Lesser suppression of response to bright visual stimuli and visual abnormality in children with autism spectrum disorder: a magnetoencephalographic study

Sho Aoki, Kuriko Kagitani‐Shimono, Junko Matsuzaki, Ryuzo Hanaie, Mariko Nakanishi, Koji Tominaga, Yukie Nagai, Ikuko Mohri, Masako TaniikeJournal of Neurodevelopmental Disorders 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) exhibit altered neural responses to visual stimuli, specifically showing less suppression of brain activity when exposed to bright or complex visual information. This reduced neural suppression is linked to the severity of their visual abnormalities and may be a key mechanism underlying sensory processing differences in ASD, potentially paving the way for improved diagnostic and intervention strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sensory abnormalities, particularly visual ones, are a common and significant feature of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), often contributing to behavioral challenges. While the prevalence of these visual differences is well-documented, the underlying neural mechanisms remain poorly understood. Existing research has explored early visual processing and emotional pathways, but a comprehensive understanding of how the brain handles complex or intense visual input in ASD is lacking. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the neural basis of visual abnormalities in children with ASD using magnetoencephalography (MEG), focusing on how their brains process and suppress responses to varying visual stimuli.

Methods

The study employed magnetoencephalography (MEG) to measure the brain's electrical activity in response to visual stimuli. Participants, including children with ASD and typically developing (TD) children, were presented with three types of images:

  1. Original Image: A standard image of an object (e.g., a toy tree).
  2. Dot Noise Image: The Original image with superimposed bright dots.
  3. Blind Image: The Original image with enhanced brightness.

MEG data were analyzed to assess cortical responses, specifically focusing on:

  • M100 Latency: The time it takes for a specific neural response (M100 peak) to occur in the primary visual cortex.
  • Activated Intensities: The strength of neural activation in various brain regions (Regions of Interest - ROIs) like the pericalcarine cortex, supramarginal gyrus (SMG), middle temporal gyrus (MTG), and medial orbitofrontal cortex (mOFC).
  • Attenuation Ratios: The degree to which neural responses to bright images (Dot noise and Blind) were suppressed compared to the Original image. This was calculated as the ratio of activated intensities for the bright images to the Original image.

Statistical analyses, including ANOVA and correlation analyses, were used to compare groups and examine relationships between neural responses, visual abnormality scores (Sensory Profile - SP), and behavioral problems (Child Behavior Checklist - CBCL).

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it utilized data collected from human participants.

  • Participants: 22 high-functioning children with ASD and 23 age-matched typically developing (TD) children.
  • Behavioral and Sensory Assessments: Data from the Japanese version of the Sensory Profile (SP) to assess visual abnormality severity and the Japanese version of the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) to assess behavioral problems were collected from guardians.
  • Cognitive Assessment: The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Fourth Edition (WSIQ) was used to assess cognitive functioning.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reduced Neural Suppression is Key: The most significant finding is that children with ASD exhibit a reduced ability to suppress neural responses to bright or visually complex stimuli. This "lesser attenuation" suggests a fundamental difference in how their brains filter or down-regulate sensory input.
  • Link to Visual Abnormality: The degree of this reduced neural suppression, particularly in the right supramarginal gyrus (SMG), was directly correlated with the severity of visual abnormalities reported by the children's guardians. This provides a direct neural correlate for subjective visual experiences in ASD.
  • Higher-Order Processing Affected: While early visual processing (primary visual cortex) showed no significant differences between groups, higher-order processing areas like the SMG and MTG showed increased activation in ASD children to the original image and less suppression to bright images. This points to issues in how the brain integrates and modulates visual information beyond the initial sensory input.
  • Potential for Intervention: Understanding this neural mechanism of reduced suppression opens doors for targeted interventions. If the brain struggles to "turn down" overwhelming sensory input, strategies to enhance this suppression could be beneficial.

Key Results

  • Demographics: No significant differences were found between ASD and TD groups in age, sex ratio, or Full-Scale IQ (FSIQ). However, children with ASD showed significantly higher scores on the SP visual item, indicating greater visual abnormality, and higher CBCL total scores, indicating more problematic behaviors.
  • M100 Latencies: No significant differences were observed in M100 latencies in the primary visual cortex between ASD and TD groups for any of the image types, nor were there differences in latency ratios.
  • Activated Intensities (Original Image): Children with ASD showed significantly increased cortical activation in the left supramarginal gyrus (SMG) and bilateral middle temporal gyrus (MTG) in response to the Original image compared to TD children.
  • Attenuation Ratios (Bright Images): Children with ASD showed significantly lesser attenuation of activated intensities in response to bright images (Dot noise and Blind) compared to the Original image, particularly in the right SMG. This means their brains did not "turn down" the response as much as TD children's brains.
  • Correlation: The attenuation ratios in the right SMG were significantly correlated with the severity of visual abnormalities (SP visual item scores) in the ASD group. Specifically, greater visual abnormality was associated with lower attenuation ratios (i.e., less suppression).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study population was relatively small, which may have limited the statistical power to detect inter-group differences, especially after multiple comparison corrections. Larger studies with a wider age range are recommended.
  • Lack of Sex-Related Differences: The study did not examine sex-related differences, which could be important given the skewed sex ratio in ASD and potential differences in sensory experiences between males and females. Future research should consider this.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study was cross-sectional, meaning it captured a single point in time. A longitudinal design is suggested to track changes in visual symptoms and neural activation throughout development, which could provide clearer evidence for intervention strategies.
  • Limited Luminance Contrast: The luminance differences between the "bright" images and the original image were relatively small compared to some previous studies. While this was intended to simulate real-world experiences, it might explain some discrepancies with prior findings on luminance effects.

Future work could focus on exploring the specific neural mechanisms of this reduced suppression, investigating the role of other brain regions, and developing and testing interventions aimed at enhancing neural suppression in children with ASD.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our results show that dysfunction of stimulus-driven neural suppression plays a crucial role in the neural mechanism of visual abnormality in children with ASD. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first magnetoencephalography study to demonstrate the association between the severity of visual abnormality and lower attenuation ratios in children with ASD. Our results contribute to the knowledge of the mechanisms underlying visual abnormality in children with ASD, and may therefore lead to more effective diagnosis and earlier intervention.
BibTeX
@article{aoki2019lesser,
  author = {Sho Aoki and Kuriko Kagitani‐Shimono and Junko Matsuzaki and Ryuzo Hanaie and Mariko Nakanishi and Koji Tominaga and Yukie Nagai and Ikuko Mohri and Masako Taniike},
  title = {{Lesser suppression of response to bright visual stimuli and visual abnormality in children with autism spectrum disorder: a magnetoencephalographic study}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurodevelopmental Disorders},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1186/s11689-019-9266-0},
}
Figure