Light NMSSM neutralino dark matter in the wake of CDMS II and a 126 GeV Higgs boson

Jonathan Kozaczuk, Stefano ProfumoPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract Recent results from the CDMS II experiment have sparked interest in light (5–15 GeV) dark matter with a large spin-independent neutralino-nucleon scattering cross-section. While the Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (NMSSM) can theoretically provide such a candidate, the discovery of a 126 GeV Standard Model (SM)-like Higgs boson imposes severe constraints on the available parameter space. This paper examines regions of the NMSSM that accommodate a light neutralino while remaining consistent with LHC results, cosmological data, and flavor physics. We identify two primary scenarios—mediated by light scalars or pseudoscalars—that survive current experimental bounds through specific coupling cancellations or symmetry limits.

Introduction

In the early 2010s, the dark matter community observed potential signals from experiments like CDMS II, suggesting a light Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) with a mass around 10 GeV. Explaining this within the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) is notoriously difficult; light neutralinos in the MSSM typically result in a relic density that over-closes the universe or scattering cross-sections that are far too small to match experimental hints.

The NMSSM offers a solution by adding a singlet field to the MSSM, which introduces additional "singlet-like" Higgs bosons. These extra states can mediate the necessary interactions for light dark matter. However, the discovery of the 126 GeV Higgs boson at the LHC created a new challenge: if these light mediators exist, the 126 GeV Higgs could decay into them, leading to an "invisible width" or exotic decay rates that would deviate from LHC observations. This research investigates whether any viable "loopholes" remain for light NMSSM dark matter.

Methodology

The study employs a scale-invariant NMSSM with $Z_3$ symmetry. The researchers performed systematic numerical scans of the parameter space, focusing on the Higgs sector and dark matter properties. Key technical components included:

  • Higgs Sector Analysis: Diagonalizing $3 \times 3$ CP-even and $2 \times 2$ CP-odd Higgs mass matrices, including one-loop and leading two-loop corrections to ensure an accurate 126 GeV mass for the SM-like state ($h_2$).
  • Dark Matter Calculations: Using micrOmegas and NMSSMTools to compute the spin-independent scattering cross-section ($\sigma_{SI}$) and the thermal relic abundance ($\Omega h^2$).
  • Constraint Mapping: Applying limits from LEP (direct Higgs searches), the Tevatron, the LHC (Higgs signal strengths and invisible width), and flavor physics (rare $B$ and $\Upsilon$ meson decays).

Two Scenarios for Viability

The researchers identified two distinct regions of the NMSSM parameter space that can accommodate light dark matter while satisfying the 126 GeV Higgs constraints.

1. The Light CP-Even Scalar Scenario

In this scenario, the scattering and annihilation are mediated by a very light CP-even scalar ($h_1$). To remain consistent with LHC data, the coupling between the 126 GeV Higgs ($h_2$) and the light mediators ($h_1$) must be suppressed. The authors found that for specific values of the parameter $\kappa$, accidental cancellations occur in the $h_2 h_1 h_1$ and $h_2 \chi \chi$ couplings. This "hides" the light mediators from the LHC by keeping the 126 GeV Higgs's decay properties looking Standard Model-like.

2. The Light Pseudoscalar (PQ Limit) Scenario

This scenario involves a light pseudoscalar mediator ($a_1$) and typically occurs near the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) symmetric limit (where the parameter $\lambda$ is small). In this limit, the couplings between the SM-like Higgs and the light singlet states are naturally small. This softens the constraints from the Higgs's invisible decays without requiring the fine-tuned accidental cancellations seen in the first scenario.

The Role of Flavor Physics

One of the paper's most significant findings is that high-energy collider data is not the only gatekeeper. For very light mediators (masses $< 5$ GeV), the most stringent constraints actually come from rare $B$-meson decays, such as $B \to K \mu^+ \mu^-$. To survive these flavor physics bounds, the light scalar mediator generally needs to be heavier than approximately 4.8 GeV to avoid being produced on-shell in $B$ decays. This effectively sets a lower bound on the mediator mass in these models.

Key Results and Outlook

The study concludes that both scenarios remain viable for neutralino masses in the $m_{\chi} \approx 8–12$ GeV range. These models successfully produce a scattering cross-section of $\sigma_{SI} \sim 10^{-42} – 10^{-41} \text{ cm}^2$, which aligns with the CDMS II "sweet spot," while maintaining a thermal relic abundance consistent with WMAP and Planck data ($\Omega h^2 \approx 0.11$).

However, these regions are in tension with null results from other direct detection experiments like XENON100 and LUX. While astrophysical uncertainties regarding dark matter distribution might alleviate some of this tension, future high-luminosity LHC runs will likely provide the final word. Increased precision in measuring the Higgs boson's total width and invisible branching fractions will either discover these light mediators or close the remaining NMSSM loopholes for light dark matter.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent results from the cryogenic dark matter search experiment have renewed interest in light (5--15 GeV) dark matter with a large spin-independent neutralino-nucleon scattering cross section, ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\mathrm{SI}}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}42}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$. Previous work had suggested that the lightest neutralino in the next-to-MSSM can fall in this mass range and achieve both the correct thermal relic abundance and the desired level for the scattering cross section, provided light Higgs bosons to mediate the pair annihilation and neutralino-nucleon scattering. However, the requirement of a 126 GeV standard model (SM)-like Higgs boson significantly impacts the allowed parameter space. Here, we examine the regions of the NMSSM capable of producing a light neutralino with ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\mathrm{SI}}\ensuremath{\sim}1{0}^{\ensuremath{-}42}--{10}^{\ensuremath{-}41}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$, with the scattering mediated by a very light singlet-like scalar, and a 126 GeV standard model-like Higgs consistent with the LHC results, while satisfying other relevant cosmological, flavor and collider constraints. We focus on two different scenarios for annihilation in the early Universe, namely annihilation mediated by (1) a light scalar or by (2) a light pseudoscalar. As expected, both cases are highly constrained. Nevertheless, we find that there persists potentially viable parameter space to accommodate either scenario. In the first, accidental cancellations in the couplings allow for a SM-like Higgs with a total width and invisible branching fraction compatible with the observed Higgs boson. Alternatively, the second scenario can occur in regions featuring smaller branching fractions of the SM-like Higgs to pairs of light scalars, pseudoscalars, and neutralinos without cancellations. The strongest constraints in both cases come from rare meson decays and exotic decays of the SM-like Higgs boson into neutralinos and light, charge parity even Higgs pairs. We outline the relevant parameter space for both scenarios and comment on prospects for future discovery with various experiments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kozaczuk2014light,
  author = {Jonathan Kozaczuk and Stefano Profumo},
  title = {{Light NMSSM neutralino dark matter in the wake of CDMS II and a 126 GeV Higgs boson}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.89.095012},
}
Figure