Learning the mutational landscape of the cancer genome

Maxwell A. Sherman, Adam Yaari, Oliver Priebe, Felix Dietlein, Po‐Ru Loh, Bonnie BergerbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel deep learning framework to accurately model neutral mutation rates across the entire cancer genome. By leveraging this model, they identify new candidate cancer driver mutations in previously understudied genomic regions, offering a more comprehensive understanding of cancer development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A major hurdle in cancer research is distinguishing between "neutral" mutations (passengers) that don't impact tumor fitness and "driver" mutations that actively promote cancer growth. Accurately identifying driver mutations is crucial for developing targeted therapies. However, the highly variable and tissue-specific nature of neutral mutation rates across the genome makes it difficult to build reliable models for detecting these drivers, especially in non-coding regions. Existing methods often focus on specific genomic intervals, missing potential drivers spread across regulatory elements or in infrequently mutated genes.

Methods

The authors developed a two-step probabilistic deep-learning framework:

  1. Deep Neural Network (DNN) for Kilobase-Scale Rates: A DNN is trained to predict somatic mutation rates at a kilobase-scale resolution. This model utilizes high-resolution epigenetic features from healthy tissues (e.g., chromatin accessibility, replication timing) as input, as these are known predictors of tumor mutation rates.
  2. Hierarchical Probabilistic Model for Finer-Scale Refinement: The kilobase-scale predictions are then refined using a hierarchical probabilistic model. This step incorporates cancer-specific mutational processes, leveraging nucleotide context biases to estimate mutation rates at even finer scales (base-pair level). This allows for a more accurate estimation of neutral mutation rates across the entire genome.

Datasets

  • Roadmap Epigenomics and ENCODE datasets: Used for epigenetic features to train the deep learning model.
  • Pan-Cancer Analysis of Whole Genomes (PCAWG) dataset: A large dataset comprising whole-genome sequencing data from 37 cancer types, used for benchmarking and mapping mutation rates.
  • Publicly available whole-genome, whole-exome, and targeted-sequencing cancer datasets: Utilized for identifying new candidate cancer drivers.
  • Hartwig Medical Foundation dataset: Used for validation of findings in TP53 and ELF3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Epigenetic features are powerful predictors of neutral mutation rates: The study demonstrates that detailed epigenetic profiles of healthy tissues can be effectively used to predict mutation rates in cancer genomes, even at fine resolutions.
  • Deep learning can extract biologically relevant signals from complex data: The DNN model not only predicts mutation rates but also learns to focus on specific, localized epigenetic features (like transcription start sites and regulatory regions) that are biologically meaningful.
  • Non-coding regions harbor significant driver mutations: The framework successfully identified novel candidate drivers in understudied non-coding regions, such as cryptic splice sites and 5' untranslated regions (UTRs), highlighting their importance in cancer development.
  • "Long-tail" genes are important contributors to cancer: The analysis revealed that even genes mutated at low frequencies ("long-tail" genes) can collectively contribute significantly to cancer pathology, suggesting a more nuanced view of driver mutations.

Key Results

  • High prediction accuracy: The model achieved a median of 71.2% variance explained in 10kb regions and 94.6% in 1Mb regions across 37 cancer types.
  • Identification of novel drivers: The study identified new candidate drivers in cryptic splice sites, 5' UTRs, and "long-tail" genes. For example, they found significant enrichment of intronic cryptic splice SNVs in tumor suppressor genes (TSGs), with a 1.75-fold enrichment for high-impact mutations.
  • TP53 and ELF3 5' UTRs as potential driver regions: Mutations in the 5' UTR of TP53 and ELF3 were found to be significantly enriched and associated with altered gene expression, suggesting a role in cancer.
  • Shared driver landscape: The research indicates that many driver mechanisms are shared across different cancer types, both for common and rare driver genes.
  • Web-based resource: The mutation maps for 37 cancer types are publicly available as an interactive genome browser, facilitating further research.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model inaccuracies: The authors acknowledge that no neutral mutation model is perfect, and mutational excess could reflect model inaccuracies rather than true positive selection. Local hypermutation processes at specific loci remain a challenge.
  • Sample size limitations: A power analysis suggested that current sample sizes may not be sufficient to uncover infrequent drivers under moderate or weak positive selection, particularly those involved in polygenic "mini driver" models of cancer evolution.
  • Need for functional validation: While excess mutations suggest potential driver roles, the authors emphasize the need for functional data to confirm these findings.
  • Future work: The authors anticipate that their maps will be useful for evaluating hypotheses like the "mini driver" model and for identifying drivers in enhancer networks. Further research is needed to determine whether observed mutational enrichments represent positive selection or new neutral mutational processes. Expanding mutation panels to include intronic and untranslated sequences in clinical tumor profiling is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract An ongoing challenge to better understand and treat cancer is to distinguish neutral mutations, which do not affect tumor fitness, from those that provide a proliferative advantage. However, the variability of mutation rates has limited our ability to model patterns of neutral mutations and therefore identify cancer driver mutations. Here, we predict cancer-specific mutation rates genome-wide by leveraging deep neural networks to learn mutation rates within kilobase-scale regions and then refining these estimates to test for evidence of selection on combinations of mutations by comparing observed to expected mutation counts. We mapped mutation rates for 37 cancer types and used these maps to identify new putative drivers in understudied regions of the genome including cryptic alternative-splice sites, 5’ untranslated regions and infrequently mutated genes. These results, available for exploration via web interface, indicate the potential for high-resolution neutral mutation models to empower further driver discovery as cancer sequencing cohorts grow.
BibTeX
@misc{sherman2021learning,
  author = {Maxwell A. Sherman and Adam Yaari and Oliver Priebe and Felix Dietlein and Po‐Ru Loh and Bonnie Berger},
  title = {{Learning the mutational landscape of the cancer genome}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.08.03.454669},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure