Abstract
To justify that the bank is the real victim of the credit card fraud cases, this study, from the perspective of the attribute of money, makes it clear that money still has the attribute of “possession is ownership” in the field of property crimes. The money deposited by depositors in the bank is immediately occupied and owned by the bank, and what the thief violates is actually the bank’s property. However, when a fraud case occurs, the bank immediately compensates for its own losses by eliminating the same amount of claims of depositors, and the identity of the bank’s victim is therefore covered up. Theoretically speaking, the legal background of the disputes of credit card fraud cases is the issue of the effectiveness of the debtor’s payment to the quasi-possessor of creditor’s rights in civil law. Under the influence of this theory, we can observe and interpret the common defense reasons in the disputes of credit card fraud cases, in order to benefit the judicial practice.
Introduction
As digital transactions become the backbone of the modern economy, credit card fraud has emerged as a significant challenge to financial security. According to the Blue Book on the Development of China’s Bank Card Industry (2019), out of RMB 822.3 trillion in total transactions, approximately 71.54 billion were identified as fraudulent. Despite the scale of this issue, judicial practice often struggles with a fundamental question: who is the legal victim?
Traditionally, the depositor whose account balance is depleted is viewed as the victim. However, this perspective often leaves individual cardholders in a "passive situation," forced to navigate complex legal hurdles while banks utilize various defenses to avoid liability. This paper argues for a shift in legal interpretation, identifying the bank as the true victim based on the principle of "possession is ownership."
Jurisprudential Framework: "Possession is Ownership"
In property law, money is treated as a unique movable asset. Unlike a specific physical object (like a car or a piece of jewelry), currency is fungible. The core principle governing its legal status is that "possession is ownership."
When a depositor places money into a bank account, the physical currency is transferred to the bank's possession. At that moment, the bank becomes the owner of the money, and the depositor’s property right is transformed into a "claim" or a debt owed by the bank. Therefore, when a fraudster illicitly withdraws funds from an ATM or through an online portal, they are technically stealing the bank’s property. The bank then "covers up" its status as a victim by unilaterally deducting the stolen amount from the depositor’s claim, effectively shifting the loss onto the customer.
The Theory of Quasi-Possession
The legal tension in fraud cases centers on the civil law concept of the "debtor’s satisfaction of the quasi-possessor of the claim." In this context, the bank is the debtor, the depositor is the creditor, and the fraudster is the "quasi-possessor" (someone who appears to hold the right to the claim, often by possessing a card and PIN).
Under this theory, a bank’s payment to a fraudster only extinguishes its debt to the real depositor if the bank acted in "good faith and without negligence." If the bank fails to detect a counterfeit card, it has failed in its duty of care. Because the bank provides the technical infrastructure for the transaction, it is responsible for ensuring that the credentials presented are authentic. If a cloned card is used, the bank has paid the wrong person due to its own technical limitations, and its debt to the original depositor remains valid.
Analysis of Judicial Trends and Bank Defenses
Through the analysis of various Chinese legal precedents—such as the cases of Ms. Hu in Wuhan and the "Cheng" case—several common bank defenses can be evaluated:
- "Criminal Before Civil": Banks often argue that civil claims should be stayed until the criminal perpetrator is caught. However, this paper asserts that the criminal relationship (Bank vs. Thief) and the civil relationship (Bank vs. Depositor) are independent. The bank’s contractual obligation to the depositor exists regardless of whether the thief is apprehended.
- Password Imputability: Banks frequently claim that because a correct PIN was used, the depositor must be at fault. While there is a rebuttable presumption of depositor negligence regarding secret passwords, this does not absolve the bank if the physical card was counterfeit. The bank must prove it maintained a secure system that could distinguish between a legitimate and a cloned card.
Conclusion and Policy Recommendations
Repositioning the bank as the primary victim of credit card fraud aligns with both property law and economic logic. By holding banks liable for fraudulent transactions—except in cases of proven depositor gross negligence—the legal system provides a powerful incentive for financial institutions to invest in superior security technologies, such as transitioning from magnetic stripe cards to more secure chip-based systems. This shift not only protects "relatively weak depositors" but also enhances the overall integrity of the financial ecosystem.
Summary updated