME-complete.
  • With an existentially quantified capacity and a given threshold, the problem is EXPTIME-hard.
  • With an existentially quantified capacity and only the objective of keeping energy non-negative (Recharge(w, cap)), the problem is solvable in polynomial time.
  • Tradeoffs: The paper provides examples illustrating non-monotonic tradeoffs between capacity and average energy, and between memory states and average energy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Open Problems: The exact complexity of determining the existence of an upper bound in average-energy games (Problem 2 in the paper) is still open. Similarly, the decidability of average-energy games with a given threshold but without an upper bound on energy level remains an open problem.
  • Multi-dimensional Settings: The authors suggest extending their results to multi-dimensional settings, where multiple resources or objectives are considered simultaneously.
  • Alternative Measures for Strategy Construction: For average-energy games, the current approach uses representatives that minimize peak height. Future work could explore other measures for constructing strategies that bound energy levels.
  • Complexity of Recharge Games: The complexity of solving recharge games (without average bounds) is still an open question.
  • Upper Bounds on Tradeoffs: Further investigation into the precise upper bounds for the tradeoffs between capacity, memory, and average energy is suggested.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{larsen2016limit,
  author = {Kim G. Larsen and Simon Laursen and Martin Zimmermann},
  title = {{Limit Your Consumption! Finding Bounds in Average-energy Games}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.4204/eptcs.227.1},
}
Figure