Learning to Transfer: A Foliated Theory

Janith C. Petangoda, Marc Peter Deisenroth, Nicholas A. M. MonkarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel theoretical framework for understanding "learning to transfer" by leveraging differential geometry, specifically the theory of foliations. By formalizing the concept of related tasks and their relationships, the authors provide a unified perspective on various transfer learning paradigms, aiming to bridge the gap between experimental success and foundational understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core challenge this paper addresses is the lack of a rigorous, foundational understanding of what it means for tasks to be "related" in the context of machine learning transfer. While numerous successful transfer learning techniques exist, their underlying principles and the nature of task relationships remain somewhat ad-hoc. The authors argue that a deeper theoretical description is needed to understand why these methods work, how to quantify transferability, and how to systematically develop new approaches. They aim to provide this by exposing the structural components of transfer learning and formalizing the concept of task relatedness.

Methods

The paper's primary contribution is the development of a theoretical framework for learning to transfer, grounded in differential geometry, specifically the theory of foliations.

Key methodological elements include:

  • Formalizing Learning Tasks: Defining a learning task not just by data, but by its underlying structure and generative process.
  • Model Spaces: Introducing parametric model spaces and defining a "model space" as a quotient space that captures functional equivalence of models.
  • Task Spaces as Manifolds: Proposing that the space of learning tasks can be viewed as a smooth manifold, allowing for the application of differential geometric tools.
  • Notions of Relatedness: Defining "relatedness" between tasks through partitions of the task space and, more formally, through groups and pseudogroups of transformations acting on these spaces.
  • Foliations for Structure: The central idea is to represent the structure of related tasks using foliations on the task space manifold. A foliation decomposes a manifold into a collection of "leaves," where each leaf represents a set of related tasks. This structure naturally captures the idea of task relationships and allows for the exploitation of shared underlying properties.
  • Equivariant Learning Algorithms: The framework suggests that effective transfer learning algorithms should be equivariant with respect to the defined notions of relatedness, meaning they preserve the task relationships in their learned models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Foliations as a Unifying Concept: The theory of foliations provides a powerful geometric lens to unify diverse transfer learning approaches by formalizing the structure of related tasks.
  • Task Relatedness as a Geometric Property: The paper posits that task relatedness is not just a heuristic but a fundamental geometric property that can be mathematically described using transformations and partitions on a task space manifold.
  • Structure Dictates Transferability: The degree to which knowledge can be transferred is directly linked to the underlying geometric structure (foliation) of the task space and the model space.
  • Inductive Bias as Geometric Structure: Inductive biases, crucial for learning, can be understood as the inherent structure (e.g., leaves of a foliation) that guides learning within a set of related tasks.
  • Equivariance as a Desired Property: Learning algorithms that respect the geometric structure of task relatedness (i.e., are equivariant) are likely to be more effective for transfer.

Key Results

The paper is primarily theoretical and does not present empirical results or quantitative performance metrics. Its key "results" are conceptual and definitional:

  • A formal framework for learning to transfer is introduced, based on differential geometry.
  • The concept of task relatedness is mathematically defined using groups, pseudogroups, and foliations.
  • It is shown that existing transfer learning methods (multitask learning, meta-learning, etc.) can be interpreted within this foliated framework, suggesting a unified theoretical basis.
  • The paper provides theoretical propositions and theorems (e.g., Theorem 17 on relatedness from foliations, Proposition 19 on MAML inducing local foliations) that establish connections between geometric structures and transfer learning principles.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Foliations: While foliations offer a powerful framework, defining and learning them in practice can be complex. The paper acknowledges that proving the existence of certain foliations and their properties can be challenging.
  • Practical Implementation: The paper focuses on the theoretical foundation. Future work will involve exploring how to practically implement and learn these foliated structures.
  • Measuring Relatedness: Developing methods to measure the "suitability" of a notion of relatedness and to learn it from data is a key area for future research.
  • Generalizing to Infinite Dimensions: The current framework primarily deals with finite-dimensional manifolds. Extending it to infinite-dimensional spaces (e.g., function spaces) is a potential avenue.
  • Exploration of Singular Foliations: The paper mentions singular foliations as a generalization that could capture more complex task relationships (tessellations), which warrants further investigation.
  • Applications to Specific ML Problems: The authors plan to investigate how this framework can be applied to answer foundational questions about transferability, complexity, and the development of novel transfer methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Learning to transfer considers learning solutions to tasks in a such way that relevant knowledge can be transferred from known task solutions to new, related tasks. This is important for general learning, as well as for improving the efficiency of the learning process. While techniques for learning to transfer have been studied experimentally, we still lack a foundational description of the problem that exposes what related tasks are, and how relationships between tasks can be exploited constructively. In this work, we introduce a framework using the differential geometric theory of foliations that provides such a foundation.
BibTeX
@misc{petangoda2021learning,
  author = {Janith C. Petangoda and Marc Peter Deisenroth and Nicholas A. M. Monk},
  title = {{Learning to Transfer: A Foliated Theory}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2107.10763},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.10763},
}
Figure