Learning Efficient Representations for Reinforcement Learning

Yanping HuangarXiv 2015 · arXiv

Abstract

Reinforcement Learning (RL) faces significant scalability challenges in high-dimensional environments, a phenomenon known as the "Curse of Dimensionality." Traditional solutions often rely on human experts to hand-design compact representations, such as basis functions or kernels, to simplify the state space. This paper proposes an automated approach to representation learning using a context-free grammar (CFG) to construct structured kernels. By employing a greedy search over kernel compositions, the framework discovers efficient representations that facilitate faster and more accurate learning. We discuss the theoretical foundations of this approach, including its integration with standard MDP solvers and the role of Bellman error in feature generation.

Introduction

The core challenge in Reinforcement Learning is the exponential growth of the state space as the complexity of the environment increases. While basic algorithms excel in discrete, low-dimensional settings like Tic-Tac-Toe, they often fail in real-world scenarios involving continuous states or thousands of variables. To overcome this, researchers utilize mathematical shortcuts to group similar states together. Historically, these representations were manually engineered—a process that is time-consuming, error-prone, and highly task-specific. This work explores how an agent can automatically discover the optimal way to "see" and "simplify" its environment.

Foundations of Reinforcement Learning

To establish a baseline, the paper reviews standard Markov Decision Process (MDP) solutions, including Value Iteration, Policy Iteration, and Temporal Difference (TD) learning. These algorithms serve as the fundamental "engines" that drive the learning process.

Algorithm 2: Policy Iteration, a foundational iterative method for solving Markov Decision Processes.

Policy Iteration, as shown in Algorithm 2, involves alternating between evaluating a current policy and improving it based on the resulting value function. The proposed representation learning framework aims to enhance these standard methods by projecting complex value functions onto lower-dimensional subspaces using linear basis functions or kernels.

The primary contribution of this research is the Compositional Kernel Search method for Kernel-Based RL (KBRL). This approach treats kernel construction as a structured search problem:

  1. Context-Free Grammar (CFG): The system defines a "grammar" where base kernels (the fundamental building blocks) are combined using algebraic operations such as addition and multiplication.
  2. Greedy Search: Navigating the vast space of possible kernel combinations is computationally daunting. The algorithm utilizes a greedy search strategy to identify the kernel structure that best approximates the value function of the specific RL task.

By treating kernels as a language, the environment's underlying structure can be "parsed" and simplified automatically.

Key Insights and Theoretical Framework

A critical insight of this work is that a well-chosen basis ($\Phi$) does more than just approximate a value function; it induces a new, smaller MDP that is mathematically equivalent to the original but significantly easier to solve. Furthermore, the paper highlights the utility of the Bellman Error—the residual gap between an agent's expectations and observed outcomes—as a signal for generating new features automatically (Bellman Error Basis Functions).

The research also emphasizes the inherent tradeoff between representation complexity and solver speed. While factored MDPs and hierarchical models offer power, they typically require prior human knowledge of the world's structure. The proposed automated search aims to bridge this gap.

Conclusion and Future Work

This framework successfully integrates KBRL with automated structure discovery, moving away from "black-box" kernels toward more interpretable, structured representations. While convergence is theoretically guaranteed as Bellman backups remain "contractions" in projected subspaces, several challenges remain. The "exploration-representation loop" presents a chicken-and-egg problem where an agent's representation depends on the data it explores, which in turn depends on its current representation. Future research will focus on reducing the computational overhead of grammar-based searches and investigating the transferability of learned representations across related tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Markov decision processes (MDPs) are a well studied framework for solving sequential decision making problems under uncertainty. Exact methods for solving MDPs based on dynamic programming such as policy iteration and value iteration are effective on small problems. In problems with a large discrete state space or with continuous state spaces, a compact representation is essential for providing an efficient approximation solutions to MDPs. Commonly used approximation algorithms involving constructing basis functions for projecting the value function onto a low dimensional subspace, and building a factored or hierarchical graphical model to decompose the transition and reward functions. However, hand-coding a good compact representation for a given reinforcement learning (RL) task can be quite difficult and time consuming. Recent approaches have attempted to automatically discover efficient representations for RL. In this thesis proposal, we discuss the problems of automatically constructing structured kernel for kernel based RL, a popular approach to learning non-parametric approximations for value function. We explore a space of kernel structures which are built compositionally from base kernels using a context-free grammar. We examine a greedy algorithm for searching over the structure space. To demonstrate how the learned structure can represent and approximate the original RL problem in terms of compactness and efficiency, we plan to evaluate our method on a synthetic problem and compare it to other RL baselines.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2015learning,
  author = {Yanping Huang},
  title = {{Learning Efficient Representations for Reinforcement Learning}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1509.02413},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1509.02413},
}
Figure