Legacies and impacts of major sporting events for communities and individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds: a systematic review

Xiao Liang, Mary L. Quinton, Jet Veldhuijzen Zanten, Zheng‐Chao Duan, Barnaby N. Zoob Carter, Andrew Heyes, Mark Lee, Abdullah Alharbi, Shushu ChenEquality 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review investigates whether major sporting events—like the Olympics and FIFA World Cups—actually deliver on their promises to revitalize disadvantaged communities. The findings reveal a sobering reality: despite "social inclusion" rhetoric in bid documents, these events predominantly result in negative legacies for marginalized populations, including displacement, gentrification, and the diversion of public funds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Governments often justify the massive costs of hosting mega-sporting events by claiming they act as catalysts for urban renewal and social "leveling up." However, these benefits are rarely distributed equally.

The authors identify a significant "knowledge gap" between the aspirational narratives found in event bid proposals and the actual lived experiences of Communities and Individuals from Disadvantaged Backgrounds (CIDBs). While general event legacies are well-studied, this paper specifically scrutinizes the impact on those at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder—residents of deprived areas, ethnic minorities, and the "socially excluded"—to see if these events exacerbate or alleviate systemic inequality.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines.

  • Search Strategy: They searched four major academic databases (Web of Science, SPORTDiscus, Scopus, and ProQuest – ASSIA) for peer-reviewed articles published between 2000 and 2023.
  • Selection: Out of 1,867 initial records and 95 full-text assessments, only 14 articles met the strict criteria for focusing specifically on CIDBs and event legacies.
  • Analysis: Qualitative studies were synthesized thematically (ENTREQ guidelines), while quantitative data used the SWiM (Synthesis without Meta-analysis) approach. The quality of the included studies was appraised using a modified QATSDD tool, revealing a "moderate" average scholarly quality (53%).

Datasets

As a systematic review, the "dataset" consists of the existing body of peer-reviewed literature. The final sample included 14 studies covering events across Europe (36%), Asia (18%), South America (14%), North America (14%), and Africa (14%). Notable events studied include the Beijing 2008 Olympics, London 2012 Olympics, Rio 2016 Olympics, and various FIFA World Cups (2010, 2014).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Aspirational Gap": Bid documents frequently promise "social inclusion" and "direct benefits" for low-income families, but the review found almost no systematic reporting of these outcomes post-event.
  • Infrastructure as a Weapon: "City regeneration" often functions as a euphemism for gentrification. In Beijing and Rio, the construction of new apartment blocks and stadiums led to the forced eviction and geographical displacement of the poor to less desirable locations.
  • The "Sanitization" of Public Space: To prepare for the "global gaze," host cities often implement restrictive measures, such as removing homeless individuals from public spaces (noted in Vancouver 2010 and London 2012), which further marginalizes vulnerable groups.
  • Organic vs. Directed Impact: Interestingly, "national pride" and "community cohesion" were some of the few positive impacts felt by CIDBs. However, these were often "organic" and fleeting, rather than the result of specific policy interventions.
  • Sport Participation Paradox: While mega-events rarely increase sports participation in the general public, they did show a short-term "demonstration effect" for CIDBs (e.g., interest in BMX after the 2016 World SuperCross). Unfortunately, without sustained funding and facility access, this enthusiasm quickly dissipated.

Key Results

  • Predominantly Negative: 9 out of the 14 reviewed studies reported only negative impacts and legacies. Only 2 reported a mix of positive and negative outcomes.
  • Economic Failure: CIDBs struggle to secure event-related employment. Small local businesses in London’s East End, for example, were often "oblivious" to business opportunities or found them inaccessible due to complex delivery structures.
  • Diverted Resources: In developing nations like India, South Africa, and Brazil, hosting events often forced the diversion of funds away from essential public sectors (healthcare, education) to pay for stadiums, directly harming the interests of the poor.
  • Transportation Inequality: While city-wide transport often improves, local bus routes in deprived areas were sometimes reduced or reorganized to prioritize event traffic, actually decreasing connectivity for low-income residents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The fact that only 14 papers met the criteria over a 23-year period highlights how little research actually focuses on disadvantaged populations.
  • Excluded Groups: This review did not include the disabled population, noting that their specific needs and rights warrant a standalone systematic review.
  • Lack of Longitudinal Data: Most studies are "snapshots." The authors call for long-term research to see if any "positive impacts" (like job creation) actually survive more than a few years.
  • Strategic Leveraging: The paper concludes that hosting an event is "ineffectual" for the poor without strategic leverage—targeted policies designed from the start to ensure equitable distribution of benefits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose The global hosting of major events is garnering increasing attention from governments. As this phenomenon expands into emerging states, where arguably the most severe inequalities exist, the question of who truly benefits from these events has not been systematically scrutinised, particularly from an Equality, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) perspective. Therefore, adopting a nuanced segmentation approach is increasingly vital to assess the diverse impacts of hosting major sporting events on varied populations. This systematic review offers a broad and exploratory investigation into how major sporting events affect communities and individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds (CIDBs). Design/methodology/approach In alignment with the PRISMA guidelines, four academic databases were searched to identify peer-reviewed articles published in English-language journals from 2000 to 2023. A total of 95 full-text articles were assessed for eligibility, culminating in a final sample of 14 articles in the review. Findings The selected articles showed moderate quality and primarily used qualitative methods. The urban theories or event leverage frameworks are frequently employed. There are four legacy/impact themes that emerged: social, economic, sport and infrastructure. The prevailing conclusion is that CIDBs tend to experience negative legacies from these events. Research limitations/implications This research underscores the pressing need for more socially responsible and equitable approaches to event hosting. Failing to tackle these crucial issues may intensify existing inequalities and provoke significant public dissatisfaction, thereby jeopardising the overarching goals these major events strive to accomplish. Originality/value This review marks the first of its kind, offering a thorough and comprehensive synthesis of evidence concerning the legacies of major events for CIDBs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2024legacies,
  author = {Xiao Liang and Mary L. Quinton and Jet Veldhuijzen Zanten and Zheng‐Chao Duan and Barnaby N. Zoob Carter and Andrew Heyes and Mark Lee and Abdullah Alharbi and Shushu Chen},
  title = {{Legacies and impacts of major sporting events for communities and individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds: a systematic review}},
  booktitle = {Equality},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1108/edi-02-2024-0058},
}
Figure