Lethal Concentration and Sporulation by Contact and Direct Spray of the Entomopathogenic Fungus Beauveria bassiana on Different Stages of Nezara viridula (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae)

Maribel Portilla, Min-Ling Zhang, James P. Glover, Gadi V. P. Reddy, Chris A. JohnsonJournal of Fungi 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of the entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana against the southern green stink bug, Nezara viridula, across different life stages. The findings reveal that direct spraying of the fungus is more lethal than contact exposure, and younger nymphal stages are significantly more susceptible than adults, offering potential for integrated pest management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The southern green stink bug (Nezara viridula) is a major agricultural pest, particularly in soybean and cotton production, causing significant economic losses worldwide. Current control methods heavily rely on chemical insecticides, which raise concerns about resistance development, environmental impact, and human health. While entomopathogenic fungi like Beauveria bassiana offer a promising biological control alternative, their efficacy against N. viridula has been inconsistent, partly due to the insect's natural resistance mechanisms and the influence of environmental factors. This paper aims to systematically evaluate the lethal concentration and sporulation potential of B. bassiana on various life stages of N. viridula under controlled conditions, comparing two application methods (contact and direct spray) to better understand its potential as a biocontrol agent.

Methods

The researchers conducted bioassays using a native strain of Beauveria bassiana (Delta native strain NI8) against different life stages of Nezara viridula, including 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th instar nymphs, as well as adult insects. Two primary infection methods were employed:

  • Contact Exposure (Treated Diet): Insects were placed on an artificial diet that had been sprayed with varying concentrations of B. bassiana conidia. This method assesses the fungus's ability to infect insects that come into contact with contaminated surfaces.
  • Direct Spray: Insects were directly sprayed with B. bassiana conidia suspensions. This method simulates a more direct application of the biopesticide.

For each method, insects were exposed to a water control and four different concentrations of the fungal suspension. The study meticulously recorded survival, mortality, and molting percentages over a 10-day period. Statistical analyses, including ANOVA, Tukey's HSD test, and Probit analysis, were used to determine median lethal concentrations (LC50), median lethal sporulation (LS50), and resistance ratios (RR50). Correlations between mortality, sporulation, and molting were also analyzed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized laboratory-reared colonies of Nezara viridula and a specific strain of Beauveria bassiana (Delta native strain NI8) obtained from the USDA-ARS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct Spray Superiority: Direct spraying of B. bassiana proved to be a more effective method for reducing insect survival across all life stages compared to contact exposure. This suggests that a direct application is crucial for maximizing the immediate impact of the fungus.
  • Nymphal Susceptibility: Younger nymphal instars (particularly the 4th instar) were significantly more susceptible to B. bassiana infection than older nymphs and adults. This highlights a critical window for intervention when the insects are in their more vulnerable developmental stages.
  • Adult Resistance: Adult N. viridula exhibited considerable resistance to B. bassiana, requiring much higher concentrations for lethal effects. This aligns with previous research suggesting that adult insect cuticles can present a barrier to fungal infection.
  • Sporulation vs. Mortality: While mortality and sporulation were positively correlated with fungal concentration, sporulation levels were generally lower than mortality rates. This indicates that the fungus can kill the insect before extensive sporulation occurs, which is a desirable trait for a biopesticide.
  • Molting Variability: Molting percentage showed high variability and a weak negative correlation with fungal concentration, especially in directly sprayed insects. This suggests that the molting process itself might not be a primary target or significantly impacted by the fungus in a predictable manner across all concentrations and methods.

Key Results

  • Lethal Concentrations (LC50): Adults were the most resistant, with LC50 values of 612 spores/mm² for contact and 179 spores/mm² for direct spray. The 4th instar was the most susceptible, with LC50 values of 18 spores/mm² (contact) and 23 spores/mm² (direct spray).
  • Lethal Sporulation (LS50): Adults also showed high resistance for sporulation, with LS50 values of 1960 spores/mm² (contact) and a remarkably high 3.3 × 10⁶ spores/mm² (direct spray). The 4th instar was again most susceptible, with LS50 values of 53 spores/mm² (contact) and 26 spores/mm² (direct spray).
  • Mortality Rates: Direct spray resulted in higher mortality across all life stages. For instance, at the highest concentration (7 × 10⁷ spores/mm²), direct spray achieved 100% mortality in 2nd and 3rd instars, while adults showed around 60% mortality.
  • Resistance Ratio (RR50): Adults were found to be significantly more resistant than younger instars, with RR50 values indicating a substantial increase in the concentration needed to achieve the same lethal effect.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Laboratory Conditions: The study was conducted under controlled laboratory conditions. The efficacy of B. bassiana in the field may be influenced by environmental factors such as temperature, humidity, and UV radiation, which were not simulated.
  • Adult Tolerance: The high tolerance of adult N. viridula to B. bassiana remains a challenge for complete control. Future research could explore combinations of B. bassiana with other control agents or investigate factors that might enhance its efficacy against adults.
  • Environmental Factors: The paper acknowledges that environmental conditions significantly impact fungal efficacy. Further research could focus on optimizing application timing and conditions to maximize B. bassiana's effectiveness in the field.
  • Fecundity Impact: While not the primary focus, the paper briefly mentions that B. bassiana strains can affect the fecundity of N. viridula. Future work could delve deeper into the sub-lethal effects of the fungus on insect reproduction and behavior.
  • Integrated Pest Management (IPM): The authors emphasize that B. bassiana should be considered as part of a broader IPM strategy, rather than a standalone solution. Future research should focus on how to best integrate this biopesticide into existing pest management programs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The southern green stink bug, <i>Nezara viridula</i> (L.) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae) is the most significant pest of soybean worldwide. The present study was conducted to compare the effectiveness of a Delta native strain NI8 of <i>Beauveria bassiana</i> by contact and direct spray on nymphs (2nd to 5th instar) and adults of <i>N. viridula</i>. Water control and four concentrations of <i>B. bassiana</i> were used to evaluate the survival, mortality, and molting percentage and to estimate median lethal concentration (LC<sub>50</sub>), median lethal sporulation (LS<sub>50</sub>), and resistance ratio (RR<sub>50</sub>). Direct spray at all concentrations observed the greatest reduction in survival on all life stages. Mortality and sporulation were positively correlated by concentration, while molting was highly variable with a significantly lower negative correlation on insects that were directly sprayed. Pathogenicity exhibited reduction as young stages developed and emerged to adult. The LC<sub>50</sub> (Contact: 612 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>; Direct spray: 179 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>) and LS<sub>50</sub> (Contact: 1960 spores/mm<sup>2</sup> Spray: 3.3 × 10<sup>6</sup>) values showed that adults of <i>N. viridula</i> were highly resistant than any other life stage when exposed to either contact or direct spray. Fourth instar was the most susceptible (LC<sub>50</sub>: Contact: 18 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>; Direct spray: 23 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>) (LS<sub>50</sub>: Contact: 53 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>; Direct spray: 26 spores/mm<sup>2</sup>) followed by second, third, and fifth instars.
BibTeX
@article{portilla2022lethal,
  author = {Maribel Portilla and Min-Ling Zhang and James P. Glover and Gadi V. P. Reddy and Chris A. Johnson},
  title = {{Lethal Concentration and Sporulation by Contact and Direct Spray of the Entomopathogenic Fungus Beauveria bassiana on Different Stages of Nezara viridula (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae)}},
  journal = {Journal of Fungi},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jof8111164},
}
Figure