Learning Delayed Influences of Biological Systems

Tony Ribeiro, Morgan Magnin, Katsumi Inoue, Chiaki SakamaFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Boolean networks are widely used models to represent gene interactions and global dynamical behavior of gene regulatory networks. To understand the memory effect involved in some interactions between biological components, it is necessary to include delayed influences in the model. In this paper, we present a logical method to learn such models from sequences of gene expression data. This method analyzes each sequence one by one to iteratively construct a Boolean network that captures the dynamics of these observations. To illustrate the merits of this approach, we apply it to learning real data from bioinformatic literature. Using data from the yeast cell cycle, we give experimental results and show the scalability of the method. We show empirically that using this method we can handle millions of observations and successfully capture delayed influences of Boolean networks.

Introduction

In systems biology, Boolean Networks (BNs) serve as a fundamental framework for modeling the regulatory logic of genetic interactions. Traditionally, these models assume that the state of a gene at time $t+1$ is determined solely by the states of its regulators at time $t$. However, biological reality is often characterized by significant time delays. Processes such as DNA repair, protein synthesis, and the mammalian circadian clock rely on "memory," where an event at one time point triggers a response several steps later.

Example of a feedforward loop illustrating how signals can travel through direct and indirect paths with different delays.

A classic example of this is the feedforward loop (Figure 1), where a signal reaches a target through both a direct, fast path and an indirect, slow path. Existing inference methods often struggle with the computational complexity of modeling these delays, typically failing to scale beyond small networks or short memory windows. This research introduces a computationally efficient method to learn delayed influences from large-scale gene expression datasets.

Methods: The LFkT Algorithm

The authors propose LFkT (Learning from $k$-step Transitions), an advancement of the LFIT algorithm rooted in Inductive Logic Programming (ILP). Instead of relying on complex differential equations, LFkT represents biological interactions as formal logic statements. For instance, a rule might state: "Gene C is active if Gene A was active two steps ago AND Gene B was active one step ago."

Key Technical Components

  • Timed Herbrand Bases: The logic framework is extended to include time-stamped variables ($v_{t-i}$), allowing the model to "look back" $k$ steps into the past to identify delayed influences.
  • Minimal Specialization: The algorithm employs a "bottom-up" approach. It begins with the most general possible rules and iteratively refines them only when they are contradicted by observed data. This ensures the final model is the simplest representation consistent with the evidence.
  • Iterative Learning: LFkT processes sequences of gene expression (traces) sequentially, updating its internal logic program dynamically. This iterative nature allows it to handle massive datasets without re-processing the entire history at every step.

Experimental Validation and Results

The method was validated using two primary sources: real-world time-series data from the yeast cell cycle (Spellman et al., 1998; Cho et al., 1998) and synthetic benchmarks designed to test scalability.

Scalability and Performance

A major breakthrough of this work is the algorithm's linear scaling with respect to the number of observations. While many existing methods face exponential complexity growth, LFkT successfully processed one million observations in under 10 hours on standard hardware. Furthermore, the researchers found that learning time-delayed rules is not inherently more difficult than learning immediate ones; in the yeast cell cycle model, a 3-step delay model was learned faster than a 1-step model because the underlying logic was more concise.

Biological Insights

When applied to the yeast cell cycle, LFkT accurately captured delayed correlations between genes that traditional static models would overlook. The system demonstrated the ability to handle "memory effects" of up to 7 time steps without the computational "explosion" typical of previous attempts.

Discussion and Future Directions

While LFkT offers a scalable solution for learning delayed influences, several challenges remain. The discretization of continuous biological data into binary Boolean values can introduce noise and potential errors. Additionally, the current model assumes a synchronous update rhythm, whereas biological systems are often asynchronous. Future work will explore multi-valued networks (e.g., "low," "medium," "high" states) to better capture the nuances of biological behavior beyond simple on/off switches.

References

Ribeiro, T., Magnin, M., Inoue, K., & Sakama, C. (2015). Learning delayed influences of biological systems. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 2, 81.

Summary updated

Abstract

Boolean networks are widely used model to represent gene interactions and global dynamical behavior of gene regulatory networks. To understand the memory effect involved in some interactions between biological components, it is necessary to include delayed influences in the model. In this paper, we present a logical method to learn such models from sequences of gene expression data. This method analyzes each sequence one by one to iteratively construct a Boolean network that captures the dynamics of these observations. To illustrate the merits of this approach, we apply it to learning real data from bioinformatic literature. Using data from the yeast cell cycle, we give experimental results and show the scalability of the method. We show empirically that using this method we can handle millions of observations and successfully capture delayed influences of Boolean networks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ribeiro2015learning,
  author = {Tony Ribeiro and Morgan Magnin and Katsumi Inoue and Chiaki Sakama},
  title = {{Learning Delayed Influences of Biological Systems}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2014.00081},
}
Figure