Learning Implicit Sampling Distributions for Motion Planning

Clark Zhang, Jinwook Huh, Daniel D. LeeIROS 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for learning adaptive sampling distributions for motion planning. By framing rejection sampling as a Markov Decision Process and using reinforcement learning, the approach learns to intelligently bias sample generation, significantly reducing collision checks and tree expansion in complex environments. This leads to faster and more efficient motion planning without requiring hand-crafted heuristics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sampling-based motion planners, like RRT and PRM, are powerful tools for finding paths in high-dimensional spaces. However, their efficiency heavily relies on the sampling distribution. Traditionally, uniform sampling is used, which can be inefficient in environments with specific structures (e.g., sparse obstacles, narrow passages). While some methods use hand-crafted heuristics to bias sampling (e.g., towards the goal or away from obstacles), these heuristics are often environment-specific and can even degrade performance if ill-suited. The core problem this paper addresses is how to automatically learn effective, adaptive sampling distributions that improve planning efficiency across diverse environments without relying on brittle, manual heuristics.

Methods

The paper proposes a method that learns an implicit sampling distribution using rejection sampling. Instead of explicitly defining a complex probability distribution, they learn a policy that decides whether to accept or reject samples drawn from a simpler, explicit distribution (e.g., uniform with a goal bias). This rejection policy is learned by framing the process as a Markov Decision Process (MDP).

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological components:

  • Rejection Sampling: Samples are drawn from an initial distribution $\nu$. A learned policy $\pi$ then decides to "accept" or "reject" the sample. The effective distribution $\mu$ is formed by the accepted samples.
  • Markov Decision Process (MDP) Formulation: The state in the MDP includes the environment, the planner's current state, and a randomly generated sample. Actions are "accept" or "reject." The reward is designed to reflect the negative cost of planning (e.g., number of collision checks, nodes added, samples drawn).
  • Policy Gradient Reinforcement Learning: The paper uses the REINFORCE algorithm with function approximation (neural networks) to optimize the policy parameters $\theta$. This allows the policy to learn complex, non-linear relationships between the state and the optimal rejection strategy.
  • Value Function Baseline: A separate neural network is trained to estimate the value function, which is used as a baseline in the policy gradient updates to reduce variance and improve learning stability.
  • Implicit Distribution: The learned policy $\pi_\theta$ implicitly defines the sampling distribution $\mu_\theta$. This is advantageous because complex distributions can be hard to represent explicitly.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets but rather uses simulated and real-world environments for training and evaluation.

  • Simulated Environments:
    • 2D Flytrap: A benchmark environment known for its narrow passages, used to test RRT, BiRRT, and EST planners.
  • Pendulum Task: A dynamical system environment used to evaluate performance with dynamic systems.
  • Real-World Environment:
    • 7-DOF Robotic Arm (Thor robot): Used for testing in a high-dimensional, realistic tabletop manipulation scenario with various objects and obstacles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rejection Sampling as a Powerful Implicit Distribution: The paper demonstrates that rejection sampling, guided by a learned policy, can effectively represent complex sampling distributions that are difficult to model explicitly.
  • Reinforcement Learning for Adaptive Sampling: Framing the problem as an MDP and using policy gradient methods provides a systematic and generalizable way to learn optimal sampling strategies, adapting to different environments.
  • Environment-Specific Heuristics Emerge Naturally: The learned policies implicitly capture environment-specific behaviors. For example, in narrow passage environments, the policy learns to reject samples far from the tree, while in other scenarios, it might learn to reject samples too close to obstacles.
  • Trade-off Between Samples and Collision Checks: The learned policies effectively trade off an increase in the number of samples drawn from the initial distribution for a significant decrease in expensive collision checks and tree expansions, leading to overall faster planning.
  • Preservation of Probabilistic Completeness: The authors argue that their rejection sampling approach scales the probability of finding a path, thus preserving the probabilistic completeness guarantees of planners like RRT.

Key Results

The paper reports significant improvements across various planners and environments:

  • 2D Flytrap: For RRT, BiRRT, and EST, the learned planner achieved substantial reductions in execution time, number of tree nodes, and number of collision checks, often by factors of 2-5x, while maintaining or improving path quality. For example, RRT saw a ~5x reduction in collision checks.
  • Pendulum Task: The learned policy reduced the number of collision checks (though this metric was less relevant in obstacle-free scenarios) and improved planning efficiency by learning to reject samples unlikely to lead to the goal.
  • 7-DOF Robotic Arm: In a high-dimensional, realistic task, the learned policy reduced the number of tree nodes by over 5x and collision checks by 2.7x compared to the baseline, with a high success rate (97% vs. 96% for the baseline with limited samples). The variance in results was also greatly reduced.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Susceptibility to Local Minima: Policy gradient methods can be susceptible to local minima. The authors mitigate this by initializing policies differently and selecting the best one.
  • Thin Tunnel Problem: The paper acknowledges that rejection sampling alone may not fully solve the "thin tunnel" problem, where the fundamental challenge is sampling within extremely narrow passages. They suggest combining their method with other techniques (e.g., those that modify the workspace or use medial axis approximations) to further improve performance.
  • Optimal Solution Not Directly Addressed: The current method focuses on finding a solution faster, not necessarily the optimal solution. The authors suggest that their learned sampling distributions can be integrated with existing optimal planners (like Informed RRT or BIT) to accelerate the search for optimal paths.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more complex reward functions, different feature representations for the policy network, and further integration with existing planning techniques.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018learning,
  author = {Clark Zhang and Jinwook Huh and Daniel D. Lee},
  title = {{Learning Implicit Sampling Distributions for Motion Planning}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/iros.2018.8594028},
}
Figure