TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel method for embodied AI agents to learn when and how to perceive information in partially unknown environments. By combining neural network-based perception with symbolic planning, the agent can actively seek out situations that yield more reliable observations, improving its understanding of the world.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Autonomous agents operating in the real world, especially robots, often face environments where not all information is immediately available or reliable. For instance, to determine if a cup is full of coffee, a robot might need to perform specific actions like turning on a light or changing its viewpoint. This paper tackles the challenge of how an agent can learn these optimal perceptual situations and plan to reach them, especially when the environment's properties are not fully known beforehand. Traditional symbolic planning relies on well-defined states, but in reality, perceptions can be noisy or incomplete. This work bridges this gap by enabling agents to dynamically improve their perception capabilities through interaction and planning.
Methods
The core of the proposed method involves a two-pronged approach:
- Perception Modeling: The agent uses a set of deep neural networks to map raw sensory data (like images) into symbolic state representations. This is a standard approach for perception.
- Confidence Estimation and Learning: The novelty lies in how the agent estimates the confidence of its perception model in different situations. It does this by:
- Clustering: Grouping situations (defined by control variables like lighting or viewpoint) based on the neural network's prediction confidence.
- Viewpoint Identification: Identifying clusters (viewpoints) where the perception model achieves a confidence above a predefined threshold.
- Symbolic Planning: Once these "good" viewpoints are identified, the agent uses a symbolic planner (like PDDL) to generate plans. These plans are designed to guide the agent from its current state to one of these high-confidence viewpoints, without altering the observable state variable itself. This transforms the problem into a classical planning task.
Essentially, the agent learns to recognize when its perception is unreliable and then plans to change its own state (e.g., move, adjust lighting) to improve that perception.
Datasets
The authors evaluated their approach on several datasets:
- Synthetic Datasets: They used standard image classification datasets like Cifar10, Cifar100, EuroSAT, FER, MNIST, and OxfordPet. These datasets were modified to simulate "noisy" conditions (e.g., varying brightness, blur, and added occlusions) to represent partially observable environments.
- Real-World Scenario: A Softbank Pepper humanoid robot was used in a living room environment with objects. This setup involved noisy sensors and actuators, and the task was to perceive object properties (e.g., "filled" for a mug).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Active Perception as Planning: The paper frames active perception not just as finding the "best view," but as a planning problem where the agent actively seeks out informative situations.
- Learning to Trust Your Senses: The agent doesn't just passively receive data; it learns to assess the reliability of its own perception model and takes action when that reliability is low.
- Bridging Subsymbolic and Symbolic: The method effectively connects low-level, continuous sensory data processed by neural networks with high-level, discrete symbolic planning.
- Generalizability: The approach is demonstrated across various object recognition tasks and a real-world robotic manipulation scenario, suggesting its broad applicability.
Key Results
- Improved Accuracy: The proposed approach significantly improved object classification accuracy compared to baselines that did not plan for better perception. For instance, it was at least 10% better than a baseline that assumed full observability.
- Effective Viewpoint Discovery: In the real-world experiment, the method successfully identified viewpoints that provided high precision (1) for observing object properties, though recall varied.
- Robotic Performance: The Pepper robot, using the learned viewpoints, demonstrated improved accuracy in predicting object properties over multiple epochs compared to a baseline that did not plan for better perception.
Limitations and Future Work
- Human Assistance: The current approach assumes that the agent can change the value of observable variables, potentially with human help (as in the real-world experiment where humans labeled data).
- Future Work: The authors suggest investigating how agents can change observable values without explicit human intervention. They also aim to explore how agents can learn these values without knowing them beforehand.
Summary updated