Abstract
This paper introduces the Stochastic Generative Adversarial Network (SGAN), a novel GAN variant designed specifically to learn stochastic transition models for reinforcement learning. By implementing dense interpolation sampling and a modified discriminator loss, SGAN effectively captures complex probability distributions over next states, overcoming the "hedging" problem common in deterministic deep networks and the instability of standard GANs. Evaluations on synthetic grid worlds and a real-world physical marble domain demonstrate SGAN's superior ability to generalize and accurately represent stochastic transitions in high-dimensional state spaces.
Introduction
In model-based reinforcement learning (RL), an agent relies on a transition model to predict the next state given its current state and action. While many simulated environments are deterministic, real-world scenarios are inherently stochastic. Traditional modeling approaches often fail in these settings: tabular models do not generalize to unseen states, while deterministic deep networks tend to "hedge their bets" by predicting the mean of all possible next states. This results in blurry, non-physical predictions where an agent might appear in multiple locations simultaneously. Even standard GANs, such as the Gradient Penalty Wasserstein GAN (GP-WGAN), often struggle to capture the fine-grained details of transition probabilities required for effective RL.
The SGAN Framework
To address these challenges, the authors propose SGAN, which introduces two core innovations to the GP-WGAN architecture to provide a more robust training signal for the discriminator:
- Dense Interpolation Sampling: Unlike GP-WGAN, which calculates a gradient penalty at a single random point between real and generated samples, SGAN samples multiple points along the path. The number of samples ($T$) is proportional to the distance between the two points ($T = |x_r - x_g|/\delta$), providing a much denser signal to the discriminator.
- Modified Discriminator Loss: The loss function encourages the discriminator's gradient to align with the vector pointing from the generated state to the real state. Theoretically, this causes the discriminator to converge to a function representing the difference between the cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) of the real and generated data.
- Feature Retention Loss: For environments with complex, non-informative backgrounds, an optional loss term ensures the generator maintains its sensitivity to the random noise input, preventing it from "ignoring" the stochastic elements of the transition.
Experimental Evaluation
The SGAN model was evaluated across several benchmarks, ranging from simple synthetic grids to complex real-world video data.
Synthetic Grid Worlds
In 1D and 2D grid environments with predefined movement probabilities (e.g., 80% North, 10% West, 10% East), SGAN significantly outperformed GP-WGAN, showing an average improvement of 0.128 in L1 loss and a 3% increase in sample validity. In a more challenging "Random Background" task, SGAN maintained high accuracy (94% sample validity) where tabular learners failed entirely due to the complexity of the state space.
Physical Marble Domain
The model was also tested on a real-world dataset consisting of over 22,000 transition pairs from a video of a marble hitting a pillar and deflecting randomly. This task requires the model to understand complex physics and stochasticity directly from raw pixels.
SGAN was the only model capable of generating diverse, valid sequences of the marble's movement. Deterministic models collapsed to a single average path, while standard GP-WGAN produced significantly less diverse outcomes compared to the ground truth.
Key Insights
- Avoiding the Mean: By using an adversarial framework, SGAN avoids the "hedging" problem of MSE-based models, producing single valid outcomes rather than blurry averages.
- Generalization vs. Memorization: SGAN demonstrates the ability to learn underlying physical rules, allowing it to predict transitions for states not present in the training set, a feat impossible for tabular models.
- Dense Signal: The distance-aware sampling strategy provides the discriminator with the necessary information to accurately model the "shape" of the underlying probability distribution, leading to more stable training.
Conclusion and Future Work
SGAN represents a significant step forward in learning stochastic transition models for RL. While it excels at capturing probabilistic nuances, there is a noted trade-off between stochastic accuracy and visual image quality, with SGAN-generated images sometimes exhibiting more artifacts than deterministic counterparts. Future research will focus on improving visual fidelity and reducing the computational overhead of the dense sampling strategy to make SGAN more applicable to high-resolution, complex environments.
Summary updated