Learning Inclusion-Optimal Chordal Graphs

Vincent Auvray, Louis WehenkelUAI 2008

TL;DR

This paper introduces a greedy algorithm for learning chordal graph structures, which are useful for representing complex dependency models. They prove that this algorithm, under specific conditions, can efficiently find an "inclusion-optimal" structure, meaning it captures the true dependencies without making unnecessary assumptions. This is a significant step towards learning complex graphical models from data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Graphical models use graphs to represent dependencies between random variables. Two common types are Bayesian networks (directed acyclic graphs, DAGs) and Markov networks (undirected graphs). This paper focuses on a specific class of undirected graphs called chordal graphs. Chordal graphs are important because they represent a dependency model that is the intersection of those representable by DAGs and general undirected graphs. This makes them powerful for encoding complex relationships.

The challenge is learning these chordal structures from data. While greedy search algorithms are common for learning DAGs, their application to chordal graphs and their theoretical guarantees are less explored. Specifically, the authors aim to develop and analyze a greedy algorithm that learns an inclusion-optimal chordal graph. An inclusion-optimal graph is one that accurately reflects the dependencies in the data without adding any unnecessary independence assumptions, and importantly, no larger chordal graph can also accurately represent these dependencies.

Methods

The core of the paper is a greedy hill-climbing search algorithm for learning chordal graph structures. This algorithm operates on the inclusion boundary neighborhood of chordal graphs. This neighborhood is defined as the set of chordal graphs that can be obtained by adding or removing a single edge from the current graph, while maintaining chordality.

The authors introduce a theoretical concept called local consistency for scoring criteria (functions that evaluate how well a graph structure fits the data). They prove that if a scoring criterion is locally consistent and a greedy search uses the inclusion boundary neighborhood, it will find an inclusion-optimal chordal graph. This theoretical guarantee is crucial for understanding the algorithm's behavior. They also show how to derive this local consistency property from existing criteria used for DAGs.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the proposed algorithm using simulated datasets. These datasets are generated from either chordal structures or DAG structures. The authors do not introduce any new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chordal graphs as a powerful middle ground: Chordal graphs offer a way to represent dependencies that are common to both directed and undirected graphical models, making them a versatile choice.
  • Inclusion boundary as an efficient neighborhood: The inclusion boundary neighborhood for chordal graphs is shown to be computationally manageable (bounded by the square of the number of variables), unlike some neighborhoods for DAGs which can be exponentially large.
  • Theoretical guarantee for greedy search: The paper provides a theoretical proof that a greedy search algorithm, using the inclusion boundary and a locally consistent scoring criterion, will find an inclusion-optimal chordal graph when the data-generating distribution is perfectly representable by an undirected graph. This is a strong theoretical foundation for the practical algorithm.
  • Practical implications for complex models: The algorithm's ability to find inclusion-optimal structures suggests it can effectively learn complex dependency relationships from data, even when the underlying structure is not perfectly chordal.

Key Results

The paper's main result is a theoretical proposition (Proposition 2) that guarantees the asymptotic inclusion-optimality of a greedy search algorithm using the inclusion boundary neighborhood for learning chordal graphs. This guarantee holds under specific conditions on the scoring criterion and the data-generating distribution.

Experimental results (Figures 3-12) show that the learned chordal models generally exhibit lower KL divergence (a measure of how well the learned distribution matches the true distribution) and lower dimensions compared to learned DAG models, especially with smaller sample sizes. As the sample size increases, the learned chordal model's performance becomes more comparable to the true data-generating structure, supporting the inclusion-optimality property. For chordal data-generating distributions, the number of false positive and false negative lines in the learned chordal structure tends to decrease with more data, and false positives are generally lower, likely due to the conservative nature of the Bayesian scoring.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conjecture for DAGs: The authors conjecture that the optimality property might extend to cases where the target dependency model is a DAG, but they haven't proven it.
  • Hidden variables: The paper notes that the optimality guarantee does not hold when the DAG structure involves hidden variables, as illustrated by an example.
  • Extension to other graphical models: The authors suggest that further theoretical work should focus on extending the optimality property to more general dependency models.
  • Practical exploration: They also propose more in-depth empirical investigations comparing inclusion boundary search for chordal models with search in the larger space of Markov equivalence classes of DAGs.
  • Approximate inference: The potential use of inclusion-optimal chordal models for designing efficient approximate inference algorithms is highlighted as an area for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{auvray2008learning,
  author = {Vincent Auvray and Louis Wehenkel},
  title = {{Learning Inclusion-Optimal Chordal Graphs}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2008},
}
Figure