Leveraging ecosystems responses to enhanced rock weathering in mitigation scenarios

Yann Gaucher, Katsumasa Tanaka, Daniel Johansson, Daniel S. Goll, Philippe CiaisNature Communications 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Enhanced rock weathering (EW) could significantly boost carbon dioxide removal (CDR) efforts, especially when applied to forests, potentially tripling sequestration compared to croplands alone. This approach not only reduces the cost of meeting Paris Agreement climate targets but also lessens our reliance on bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS), offering a more sustainable CDR portfolio.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Paris Agreement's ambitious climate goals (limiting warming to 1.5°C or 2°C) necessitate rapid emissions reductions and substantial carbon dioxide removal (CDR). While BECCS has been a primary focus for CDR, concerns about its technical feasibility, land use, and sustainability at scale have prompted a search for alternatives. Enhanced rock weathering (EW), the process of spreading finely ground silicate rocks like basalt on land to accelerate natural weathering and sequester CO2, is emerging as a promising option. However, previous assessments have largely focused on the "geochemical" CDR from mineral dissolution and often overlooked the "biotic" CDR potential from enhanced ecosystem growth due to nutrient release (specifically phosphorus from basalt). This paper aims to quantify the role of EW, including both geochemical and biotic components, within integrated climate-energy-economy models for cost-effective mitigation pathways.

Methods

The study employs a sophisticated integrated model called GET-ACC2, which couples an energy-economy model (GET7.1) with a carbon cycle, atmospheric chemistry, and climate model (ACC2). A key innovation is the inclusion of a dedicated EW module. This module simulates:

  • Geochemical CDR: Direct CO2 capture from basalt weathering.
  • Biotic CDR: Enhanced ecosystem growth and carbon storage stimulated by phosphorus released from basalt. This biotic component is quantified using an emulator of the ORCHIDEE-CNP biosphere model, which accounts for nutrient limitations on plant growth.

The model optimizes least-cost pathways to achieve specific temperature targets (1.5°C and 2°C, with various overshoot scenarios) by considering various CDR options, including BECCS and EW. The analysis explores different application scenarios for EW: BECCS only, BECCS with EW on croplands only (EW on CL), and BECCS with EW on both croplands and forests (EW on CL + FA).

Datasets

The study utilizes existing datasets and models for its simulations:

  • ORCHIDEE-CNP model: Used to simulate the response of Net Primary Production (NPP) to phosphorus fertilization, providing data for the biotic CDR component.
  • Existing literature and databases: Information on basalt properties, weathering rates, application costs, energy requirements for mining, grinding, transport, and spreading, as well as climate model parameters (e.g., equilibrium climate sensitivity) were drawn from previous research and publicly available data.
  • SSP2 baseline: Used for energy demand projections.
  • SSP1-1.9 and SSP1-2.6 scenarios: Used for exogenous non-energy-related CO2 emissions and other greenhouse gas emissions.

No new datasets were explicitly introduced or benchmarked in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Forests are key for EW's biotic potential: Applying basalt to forests, despite higher application costs (due to airborne spreading), can triple the carbon sequestration potential of EW compared to croplands alone. This is primarily driven by the significant biotic CDR effect in forest ecosystems, where phosphorus release stimulates biomass growth over decades.
  • EW as a cost-reducer and BECCS reliever: Incorporating EW into mitigation portfolios significantly reduces the overall cost of achieving climate targets, especially in high-overshoot scenarios. It also decreases the reliance on BECCS, mitigating concerns about its sustainability and land-use impacts.
  • Overshoot scenarios favor EW: EW is more heavily utilized in scenarios with higher temperature overshoots. This is because the model's "perfect foresight" optimization allows for delayed abatement and greater reliance on negative emissions in the future when overshoot is permitted, making the long-term benefits of EW more attractive.
  • Weathering rate is a critical uncertainty: The study highlights that weathering rates are a major source of uncertainty. While the model uses a median rate of 13% per year, lower rates (below 1%) could significantly diminish EW's effectiveness, particularly its geochemical component, making it viable mainly in natural areas where phosphorus is scarce.
  • EW is not a "silver bullet" for immediate warming reduction: While EW helps achieve long-term climate goals, it doesn't significantly alter peak warming levels in the near term, especially in high-overshoot scenarios. Its primary role is in cost-effective long-term carbon removal.

Key Results

  • Tripled CDR with forest application: Applying EW to both croplands and forests can triple the EW-induced CDR compared to croplands alone, reaching a peak of 12.4 GtCO2 per year and 446 GtCO2 cumulatively in the 1.5°C high overshoot scenario.
  • Reduced policy costs: EW deployment on croplands and forests can reduce policy costs by up to 44% in the 1.5°C high overshoot scenario.
  • Lower carbon prices: EW application reduces the carbon price by an average of 67% in the 1.5°C high overshoot scenario when applied to both croplands and forests.
  • Reduced BECCS reliance: EW partially replaces BECCS, with the reduction being more pronounced in medium or no-overshoot scenarios.
  • Energy intensity: EW's energy intensity per ton of CO2 sequestered varies, generally being lower than direct air capture, but can increase with transport distances for croplands and due to saturation of the biotic effect in forests.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weathering rate uncertainty: The study acknowledges that weathering rates are highly uncertain and can vary significantly based on soil conditions, temperature, and biological activity. Field testing is crucial for better understanding these rates.
  • Side effects of basalt: The model does not fully capture potential negative side effects of basalt application, such as impacts on soil microbes, soil biota, human health (e.g., silicosis from dust), ecosystems, or riverine chemistry. Further research and field testing are needed to assess these.
  • Local factors and scalability: The global assessment does not account for local factors like regulatory frameworks, socio-cultural barriers, or specific geological conditions that could constrain EW's real-world efficiency and scalability.
  • MRV costs: The cost of monitoring, reporting, and verification (MRV) for EW is not fully integrated, which could increase marginal costs.
  • Future work: The authors emphasize the need for improved knowledge of weathering rates and basalt side-effects through field testing. Further research should also explore the potential for EW to mitigate near-term climate damage through cost-benefit analyses that consider its role alongside other mitigation strategies. Investigating the impact of different basalt types and application methods is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) is deemed necessary to attain the Paris Agreement's climate objectives. While bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) has generated substantial attention, sustainability concerns have led to increased examination of alternative strategies, including enhanced rock weathering (EW). We analyse the role of EW under cost-effective mitigation pathways, by including the CDR potential of basalt applications from silicate weathering (geochemical CDR) and enhanced ecosystem growth and carbon storage in response to phosphorus released by basalt (biotic CDR). Using an integrated carbon cycle, climate and energy system model, we show that the application of basalt to forests could triple the level of carbon sequestration induced by EW compared to an application restricted to croplands. EW also reduces the costs of achieving the Paris Agreement targets as well as the reliance on BECCS. Further understanding requires improved knowledge of weathering rates and basalt side-effects through field testing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gaucher2025leveraging,
  author = {Yann Gaucher and Katsumasa Tanaka and Daniel Johansson and Daniel S. Goll and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{Leveraging ecosystems responses to enhanced rock weathering in mitigation scenarios}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-58284-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure