Learning for stochastic dynamic programming

Sylvain Gelly, Jérémie Mary, Olivier TeytaudESANN 2006 · OpenReview

Abstract

Stochastic Dynamic Programming (SDP) provides a rigorous mathematical framework for sequential decision-making under uncertainty. However, the "curse of dimensionality" often renders exact solutions intractable for high-dimensional or continuous state spaces. This paper presents openDP, an open-source benchmarking framework designed to evaluate machine learning techniques for approximating the Bellman value function. Through a comparative study of various regression models across six control tasks, we identify Support Vector Regression (SMOreg) as a highly robust approach for SDP value function approximation, effectively managing the error propagation inherent in backwards induction.

Introduction

At the core of Stochastic Dynamic Programming lies the Bellman equation, which balances immediate rewards with expected future costs. In real-world applications, calculating this "future cost" for every possible state is computationally prohibitive. While discretization and specialized neural networks are common workarounds, there has been a lack of standardized, reproducible comparisons between general-purpose machine learning tools in this context. This work addresses this gap by integrating the Weka machine learning suite into a unified benchmarking tool, openDP, allowing for a rigorous comparison of linear models, decision trees, and kernel-based methods.

Methodology

The framework utilizes backwards induction to solve the SDP problem. Starting from the final time step, the value function is computed iteratively toward the initial state. To handle continuous state spaces, the authors employ a three-step process at each time interval:

  1. Sampling: A finite set of points is sampled within the state space.
  2. Local Optimization: The Bellman values for these specific points are calculated using a local optimizer (e.g., a genetic algorithm).
  3. Regression: A machine learning model is trained on these samples to learn a global approximation of the value function, which is then used to estimate values for the preceding time step.

The study evaluates a broad spectrum of algorithms, including Linear Regression, Decision Trees (REPTree), Instance-based learners (k-NN), Support Vector Regression (SMOreg), and Multilayer Perceptrons (MLP).

Benchmark Problems

The authors developed six benchmark problems specifically designed to be "greedy-inefficient," ensuring that simple short-sighted strategies fail. These tasks range from inventory optimization (Stock Management) to robotic navigation and coordination (Bot, Many Bots, Arm, Away). The specific dimensions and parameters for these benchmarks, which vary in state and action space complexity, are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1: Problem specifications for the six benchmarks

Results and Discussion

The experimental evaluation revealed that robustness is the most critical factor for success in SDP. Because value functions are computed recursively, errors at any given time step propagate and compound throughout the backwards induction process. Models that generalize well are significantly more valuable than those that merely minimize training error.

The Dominance of SVMs

Support Vector Regression (SMOreg) with a Gaussian kernel emerged as the most versatile tool, achieving the best performance in four out of six benchmarks and ranking second in the remaining two. Its ability to handle non-linearities effectively makes it a "Swiss Army knife" for value function approximation across diverse control domains.

Domain-Specific Successes

While SMOreg was generally superior, certain models excelled in specific domains:

  • Multilayer Perceptrons (MLP): Performed best in the Stock Management task. The authors suggest that sigmoidal activation functions naturally align with the "increasing marginal cost" curves typical in economic and inventory theory.
  • REPTree: Provided a balance between performance and interpretability. For controllers requiring human-readable logic, decision trees offer a symbolic set of rules that consistently outperform baseline greedy strategies.
  • Kernel-based Linear Regression (LRK): A polynomial kernel variant was the top performer for the "Bot" task involving multiple obstacles.

Detailed performance metrics across all benchmarks are provided in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Summary of experimental results across different benchmarks. Lower values indicate better performance (lower cost).

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that general-purpose machine learning algorithms, particularly Support Vector Regression, can effectively mitigate the curse of dimensionality in Stochastic Dynamic Programming. The openDP framework provides a necessary foundation for reproducible research in this field. Future work will explore the impact of increased sample sizes, the use of more sophisticated local optimizers, and extensive hyper-parameter tuning to further refine these approximations.

The openDP source code is available at http://opendp.sourceforge.net.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gelly2006learning,
  author = {Sylvain Gelly and Jérémie Mary and Olivier Teytaud},
  title = {{Learning for stochastic dynamic programming}},
  booktitle = {ESANN},
  year = {2006},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=VH9JNiwvsN},
}
Figure