Leveraging Software, Advocating Ideology: Free Software and Open Source

Matt RattoarXiv 2001 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper argues that software, beyond its functional aspects, is a powerful tool for articulating and defending social and economic ideologies. By examining Linux, the author demonstrates how code, behavior, and structure are "doubly expressive," not only organizing relationships but also serving as arguments in broader societal debates. This perspective is crucial for understanding how software "governs" and how we can govern software.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding how software, particularly in the context of governance and social meaning, operates beyond its purely functional or technical aspects. Traditional legal scholarship often struggles to categorize software, oscillating between viewing it as "text" or "machine," "expressive" or "functional." This binary thinking hinders a deeper understanding of how software influences and reflects social realities. The author posits that this dichotomy is problematic and that a more nuanced approach is needed to grasp how software's technical characteristics are leveraged to articulate and defend ideas, thereby becoming socially meaningful.

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative, analytical approach, focusing on the case study of the Linux operating system. It draws heavily on legal scholarship, Science, Technology, and Society (STS) studies, and the discourse surrounding Free Software and Open Source movements. The author analyzes:

  • Source code: Examining comments within code and how it expresses programming methods and debates.
  • Program behavior: How software affords certain uses and constrains user actions, thereby communicating relationships between users and tasks.
  • Code structure: How the organization of code (e.g., modularity, licensing) reflects and organizes relationships between programmers and influences development processes.

The author also analyzes discursive practices, such as speeches and writings, that leverage these technical aspects to articulate and defend ideological positions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Software as Argument: Software is not merely a tool but an active participant in argumentation, used to articulate and defend social and economic positions.
  • "Doubly Expressive" Nature: Software's functionality is "doubly expressive." It first authorizes specific relationships (programmer-user, programmer-programmer) and then provides examples that can be used to articulate and defend these relationships in broader discourse.
  • Critique of Dichotomy: The paper challenges the strict separation between "functional" and "expressive" aspects of software, arguing that these are often intertwined and used strategically.
  • Linux as a Microcosm: Linux serves as an excellent case study because its development is public, allowing for the analysis of how technical decisions and discursive arguments about it are intertwined.
  • Social Construction of Technology: Technical decisions in software development are not purely rational but are influenced by social factors, desires, and ideological stances.
  • "De-commoditizing Protocols": Microsoft's strategy to extend proprietary control by slightly altering standard protocols is presented as a clandestine form of its discursive strategy to label Linux as "viral software," both aimed at extending market dominance.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results but rather offers a conceptual framework for understanding software's social and ideological dimensions. The key "results" are the insights derived from the analysis of Linux and the surrounding discourse, which demonstrate:

  • How Richard Stallman (Free Software) and Eric Raymond (Open Source) use arguments about Linux's development and licensing to defend their respective ideologies, focusing on freedom and ownership versus development speed and efficiency.
  • How Microsoft's strategic use of language ("viral software") and technical maneuvers ("de-commoditizing protocols") aims to delegitimize open-source alternatives and maintain market control.
  • The paper establishes that understanding software's functionality is essential for understanding how it "governs" and how we can govern software itself.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The author acknowledges that technical requirements sometimes drive technical decisions, and the analysis does not claim to segregate all such processes from social analysis. The paper also notes that analyzing relationships can be futile if done apart from the software's actual use by communities.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that understanding how software "governs" is a necessary corollary to understanding how to govern software. This implies a need for continued analysis of software's role in policy-making and societal organization. The author also hints at the difficulty of analyzing seemingly pragmatic software like Microsoft Excel, suggesting that such analyses, while challenging, are important.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ratto2001leveraging,
  author = {Matt Ratto},
  title = {{Leveraging Software, Advocating Ideology: Free Software and Open Source}},
  year = {2001},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=5OSerZmJXv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure