Learning with filopodia and spines

Albert Albesa-González, Claudia ClopathbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel learning rule, Filopodium-Spine STDP (FS-STDP), that unifies additive and multiplicative learning to model the distinct plasticity of filopodia and spines. This approach offers a more robust and stable learning mechanism, capable of both precise input correlation representation and memory consolidation, addressing limitations of previous models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain's ability to learn and adapt relies on changes in synaptic strength between neurons. Traditionally, two main models of synaptic plasticity, additive STDP (add-STDP) and multiplicative STDP (mult-STDP), have been used. Add-STDP is highly competitive and good at detecting salient patterns but is unstable. Mult-STDP is more stable and better at representing fine correlations but can lack specificity. Recent discoveries reveal that filopodia, thin synaptic protrusions, are more plastic and volatile than mature spines. This paper bridges this gap by proposing a unified learning framework that accounts for the distinct properties of filopodia and spines, aiming to overcome the individual limitations of add-STDP and mult-STDP.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of the Filopodium-Spine STDP (FS-STDP) learning rule. This rule is built upon a generalized nonlinear temporally asymmetric (nlta) STDP framework, where a parameter $\mu$ controls the balance between additive and multiplicative dynamics. The key innovation is that this parameter $\mu$ is made weight-dependent, specifically increasing with synaptic efficacy. This means:

  • Filopodia (low synaptic efficacy) exhibit additive STDP, leading to strong competition and rapid learning.
  • Spines (high synaptic efficacy) exhibit multiplicative STDP, resulting in more stable learning and fine-tuning to input correlations.

The model also incorporates a transition mechanism where potentiated filopodia can consolidate into spines. This transition is governed by a "spineness" parameter that increases with synaptic efficacy, effectively making the learning rule shift from additive to multiplicative as synapses mature.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated by the proposed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Filopodia as "plastic pioneers": The model posits that filopodia, with their additive plasticity, act as initial, highly competitive learners, quickly identifying and strengthening salient input patterns.
  • Spines as "memory keepers": Once filopodia consolidate into spines, their multiplicative plasticity allows for stable, fine-grained representation of input correlations, preserving learned information.
  • A two-stage learning process: FS-STDP creates a natural two-stage learning system: an initial strong competition phase (filopodia) followed by a weaker, more refined competition phase (spines).
  • Synaptic consolidation: The transition from filopodia to spines, coupled with the protective nature of multiplicative STDP, acts as a form of synaptic consolidation, making learned memories more resistant to erasure by new environmental statistics.
  • Bridging the stability-specificity gap: By combining the strengths of additive and multiplicative learning, FS-STDP offers a more balanced approach to synaptic plasticity, achieving both stability and specificity in receptive field formation.

Key Results

  • Selective representation of input correlations: FS-STDP successfully forms receptive fields that are more selective and better represent input correlations compared to pure additive STDP.
  • Improved memory protection: The model demonstrates a mechanism for protecting previously formed memories from being overwritten by new input patterns, a capability lacking in simpler STDP models. This protection can be tuned by model parameters.
  • Bimodal and sparse receptive fields: The learning process naturally leads to bimodal and sparse receptive fields, similar to those observed with additive STDP, but with the added benefit of fine-grained correlation representation characteristic of multiplicative STDP.
  • Parameter-controlled learning dynamics: The model's behavior, including the degree of memory overwriting or preservation, can be controlled by parameters like potentiation/depression imbalance ($\alpha$) and protection ($\alpha$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reverse transition assumption: The model assumes that spines can revert to filopodia, a process not yet experimentally confirmed. Future experiments could investigate this inverse transformation.
  • Simplified channel model: The model does not explicitly differentiate between AMPA and NMDA channels, which are known to play roles in filopodial plasticity. Future work could incorporate these distinctions.
  • Recurrent networks: The current study focuses on a single postsynaptic neuron. Extending the model to recurrently connected networks could reveal its potential for learning neuronal assemblies and overcoming catastrophic forgetting.
  • Experimental validation: While inspired by experimental findings, further direct experimental validation of the FS-STDP rule and its proposed mechanisms would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Filopodia are thin synaptic protrusions that have been long known to play an important role in early development. It has recently been found that they are more abundant in the adult cortex than previously thought, and more plastic than spines (button-shaped mature synapses). Inspired by these findings, we introduce a new model of synaptic plasticity that jointly describes learning of filopodia and spines. The model assumes that filopodia exhibit additive learning, which is highly competitive and volatile. At the same time, it proposes that if filopodia undergo sufficient potentiation they consolidate into spines, and start following multiplicative learning dynamics. This makes spines more stable and sensitive to the fine structure of input correlations. We show that our learning rule has a selectivity comparable to additive spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) and represents input correlations as well as multiplicative STDP. We also show how it can protect previously formed memories and act as a synaptic consolidation mechanism. Overall, our results provide a mechanistic explanation of how filopodia and spines could cooperate to overcome the difficulties that these separate forms of learning (additive and multiplicative) each have. Author Summary Changes in the strength of synaptic connections between neurons are the basis of learning in biological and artificial networks. In animals, these changes can only depend on locally available signals, and are usually modeled with learning rules . Based on recent discoveries on filopodia , a special type of synaptic structure, we propose a new learning rule called Filopodium-Spine spike-timing-dependent-plasticity. Our rule proposes that filopodia follow additive STDP and spines (mature synapses) multiplicative STDP. We show that our model overcomes classic difficulties that these learning rules have separately, like the absence of stability or specificity, and can also be seen as a first stage of synaptic consolidation.
BibTeX
@misc{albesagonzalez2023learning,
  author = {Albert Albesa-González and Claudia Clopath},
  title = {{Learning with filopodia and spines}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.08.26.554942},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure