Light Sterile Neutrinos: A White Paper

Kevork N. Abazajian, M. A. Acero, Sanjib Kumar Agarwalla, A. A. Aguilar-Arevalo, Carl H. Albright, Stefan Antusch, C. Argüelles, A. B. Balantekin, Gabriela Barenboim, V. Barger, P. Bernardini, Fedor Bezrukov, Ole Eggers Bjælde, S. A. Bogacz, N. S. Bowden, Alexey Boyarsky, A. Bravar, D. Bravo, S. J. Brice, A. D. Bross, B. Caccianiga, F. Cavanna, E. J. Chun, B. T. Cleveland, A. P. Collin, Pilar Coloma, J. M. Conrad, M. Cribier, A. Cucoanes, Juan Carlos D’Olivo, Subinoy Das, André de Gouvêa, A. Derbin, R. Dharmapalan, J. S. Díaz, Xiaoou Ding, Z. Djurcic, A. Donini, D. Duchesneau, H. Ejiri, S. R. Elliott, D. J. Ernst, A. Esmaili, J. J. Evans, E. Fernández-Martínez, E. Figueroa‐Feliciano, B. T. Fleming, J. A. Formaggio, D. Franco, J. Gaffiot, Raj Gandhi, Y. Gao, G. T. Garvey, В. Н. Гаврин, Pomita Ghoshal, D. Gibin, C. Giunti, S. Gninenko, V. V. Gorbachev, Dmitry Gorbunov, R. Guénette, A. Guglielmi, F. Halzen, J. Hamann, Steen Hannestad, W. C. Haxton, K. M. Heeger, R. Henning, Pilar Hernández, Patrick Huber, W. Huelsnitz, Aldo Ianni, Т. В. Ибрагимова, Y. Karadzhov, G. Karagiorgi, G. Keefer, Y. D. Kim, Joachim Kopp, В. Н. Корноухов, Alexander Kusenko, P. Kyberd, Paul Langacker, Th. Lasserre, M. Laveder, A. Letourneau, D. Lhuillier, Yufeng Li, M. Lindner, J. M. Link, B. L. Littlejohn, P. Lombardi, K. Long, J. López-Pavón, W. C. Louis, L. Ludhová, J. Lykken, P. Machado, Michele Maltoni, W. A. Mann, Danny MarfatiaarXiv 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This white paper addresses the hypothesis of light sterile neutrinos based on recent anomalies observed in neutrino experiments and the latest astrophysical data.

Introduction

The Standard Model of particle physics describes neutrinos as nearly massless particles that exist in three distinct flavors: electron ($ν_e$), muon ($ν_μ$), and tau ($ν_τ$). These "active" neutrinos interact via the weak nuclear force and gravity. However, over the past decade, a series of persistent experimental anomalies has challenged this three-flavor paradigm, suggesting the existence of "sterile" neutrinos. These hypothetical particles would not participate in weak interactions, manifesting only through gravitational effects and their ability to mix with active neutrinos.

Experimental Anomalies

The motivation for light sterile neutrinos (typically at the 1 eV mass scale) stems from three primary sources:

  1. The LSND and MiniBooNE Results: The Liquid Scintillator Neutrino Detector (LSND) observed an unexpected excess of electron antineutrino events in a muon antineutrino beam. This was later supported by the MiniBooNE experiment, which observed a similar low-energy excess. These results suggest a mass-squared difference ($Δ m^2 \sim 1 \text{ eV}^2$) that is significantly larger than the known solar and atmospheric oscillation scales.
  2. The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly: A re-evaluation of the predicted flux from nuclear reactors revealed a consistent ~6% deficit in the observed number of antineutrinos at short baselines compared to theoretical predictions. This deficit is significant at roughly the $3\sigma$ level.
  3. The Gallium Anomaly: During the calibration of solar neutrino detectors (GALLEX and SAGE) using high-intensity radioactive sources, researchers measured a significant deficit in expected event rates, currently estimated at a $2.7\sigma$ significance.

Theoretical Frameworks and Global Fits

To reconcile these findings, theorists have proposed "3+N" models, where N represents the number of additional sterile states. The paper utilizes Bayesian and frequentist statistical methods to perform global fits across dozens of disparate datasets.

  • 3+1 Models: The simplest extension adds one sterile neutrino. While it provides a basic framework for the anomalies, it faces severe "tension." Global fits show that the parameters required to explain appearance data (like LSND) are in direct conflict with disappearance data (like reactor and accelerator experiments), which show no evidence of sterile mixing. The paper concludes this model is essentially excluded by this internal contradiction.
  • 3+2 Models: Adding a second sterile neutrino introduces the possibility of CP violation (differences between matter and antimatter behavior). This provides additional degrees of freedom that can mitigate some statistical tensions, though severe discrepancies remain.

Cosmological Constraints

Sterile neutrinos also leave imprints on the early universe. Data from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) provide a measure of the effective number of relativistic degrees of freedom ($N_{eff}$).

Current cosmological observations from WMAP, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), and the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) hint at $N_{eff} \approx 3.5$ to $4.0$, which is higher than the Standard Model prediction of 3.046. This supports the existence of "extra" light particles. However, a mass conflict exists: while terrestrial experiments suggest a mass of ~1 eV, cosmological models prefer the sum of all neutrino masses to be $< 0.5 \text{ eV}$. This suggests that if sterile neutrinos exist, they may not have been fully thermalized during the Big Bang, or our understanding of early-universe cosmology requires adjustment.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The evidence for light sterile neutrinos remains tantalizing but contradictory. The current evidence is incomplete, and the observed anomalies could represent the first sign of a new sector of physics or, alternatively, mundane systematic errors in nuclear flux predictions.

The field is now transitioning toward a "definitive" experimental phase. Key future work includes:

  • MicroBooNE: Utilizing Liquid Argon Time Projection Chambers (LArTPCs) to distinguish between electrons and photons, potentially resolving the MiniBooNE low-energy excess.
  • OscSNS: Using the Spallation Neutron Source at Oak Ridge to test the LSND result with significantly lower backgrounds.
  • Radioactive Source Deployments: Placing megacurie sources (like $^{51}$Cr or $^{144}$Ce) inside or near large detectors like Borexino or Daya Bay to watch the "oscillation wave" directly.

Resolving this mystery is critical; if sterile neutrinos exist at the keV range, they could also serve as candidates for Warm Dark Matter, potentially solving small-scale structure problems in galaxy formation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This white paper addresses the hypothesis of light sterile neutrinos based on recent anomalies observed in neutrino experiments and the latest astrophysical data.
BibTeX
@misc{abazajian2012light,
  author = {Kevork N. Abazajian and M. A. Acero and Sanjib Kumar Agarwalla and A. A. Aguilar-Arevalo and Carl H. Albright and Stefan Antusch and C. Argüelles and A. B. Balantekin and Gabriela Barenboim and V. Barger and P. Bernardini and Fedor Bezrukov and Ole Eggers Bjælde and S. A. Bogacz and N. S. Bowden and Alexey Boyarsky and A. Bravar and D. Bravo and S. J. Brice and A. D. Bross and B. Caccianiga and F. Cavanna and E. J. Chun and B. T. Cleveland and A. P. Collin and Pilar Coloma and J. M. Conrad and M. Cribier and A. Cucoanes and Juan Carlos D’Olivo and Subinoy Das and André de Gouvêa and A. Derbin and R. Dharmapalan and J. S. Díaz and Xiaoou Ding and Z. Djurcic and A. Donini and D. Duchesneau and H. Ejiri and S. R. Elliott and D. J. Ernst and A. Esmaili and J. J. Evans and E. Fernández-Martínez and E. Figueroa‐Feliciano and B. T. Fleming and J. A. Formaggio and D. Franco and J. Gaffiot and Raj Gandhi and Y. Gao and G. T. Garvey and В. Н. Гаврин and Pomita Ghoshal and D. Gibin and C. Giunti and S. Gninenko and V. V. Gorbachev and Dmitry Gorbunov and R. Guénette and A. Guglielmi and F. Halzen and J. Hamann and Steen Hannestad and W. C. Haxton and K. M. Heeger and R. Henning and Pilar Hernández and Patrick Huber and W. Huelsnitz and Aldo Ianni and Т. В. Ибрагимова and Y. Karadzhov and G. Karagiorgi and G. Keefer and Y. D. Kim and Joachim Kopp and В. Н. Корноухов and Alexander Kusenko and P. Kyberd and Paul Langacker and Th. Lasserre and M. Laveder and A. Letourneau and D. Lhuillier and Yufeng Li and M. Lindner and J. M. Link and B. L. Littlejohn and P. Lombardi and K. Long and J. López-Pavón and W. C. Louis and L. Ludhová and J. Lykken and P. Machado and Michele Maltoni and W. A. Mann and Danny Marfatia},
  title = {{Light Sterile Neutrinos: A White Paper}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1204.5379},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.5379},
}

Loading related content...

Figure