Li 4.3 AlS 3.3 Cl 0.7 : A Sulfide–Chloride Lithium Ion Conductor with Highly Disordered Structure and Increased Conductivity

Jacinthe Gamon, Matthew S. Dyer, Benjamin B. Duff, Andrij Vasylenko, Luke M. Daniels, Marco Zanella, Michael W. Gaultois, Frédéric Blanc, John B. Claridge, Matthew J. RosseinskyChemistry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have synthesized a new sulfide-chloride lithium ion conductor, Li₄.₃AlS₃.₃Cl₀.₇, which exhibits a highly disordered structure and a conductivity increase of three orders of magnitude compared to its pure sulfide counterparts. This discovery highlights the potential of mixed-anion materials and disordered structures for developing next-generation solid-state electrolytes for batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quest for safer and more efficient lithium-ion batteries hinges on the development of solid-state electrolytes (SSEs) that can overcome the limitations of liquid electrolytes, such as flammability. While significant progress has been made in achieving high ionic conductivity in SSEs, challenges remain in balancing conductivity with electrochemical stability and cost-effectiveness. Specifically, pure sulfide SSEs, despite their high conductivity, can suffer from poor stability. Mixed-anion strategies, where different anions are incorporated into the material, offer a promising avenue to tune properties. This paper addresses the need to explore novel mixed-anion materials, focusing on the Li-Al-S system, to achieve improved lithium ion conductivity by leveraging structural disorder.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining synthesis, advanced characterization, and theoretical modeling:

  • Solid-State Synthesis: A new lithium aluminum sulfide-chloride phase was synthesized through high-temperature solid-state reactions.
  • Elemental Analysis: Inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry (ICP-AES) and ion chromatography were used to confirm the elemental composition.
  • X-ray and Neutron Diffraction: Synchrotron X-ray diffraction (SXRD) and time-of-flight neutron powder diffraction (NPD) were crucial for determining the crystal structure, particularly the distribution of cations and anions.
  • Rietveld Refinement: This technique was used to refine structural models against the diffraction data, allowing for the determination of atomic positions, site occupancies, and displacement parameters.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Used to probe vibrational modes and understand the nature of chemical bonds within the material.
  • Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy: ¹Li and ²⁷Al Magic Angle Spinning (MAS) NMR, including ²⁷Al Triple Quantum Magic-Angle Spinning (MQMAS), provided insights into the local environment and mobility of Li and Al ions.
  • Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD): Used to simulate the dynamic behavior of Li ions at the atomic level, revealing diffusion pathways and mechanisms.
  • Maximum Entropy Method (MEM): Applied to neutron diffraction data to reconstruct nuclear density maps, providing experimental visualization of diffusion pathways.
  • Thermodynamic Phase Stability Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used to calculate Gibbs free energies of ordered and disordered structures, assessing thermodynamic stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of a novel material.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anion Substitution Drives Disorder: Replacing sulfur with chloride in Li-Al-S compounds leads to the stabilization of a higher symmetry phase with significant disorder in both the anion sublattice (S/Cl mixing) and the cation sublattice (Li/Al mixing, disordered vacancies).
  • Disorder is Thermodynamically Favored: The introduction of chloride ions thermodynamically stabilizes the disordered structure, making it energetically favorable at relevant temperatures, unlike in the pure sulfide phases.
  • 3D Diffusion Pathways Emerge from Disorder: The combined experimental (MEM) and theoretical (AIMD) evidence strongly suggests that the high degree of structural disorder facilitates three-dimensional (3D) lithium ion diffusion pathways, moving beyond the more restricted 2D pathways observed in ordered sulfide analogues.
  • Concerted Ion Migration: The diffusion mechanism in the disordered phase involves a "concerted" movement of multiple Li ions, where the movement of one ion triggers the movement of others, a mechanism linked to fast ionic conductivity.
  • Structure-Property Relationship Established: The study successfully links the observed structural disorder to enhanced ionic conductivity, providing a clear understanding of how to design future high-performance SSEs.

Key Results

  • Discovery of a Novel Phase: A new lithium aluminum sulfide-chloride phase, Li₄.₃AlS₃.₃Cl₀.₇, was successfully synthesized and characterized.
  • Significant Conductivity Increase: The ionic conductivity of Li₄.₃AlS₃.₃Cl₀.₇ was found to be approximately 10³ times higher than that of the parent pure sulfide phases (Li₃AlS₃ and Li₅AlS₄).
  • Moderate Conductivity Achieved: The room temperature conductivity reached ~10⁻⁶ S·cm⁻¹, which, while moderate, represents a significant improvement and is comparable to other promising SSEs.
  • Activation Energy Reduction: The activation energy for Li⁺ conduction decreased from ~0.48-0.61 eV in pure sulfides to ~0.33-0.35 eV in the mixed-anion compound.
  • Experimental and Theoretical Diffusion Pathway Agreement: AIMD simulations and MEM analysis of neutron diffraction data showed remarkable agreement in identifying the Li⁺ diffusion pathways, validating both techniques.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Moderate Conductivity: While a significant improvement, the conductivity of ~10⁻⁶ S·cm⁻¹ is still below the target of 10⁻³ S·cm⁻¹ for practical battery applications.
  • Electrode Interface Issues: The sintering process led to a surface reduction, impacting the electrode response in AC impedance measurements, suggesting a need for optimization of processing.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further exploration of mixed-anion materials by incorporating more polarizable anions (e.g., Br⁻, I⁻) or heterovalent doping on cationic sites to further increase Li bond covalency and potentially achieve higher conductivity. They also emphasize the importance of maintaining the high degree of atomic disorder for enabling 3D conductivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mixed anion materials and anion doping are very promising strategies to improve solid-state electrolyte properties by enabling an optimized balance between good electrochemical stability and high ionic conductivity. In this work, we present the discovery of a novel lithium aluminum sulfide-chloride phase, obtained by substitution of chloride for sulfur in Li<sub>3</sub>AlS<sub>3</sub> and Li<sub>5</sub>AlS<sub>4</sub> materials. The structure is strongly affected by the presence of chloride anions on the sulfur site, as the substitution was shown to be directly responsible for the stabilization of a higher symmetry phase presenting a large degree of cationic site disorder, as well as disordered octahedral lithium vacancies. The effect of disorder on the lithium conductivity properties was assessed by a combined experimental-theoretical approach. In particular, the conductivity is increased by a factor 10<sup>3</sup> compared to the pure sulfide phase. Although it remains moderate (10<sup>-6</sup> S·cm<sup>-1</sup>), ab initio molecular dynamics and maximum entropy (applied to neutron diffraction data) methods show that disorder leads to a 3D diffusion pathway, where Li atoms move thanks to a concerted mechanism. An understanding of the structure-property relationships is developed to determine the limiting factor governing lithium ion conductivity. This analysis, added to the strong step forward obtained in the determination of the dimensionality of diffusion, paves the way for accessing even higher conductivity in materials comprising an <i>hcp</i> anion arrangement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gamon2021li,
  author = {Jacinthe Gamon and Matthew S. Dyer and Benjamin B. Duff and Andrij Vasylenko and Luke M. Daniels and Marco Zanella and Michael W. Gaultois and Frédéric Blanc and John B. Claridge and Matthew J. Rosseinsky},
  title = {{Li <sub>4.3</sub> AlS <sub>3.3</sub> Cl <sub>0.7</sub> : A Sulfide–Chloride Lithium Ion Conductor with Highly Disordered Structure and Increased Conductivity}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.chemmater.1c02751},
}
Figure