Learning place cells, grid cells and invariances with excitatory and inhibitory plasticity

Simon N. Weber, Henning SprekelereLife 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a unified model where the interaction between excitatory and inhibitory synaptic plasticity can explain the diverse spatial tuning patterns (place cells, grid cells, head direction cells, and conjunctive cells) observed in the rodent brain. By varying the spatial "smoothness" of the excitatory and inhibitory inputs, the model can reproduce these distinct cell types, suggesting a common underlying mechanism for spatial representation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain's ability to navigate and represent space is a fundamental cognitive function, heavily reliant on specialized neurons in areas like the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex. These neurons exhibit a remarkable variety of firing patterns, including:

  • Place cells: Firing when an animal is in a specific location.
  • Grid cells: Firing at multiple locations forming a hexagonal grid pattern, effectively tiling the environment.
  • Head direction cells: Firing when the animal's head is pointing in a particular direction.
  • Conjunctive cells: Combining spatial and directional information.

A key puzzle is why some cells are selective to one spatial variable (e.g., location) but invariant to another (e.g., head direction), and vice versa. Existing models often focus on explaining one cell type or pattern, leaving the unifying principles unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a single, plasticity-driven mechanism that can generate all these observed spatial representations.

Methods

The authors employ a computational modeling approach using a feedforward network of rate-based neurons. The core of their model lies in the interaction of two types of synaptic plasticity:

  • Excitatory Synaptic Plasticity: Modeled using a Hebbian rule, where synaptic weights strengthen when pre- and post-synaptic activity are correlated.
  • Inhibitory Synaptic Plasticity: Modeled using a homeostatic rule that adjusts weights to maintain a target firing rate, balancing excitation.

The key innovation is how the statistics of the spatially tuned inputs to these neurons influence the emergent firing patterns. Specifically, the "smoothness" or spatial autocorrelation of the excitatory and inhibitory inputs is varied. The model simulates a virtual rat exploring an environment, and the synaptic weights evolve over time based on the animal's activity and the input statistics. Mathematical analysis is used to derive predictions about grid spacing and other properties.

Datasets

The paper utilizes simulated trajectories of a rat exploring environments. For two-dimensional environments, they use trajectories from behavioral data (Sargolini et al., 2006b). For simulations involving head direction, they use these same trajectories but add a random component to the head direction that is loosely aligned with the direction of motion. No external, pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense; rather, the model generates its own internal representations based on simulated experience.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Mechanism: The most significant insight is that a single mechanism – the interplay of excitatory and inhibitory plasticity – can account for the diverse spatial representations observed in the brain.
  • Smoothness is Key: The spatial "smoothness" (or autocorrelation length) of the excitatory and inhibitory inputs is the critical parameter determining the emergent cell type. Smoother inhibition relative to excitation leads to grid-like patterns, while smoother excitation leads to invariance.
  • Predictive Power: The model not only reproduces known patterns but also makes specific, testable predictions about the statistical properties of the synaptic inputs that drive these neurons.
  • Rapid Emergence: The model demonstrates that these complex spatial patterns can emerge relatively quickly, on timescales consistent with experimental observations, challenging models that require very slow learning.

Key Results

  • Place Cells: Emerged when inhibitory inputs were very smooth or spatially untuned, leading to a single firing field.
  • Grid Cells: Emerged when inhibitory inputs were smoother than excitatory inputs, leading to periodic, hexagonal firing patterns in 2D. The grid spacing was directly predicted by the smoothness of the inhibitory input.
  • Spatial Invariance: Emerged when excitatory inputs were smoother than inhibitory inputs, resulting in cells that fired at a relatively constant rate across the environment.
  • Head Direction Cells & Conjunctive Cells: By incorporating head direction tuning into the input statistics, the model could also generate head direction cells and conjunctive cells, with the relative smoothness of spatial and directional inputs determining the cell type.
  • Robustness: The model showed robustness to parameter changes and demonstrated that learned patterns could adapt to environmental changes (e.g., removing a wall).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Input Statistics: The paper relies on assumptions about the statistical properties of the input signals. The precise origin and nature of these inputs in the biological brain remain an open question.
  • Recurrent Connections: The current model is feedforward. The authors acknowledge that incorporating recurrent connections between output neurons could further explain phenomena like the coordinated orientation of grid cells.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors emphasize that investigating the spatial autocorrelation structure of excitatory and inhibitory inputs in vivo would be a crucial test of their model.
  • Speed Modulation: While the model is not directly dependent on speed, the authors suggest that incorporating speed-dependent input modulation could explain experimental observations of speed-tuned cells.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neurons in the hippocampus and adjacent brain areas show a large diversity in their tuning to location and head direction, and the underlying circuit mechanisms are not yet resolved. In particular, it is unclear why certain cell types are selective to one spatial variable, but invariant to another. For example, place cells are typically invariant to head direction. We propose that all observed spatial tuning patterns - in both their selectivity and their invariance - arise from the same mechanism: Excitatory and inhibitory synaptic plasticity driven by the spatial tuning statistics of synaptic inputs. Using simulations and a mathematical analysis, we show that combined excitatory and inhibitory plasticity can lead to localized, grid-like or invariant activity. Combinations of different input statistics along different spatial dimensions reproduce all major spatial tuning patterns observed in rodents. Our proposed model is robust to changes in parameters, develops patterns on behavioral timescales and makes distinctive experimental predictions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{weber2018learning,
  author = {Simon N. Weber and Henning Sprekeler},
  title = {{Learning place cells, grid cells and invariances with excitatory and inhibitory plasticity}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.34560},
}
Figure