Lifelong robot-assisted mobility: models, tools, and challenges

Yiannis Demiris, Tom Carlson2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel approach to lifelong user models for robot-assisted mobility, focusing on adaptive shared control that accounts for users' evolving sensorimotor skills. By predicting user intentions and approximating their "Zone of Proximal Development," the system aims to provide just enough assistance to enable safe and independent mobility, fostering long-term development rather than just task completion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of providing effective and sustainable robot-assisted mobility for individuals with disabilities, particularly those with rapidly changing sensorimotor skills (e.g., young children, individuals undergoing rehabilitation). Current assistive technologies often rely on task-specific, static user models, which fail to adapt to developmental trajectories or fluctuating abilities. This can lead to difficulties in initial control, a lack of long-term skill development, and a failure to fully leverage the potential of powered mobility. The authors highlight that even when powered mobility offers significant benefits, therapists may hesitate to recommend it due to concerns about control and adaptation. Furthermore, the burden on caregivers remains substantial, and existing solutions don't adequately address the long-term impact on user independence and quality of life.

Methods

The core of the proposed approach lies in adaptive shared control and lifelong user models. The system utilizes a generative approach to intention prediction based on the HAMMER (Hierarchical Attentive Multiple Models for Recognition and Execution) architecture. HAMMER employs coupled inverse and forward models:

  • Inverse Models: Map system state and desired goals to control commands.
  • Forward Models: Predict the next system state given the current state and control commands.

This allows the system to infer user intentions by comparing predicted outcomes with actual system behavior.

The paper then introduces the concept of approximating the user's Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD). This is achieved by:

  1. Quantifying Current Performance: The amount and effectiveness of shared control provided are used to annotate the inverse models, indicating the user's current capabilities.
  2. Approximating Potential: The system estimates the level of assistance needed for the user to achieve their intended task, determining if it falls within their ZPD. This involves decomposing the intended task's inverse model into its constituent parts and using heuristics or learned observations to estimate the required combined shared control.

The goal is to provide assistance that is challenging but achievable, promoting learning and development.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lifelong Learning for Assistive Robotics: The critical need to move beyond static user models to dynamic, adaptive models that account for developmental trajectories is emphasized. This is crucial for users whose abilities change over time.
  • Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) in Robotics: Applying Vygotsky's ZPD concept to robot-assisted mobility is a novel idea. It shifts the focus from simply enabling task completion to fostering user growth and independence by providing optimal levels of challenge.
  • Adaptive Shared Control as a Developmental Tool: Shared control isn't just about safety or convenience; it can be a mechanism for skill development. By carefully calibrating assistance, the system can help users overcome challenges and build confidence.
  • Balancing Immediate Needs with Long-Term Goals: The approach aims to strike a balance between ensuring immediate safety and success in mobility tasks and promoting long-term sensorimotor and social development.

Key Results

The paper presents a conceptual framework and algorithmic approach rather than specific quantitative results from extensive user studies. The key "results" are the proposed methods and the identification of challenges:

  • The HAMMER architecture is presented as a robust framework for intention prediction.
  • The ZPD approximation algorithm (ZPD-AA1) is outlined as a method for determining appropriate levels of shared control.
  • The paper highlights the potential for adaptive shared control to improve user performance and facilitate socio-cognitive development.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Determining Appropriate Levels of Shared Control: The authors acknowledge that determining the precise levels of shared control that balance immediate needs with long-term development is a significant challenge.
  • Continuous Measurement of Sensorimotor Activity: Principled methods for continuously measuring users' situated sensorimotor activity and approximating their capabilities are still in their infancy and require further research.
  • User-Defined vs. Situation-Dependent Assistance: Future work will explore different modes of assistance, including user-defined levels, situation-dependent adjustments (considering emotional state and context), and disability-specific training needs.
  • Practitioner-Defined Schedules: Integrating practitioner expertise into adaptive control schedules is also a direction for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing the autonomy of users with disabilities through robot-assisted mobility has the potential of facilitating their sensorimotor and social development, as well as reducing the burden of caring for such populations in both inpatient and outpatient settings. While techniques for task-specific assistance exist, they are largely focused on satisfying short- term goals, utilising stationary user models. For lifelong users and particularly for those with rapidly changing sensorimotor skills (for example very young children), adaptive models that take into consideration these developmental trajectories are becoming very important. In this paper, we present our approach to lifelong user models for robot-assisted mobility, and discuss existing models and tools, as well as challenges that remain ahead. (4 pages)
BibTeX
@misc{demiris2009lifelong,
  author = {Yiannis Demiris and Tom Carlson},
  title = {{Lifelong robot-assisted mobility: models, tools, and challenges}},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1049/ic.2009.0037},
}
Figure