Learning better by learning together: dyadic visual perceptual learning on orientation discrimination

Yifei Zhang, Jian Li, Yizhou Wang, Fang FangbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Learning with a partner significantly boosts low-level visual perceptual learning (VPL), leading to faster learning and better performance compared to training alone. This social enhancement is mediated by increased connectivity between early visual areas and higher-level social cognition regions, suggesting that social context can profoundly influence even fundamental sensory processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's well-established that social interaction can enhance complex learning tasks (like those involving value or decision-making), it's been unclear whether social context can also influence "low-level" perceptual learning. This type of learning, like improving the ability to distinguish subtle visual differences, is fundamental to our sensory experience. The authors aimed to bridge this gap by investigating if learning with a partner could accelerate and improve VPL, and what neural mechanisms underpin this social facilitation.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel "dyadic VPL paradigm" where pairs of participants trained on an orientation discrimination task together, with the ability to see each other's performance. This was compared to a traditional "single VPL" paradigm where participants trained alone.

Key methods included:

  • Psychophysics: Measuring behavioral performance (orientation discrimination thresholds) before, during, and after training to quantify learning speed and improvement.
  • Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI): Used to observe brain activity and functional connectivity during training.
  • MVPA (Multivariate Pattern Analysis): Applied to fMRI data to decode orientation representations in visual areas, assessing how training refined neural representations.
  • PPI (Psychophysiological Interaction) Analysis: Used to investigate how functional connectivity between specific brain regions (seed regions like dlPFC, IPL) and early visual cortex was modulated by the training condition (dyadic vs. single).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used human participants for behavioral and fMRI experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Social context isn't just for "high-level" learning: The study demonstrates that social interaction can significantly impact fundamental perceptual skills, not just complex cognitive tasks.
  • Learning with a partner is more than just more practice: The dyadic setup, even when simplified to equalize feedback and response numbers, still showed facilitation, pointing to the social aspect itself as the driver.
  • Partner performance matters: The degree of VPL facilitation was modulated by how well the learning partner performed, suggesting a role for social comparison.
  • Brain rewiring for social learning: Dyadic training led to distinct patterns of activity and enhanced functional connections between social cognition areas (parietal cortex, dlPFC) and early visual cortex (V1, LO). This suggests a neural mechanism where higher-level social processing directly influences sensory processing.
  • Refined neural representations: Dyadic training resulted in more precise orientation representations in early visual areas, correlating with better behavioral outcomes.

Key Results

  • Behavioral Improvement: Participants in the dyadic training group showed significantly greater performance improvement and a faster learning rate compared to the single training group (Experiment 1).
  • Partner Influence: Learning was further enhanced when the partner performed better (Experiment 2). Participants paired with a low-aptitude partner showed no significant VPL facilitation, even with more feedback, suggesting the social comparison aspect was crucial.
  • Neural Refinement: fMRI revealed that dyadic training led to more refined orientation representations in early visual areas (V1 and LO) compared to single training (Experiment 3).
  • Enhanced Connectivity: Dyadic training showed increased functional connectivity between higher-level social cognition areas (bilateral parietal cortex, left dlPFC) and early visual cortex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanisms of Social Facilitation: While the study identifies neural correlates, the precise mechanisms by which social context modulates VPL (e.g., motivation, social comparison, attention) are still being explored. Experiment 2 provided evidence against simple feedback/response count explanations.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on orientation discrimination. Future work could explore if these dyadic learning effects extend to other types of perceptual learning or even more complex cognitive tasks.
  • Clinical Applications: The authors suggest that this dyadic VPL paradigm could be a more tolerable, less costly, and safer alternative to existing add-on methods for enhancing VPL, offering a promising avenue for treating visual disorders. Further research could explore its efficacy in clinical populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The belief that learning can be modulated by social context is mainly supported by high-level value-based learning studies. However, whether social context can even modulate low-level learning such as visual perceptual learning (VPL) is still unknown. Unlike traditional VPL studies in which participants were trained singly, here we developed a novel dyadic VPL paradigm in which paired participants were trained with the same orientation discrimination task and they could monitor each other’s performance. We found that the social context (i.e., dyadic training) led to a greater behavioral performance improvement and a faster learning speed, compared with the single training. Interestingly, the facilitating effects could be modulated by the performance difference between paired participants. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) results showed that, compared with the single training, social cognition areas including bilateral parietal cortex and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex displayed a different spatial activity pattern and enhanced functional connectivities to early visual cortex during the dyadic training. Furthermore, the dyadic training resulted in more refined orientation representation in primary visual cortex (V1), which was closely associated with the greater behavioral performance improvement. Taken together, we demonstrate that the social context, learning with a partner, can remarkably augment the plasticity of low-level visual information process by means of reshaping the neural activities in early visual cortex and social cognition areas, as well as their functional interplays.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2022learning,
  author = {Yifei Zhang and Jian Li and Yizhou Wang and Fang Fang},
  title = {{Learning better by learning together: dyadic visual perceptual learning on orientation discrimination}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.06.10.495635},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure