Levelised Cost of Demand Response: Estimating the Cost-Competitiveness of Flexible Demand

Jacob Thrän, Tim C. Green, Robert ShortenarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

As the global energy transition accelerates, the need for grid flexibility has become paramount. While traditional energy storage solutions like lithium-ion batteries are often the default choice, Demand Response (DR)—the strategic shifting of consumer energy usage—offers a potentially lower-cost alternative. This paper introduces the Levelised Cost of Demand Response (LCODR), a novel metric that enables a direct economic comparison between DR schemes and traditional storage. By accounting for unique DR costs such as consumer rewards and rebound effects, the research identifies heat pumps paired with thermal storage as a uniquely competitive solution for modern grid management.

Introduction: The Flexibility Gap

Renewable energy sources like wind and solar require a flexible grid that can balance supply and demand in real-time. While large-scale batteries are effective, they are capital-intensive. Demand Response (DR) leverages existing consumer infrastructure (like electric vehicles and heating systems) to provide this flexibility. However, until now, there has been no standardized way to compare the cost of a smart EV charger to a grid-scale battery. Traditional metrics like the Levelised Cost of Storage (LCOS) fail to capture the human and behavioral costs inherent in DR.

Methodology: The LCODR Framework

The researchers developed the LCODR framework to calculate the lifetime cost per unit of shifted energy ($/MWh). Unlike traditional storage metrics, LCODR integrates several novel components:

  • Consumer Reward Integration: Using "Willingness-to-Accept" (WTA) data, the model prices the inconvenience or discomfort consumers experience when allowing external control of their devices as a literal financial cost.
  • The Value Factor (VF): This accounts for the availability of the DR resource. For instance, an EV can only provide grid services when plugged in; the VF adjusts the cost based on how well this availability aligns with high-value grid periods.
  • Rebound Effects: The model accounts for the energy required to "catch up" after a DR event, such as reheating a home after a period of reduced power.
The LCODR estimation formula incorporating investment, O&M, rebound costs, and consumer rewards.

Case Study: The Great Britain Electricity System

The framework was applied to a case study of the UK grid, modeling four specific schemes: Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G), Smart Charging, Smart Heat Pumps (temperature adjustment), and Heat Pumps paired with Thermal Storage (hot water tanks). The analysis utilized techno-economic data from UK industry reports and consumer behavior data from discrete-choice experiments.

Results and Discussion

The study revealed that for most DR schemes, the primary cost is not the hardware, but the consumer rewards. These payments often dwarf equipment costs, making human behavior the most significant economic variable in demand-side flexibility.

Overview of demand response schemes and their levelised cost comparison across grid applications.

The Thermal Storage Advantage

Heat pumps with thermal storage emerged as the clear economic winner. Because hot water tanks allow for energy shifting without impacting consumer comfort or requiring behavioral changes, the necessary reward payments are minimal. This scheme was the only one to consistently outperform traditional storage technologies across nearly all 12 studied grid applications, including energy arbitrage and frequency response.

EV Schemes and Niche Applications

EV-based schemes like V2G and Smart Charging were found to be highly competitive for "high-intensity" applications that require frequent activations, such as bill management or congestion management. However, they struggle to compete with batteries for long-duration needs like seasonal storage due to the strict "rebound" constraints of vehicle owners needing their cars charged by a specific time.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The LCODR metric provides a vital tool for policymakers and grid operators to evaluate the true cost of demand-side flexibility. While heat pumps with thermal storage represent a "low-hanging fruit" for grid decarbonization, other DR schemes remain niche due to high consumer reward requirements. Future research will focus on incorporating the lower carbon footprint of DR compared to battery manufacturing, which may further improve the economic outlook for flexible demand.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{thran2025levelised,
  author = {Jacob Thrän and Tim C. Green and Robert Shorten},
  title = {{Levelised Cost of Demand Response: Estimating the Cost-Competitiveness of Flexible Demand}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.03124},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.03124},
}
Figure