Learning From the Past to Improve the Future

Dana Naous, Manus Bonner, Mathias Humbert, Christine LegnerBus. Inf. Syst. Eng 2022 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract

While privacy concerns are often cited as the primary barrier to the adoption of COVID-19 contact tracing apps (CTAs), they represent only one facet of user decision-making. This study utilizes Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint Analysis (ACBCA) to investigate the role of "value-added services"—such as symptom checklists and infection hotspot maps—in driving app adoption. Results indicate that while privacy-preserving architectures are a baseline requirement, the inclusion of utility-focused features can significantly increase market share, potentially bridging the gap toward the 60% adoption threshold required for public health efficacy.

Introduction

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, governments launched contact tracing apps (CTAs) as high-tech solutions to break transmission chains. However, most implementations failed to reach the 60% adoption threshold estimated by epidemiologists as necessary for effectiveness. Previous research has focused intensely on the "privacy paradox"—the tension between individual data protection and public health needs. This study argues that such a focus is too narrow and addresses the gap in "prescriptive design": identifying the specific features that incentivize users to install these tools. By shifting the focus from risk mitigation to utility enhancement, the researchers aim to provide a roadmap for designing crisis management tools that people will actually use.

Methodology

The researchers employed Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint Analysis (ACBCA), a sophisticated market research technique that mimics real-world decision-making by forcing participants to make trade-offs between different app configurations.

The study involved 283 valid participants from Germany, recruited in June 2020 via the Prolific platform. The methodology followed a four-stage process:

  1. Build Your Own (BYO): Participants configured their ideal app.
  2. Screening: Evaluation of different app "profiles" to identify "must-have" or "unacceptable" features.
  3. Choice Tasks: A tournament-style selection between competing designs.
  4. Calibration: Assessing the likelihood of using specific concepts on a Likert scale.

Ten key attributes were analyzed, including architecture (centralized vs. decentralized), exposure logging (Bluetooth vs. GPS), and various value-added services.

Results and Insights

The analysis revealed that users are not a monolithic group, but rather fall into three distinct segments:

  • Cluster 1 (27%): Privacy-focused purists who want basic functionality and no extra services.
  • Cluster 2 (33%): Privacy-concerned but utility-driven users who demand decentralized architectures but are motivated by value-added services.
  • Cluster 3 (41%): "Unconcerned" users willing to trade privacy for a feature-rich, "all-in-one" experience.

The Role of Value-Added Services

A critical finding was that utility features are powerful adoption drivers. The most preferred service was a simple diagnosis tool (symptom checklist). Interestingly, "advanced diagnosis" using phone sensors was viewed negatively, likely due to perceived "data creep" or over-complexity.

Exposure logging (19%) and test result sharing (13%) were the most important individual attributes, but value-added services collectively accounted for a significant portion of the decision-making weight.

Architecture and Interoperability

Users showed a strong preference for Bluetooth-based logging (utility score 41.46) over GPS (-50.00) and decentralized architectures (utility score 37.37). Furthermore, there was a significant desire for cross-country integration (utility score 45.09), highlighting the importance of interoperability for users who travel.

The NHS COVID-19 app represents one of many national efforts where interoperability became a key concern.
France's TousAntiCovid app illustrates the variety of national CTA implementations that users wished to see integrated.

Market simulations suggested that an app combining simple diagnosis tools with maps of infected zones could achieve a 43% market share, a significant improvement over basic versions like the initial Corona-Warn-App.

Discussion and Limitations

The study demonstrates that while privacy-preserving, decentralized architectures are preferred, they are not enough on their own to maximize adoption. Utility features are what actually "move the needle" for the majority of users.

However, several limitations apply. The sample was restricted to Germany, a country with specific cultural attitudes toward privacy. Additionally, the data represents a snapshot from mid-2020 and does not account for later developments like "vaccine passports." Finally, as with all conjoint analyses, there is a risk that stated preferences in a survey may not perfectly match actual behavior in the app store.

Conclusion

For future health crises, the "prescriptive design" approach suggests that developers should not only mitigate privacy risks but also maximize personal utility. By integrating simple, high-value services and ensuring cross-border interoperability, public health authorities can better align technological solutions with user expectations, ultimately improving adoption and effectiveness.

Summary updated

Abstract

Contact tracing apps were considered among the first tools to control the spread of COVID-19 and ease lockdown measures. While these apps can be very effective at stopping transmission and saving lives, the level of adoption remains significantly below the expected critical mass. The public debate as well as academic research about contact tracing apps emphasizes general concerns about privacy (and the associated risks) but often disregards the value-added services, as well as benefits, that can result from a larger user base. To address this gap, the study analyzes goal-congruent features as drivers for user adoption. It uses market research techniques – specifically, conjoint analysis – to study individual and group preferences and gain insights into the prescriptive design. While the results confirm the privacy-preserving design of most European contact tracing apps, they emphasize the role of value-added services in addressing heterogeneous user segments to drive user adoption. The findings thereby are of relevance for designing effective contact tracing apps, but also inform the user-oriented design of apps for health and crisis management that rely on sharing sensitive information.
BibTeX
@article{naous2022learning,
  author = {Dana Naous and Manus Bonner and Mathias Humbert and Christine Legner},
  title = {{Learning From the Past to Improve the Future}},
  journal = {Bus. Inf. Syst. Eng.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s12599-022-00742-2},
}
Figure