Learning the Finer Things: Bayesian Structure Learning at the Instantiation Level

Chase Yakaboski, Eugene Santos Jr.AAAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian structure learning approach that operates at the random variable instantiation level, addressing the issue of over-generalization in traditional Bayesian Networks (BNs). By leveraging Bayesian Knowledge Bases (BKBs), their method achieves a tighter data fit and more nuanced explanations, particularly in under-determined domains like gene regulatory networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Machine learning models face a fundamental trade-off between memorization and generalization. While standard methods like cross-validation and accuracy metrics are common, they can struggle in domains where data is scarce and relationships are complex (under-determined domains). Traditional Bayesian Networks (BNs), while powerful for modeling uncertainty and offering explainability, tend to over-generalize. This means they force a complete distribution even when the data doesn't fully support it, potentially leading to inaccurate or misleading conclusions. The authors aim to develop a method that can learn more precise relationships by operating at a finer granularity – the specific instantiation of random variables, rather than just the variables themselves.

Methods

The core of this work is a new structure learning algorithm called BKBSL (Bayesian Knowledge Base Structure Learning). It leverages the Bayesian Knowledge Base (BKB) framework, which naturally operates at the random variable instantiation level.

  • Bayesian Knowledge Bases (BKBs): Unlike BNs, BKBs can handle incomplete information and cyclic dependencies. They represent knowledge as a correlation graph of "instantiation nodes" (I-nodes) and "support nodes" (S-nodes), allowing for more flexible modeling.
  • Minimum Description Length (MDL) Scoring: The authors propose an MDL-based scoring function specifically for BKBs. This score aims to minimize both the complexity of the model and the length of encoding the data given the model, theoretically accounting for over-generalization.
  • Decomposition over Instantiations: The key innovation is decomposing the learning problem. Instead of learning a single global structure, BKBSL learns a minimal entropy inference graph for each unique data instance (world) in the training set.
  • DAG Learning Integration: For learning these individual inference graphs, BKBSL can utilize existing Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) learning algorithms (like GOBNILP), making it scalable.
  • BKB Fusion: After learning individual inference fragments, a BKB fusion algorithm is used to combine them into a coherent model, ensuring consistency and avoiding mutex violations.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their approach on:

  • 40 benchmark datasets: Used for comparing MDL scores and model complexity between BKBSL and BNSL.
  • 22 benchmark datasets: Used for cross-validation experiments to compare accuracy performance with learned BNs.
  • TCGA breast cancer mutation data: A specific application domain to study gene regulatory networks in an under-determined setting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Over-generalization is a problem even for explainable models: BNs, despite their explainability, can still over-generalize, leading to potentially flawed conclusions, especially in complex, data-scarce scenarios.
  • Operating at the instantiation level matters: By focusing on specific instantiations of variables (e.g., "gene X is mutated" rather than just "gene X"), the model can capture finer-grained dependencies.
  • BKBs offer a natural fit for instantiation-level learning: The BKB framework's ability to handle incomplete data and cyclic dependencies makes it well-suited for this granular approach.
  • MDL can be adapted to penalize over-generalization: The proposed MDL score for BKBs explicitly accounts for the cost of modeling specific instantiations, naturally favoring models that fit the observed data more precisely.
  • Decomposing learning by data instance is powerful: Learning a separate, optimal inference structure for each observed data point allows the model to capture unique patterns without forcing them into a single, overarching global structure.

Key Results

  • Tighter Data Fit (MDL): BKBSL consistently found a tighter data fit (lower data MDL) than the best learned BNs across all 40 benchmark datasets.
  • Competitive Accuracy: In 10-fold cross-validation on 22 datasets, BKBSL achieved statistically competitive accuracy with learned BNs, outperforming them in 63% of cases for precision.
  • Reduced Computational Calls: BKBSL significantly reduced the number of calls to joint probability calculators compared to traditional BNSL, indicating practical efficiency gains.
  • Biological Insights: In the TCGA breast cancer dataset, BKBSL identified gene regulatory relationships that align with existing biological hypotheses (e.g., TP53 influencing HER1/HER2) and discovered cyclic relationships supported by literature, demonstrating its utility in hypothesis generation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost of Learning Fragments: The current approach requires running a DAG learning algorithm for each unique data instance, which can be computationally intensive. Future work aims to explore DAG learning formulations that can learn all fragments in a single pass.
  • Accuracy Degradation: While generally good, there are instances where BKBSL shows accuracy degradation. The authors hypothesize this might be due to datasets with fewer information-equivalent Markov Boundaries (MBs), where BNs might perform better.
  • Tuning Source Node Reliabilities: The paper suggests that tuning the "reliabilities" of source nodes in the BKB fusion process could help correct errors arising from under-fitting or over-generalization, which is a direction for future research.
  • Understanding Performance Differences: Further investigation is needed to pinpoint why BKBSL performs better on certain datasets and not others, potentially by analyzing dataset characteristics related to MBs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yakaboski2023learning,
  author = {Chase Yakaboski and Eugene Santos Jr.},
  title = {{Learning the Finer Things: Bayesian Structure Learning at the Instantiation Level}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v37i9.26269},
}
Figure