LHC Shines on Positivity

Zhen Liu, Kun-Feng Lyu, Tong Arthur WuChinese Physics C 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) can effectively test fundamental "positivity bounds" on new physics interactions involving diphoton production. By analyzing the distribution of these photon pairs, the LHC can constrain the strength of dimension-8 operators, probing physics up to multi-TeV scales, which is crucial for validating core principles of quantum field theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantum field theories, when describing interactions, must adhere to certain fundamental principles like unitarity, causality, and locality. These principles impose constraints on the possible values of coefficients (Wilson coefficients) in effective field theories (EFTs) that describe physics beyond the Standard Model. These constraints, known as "positivity bounds," become particularly interesting and non-trivial for higher-dimensional operators, starting at dimension-8. Testing these bounds experimentally is a powerful way to search for new physics and verify the consistency of our theoretical frameworks. However, experimentally probing these dimension-8 operators is challenging because their effects are often masked by larger contributions from lower-dimensional operators (like dimension-6). This paper addresses the challenge of isolating and testing these dimension-8 operators, specifically those contributing to diphoton production at hadron colliders, and shows how the LHC can provide a clean window into these fundamental constraints.

Methods

The authors employ an effective field theory (EFT) approach to describe potential new physics beyond the Standard Model. They focus on dimension-8 operators that couple two photons to either quark-antiquark pairs or gluon-gluon pairs. The key insight is that due to helicity selection rules, dimension-6 operators that modify quark-photon couplings either don't contribute to diphoton production or are already highly constrained by other experiments. This leaves dimension-8 operators as the leading new physics contributions.

The paper derives the relevant helicity amplitudes for these dimension-8 operators. They then use these amplitudes to calculate the differential cross-sections for diphoton production. To assess the experimental reach, they perform a $\chi^2$ analysis on simulated data, focusing on the interference term between the Standard Model background and the new physics signal. This interference term is linear in the dimension-8 Wilson coefficients, making it the most sensitive probe. They consider both quark-initiated ($q\bar{q} \to \gamma\gamma$) and gluon-initiated ($gg \to \gamma\gamma$) processes, noting that while the latter is loop-suppressed in the Standard Model, the interference with dimension-8 operators can be significant due to the abundance of gluons at high energies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The analysis relies on simulated data generated using theoretical calculations and standard tools for particle physics simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diphoton production as a clean probe: The diphoton final state is identified as a particularly clean channel for testing dimension-8 operators because dimension-6 contributions are either absent or heavily constrained, allowing the focus to remain on higher-order effects.
  • Positivity bounds as a fundamental test: The paper emphasizes that testing positivity bounds is not just about finding new physics, but about verifying the very foundations of quantum field theory. Violations would signal a breakdown of these fundamental principles.
  • LHC's reach into the multi-TeV scale: The study demonstrates that current and future LHC runs have a significant reach to probe the effective scale associated with these dimension-8 operators, extending into the multi-TeV range.
  • Complementarity of quark and gluon channels: Both quark-initiated and gluon-initiated diphoton production are shown to be sensitive to different sets of dimension-8 operators, providing complementary information.
  • Correlation analysis for Wilson coefficients: The paper illustrates how the diphoton channel can be used not only to test positivity bounds but also to constrain combinations of Wilson coefficients, potentially leading to stronger bounds when combined with positivity constraints.

Key Results

The study projects the sensitivity of the LHC to the effective scale ($\Lambda$) of dimension-8 operators, assuming dimensionless couplings ($C=1$).

  • HL-LHC (14 TeV): The projected 95% confidence level (C.L.) reach for the effective scale is approximately 2 TeV when considering all operators simultaneously. For individual operators, the reach can extend to 3-5 TeV.
  • Future 100 TeV Collider: For a future 100 TeV proton-proton collider, the projected reach extends to over 5 TeV when considering all operators simultaneously. For individual operators, the reach can extend to 7-20 TeV.

These results provide a powerful test of positivity bounds up to multi-TeV scales, offering a unique window into fundamental physics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Precision QCD Improvements: The authors mention that they leave the precise inclusion of higher-order QCD corrections for future work, focusing on the interference term for clarity.
  • Theoretical Uncertainties: While they vary the renormalization and factorization scales to estimate theoretical uncertainty, a more detailed study of these uncertainties could be beneficial.
  • Individual Operator Constraints: While the paper presents projections for individual operators, the primary focus is on the combined reach and the impact of positivity bounds. Further detailed analysis of individual operator sensitivities could be explored.

The authors suggest that this work provides a strong foundation for future experimental searches and theoretical investigations into the implications of positivity bounds at high-energy colliders.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We show that hadron colliders have an excellent reach for positivity tests on a class of diphoton operators. Due to the helicity selection rules, the relevant dimension-6 operators either do not contribute or are highly constrained by other experimental observables. Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI. Article funded by SCOAP3 and published under licence by Chinese Physical Society and the Institute of High Energy Physics of the Chinese Academy of Science and the Institute of Modern Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and IOP Publishing Ltd.
We show, for the first time, that the LHC can probe the positivity of the dimension-8 operators involving colored particles, with contributions from both quarks and gluons. The kinematic differential distributions of the diphoton final states are exploited to perform the $\chi^2$ analysis. Through a global fit, the effective scale for these operators can be inclusively probed up to around 2 TeV at HL-LHC and over 5 TeV at future 100 TeV FCC-hh at 95% C.L., providing a powerful test of the positivity bounds up to multi-TeV scale.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2026lhc,
  author = {Zhen Liu and Kun-Feng Lyu and Tong Arthur Wu},
  title = {{LHC Shines on Positivity}},
  booktitle = {Chinese Physics C},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1137/ae74be},
}
Figure