TL;DR
This paper introduces the first method for learning and solving Regular Decision Processes (RDPs), a type of non-Markovian decision-making model. By representing RDPs as Mealy Machines, they enable the application of existing machine learning techniques to learn these complex dynamics from data, paving the way for more realistic AI in domains where history matters.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Many real-world scenarios, particularly in areas like personal health tracking, involve decision-making where the optimal action depends not just on the current state, but on a complex history of past events and observations. Standard Reinforcement Learning (RL) models, like Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), assume a "Markovian" property, meaning the future only depends on the present state, not the entire past. This assumption breaks down in many practical applications, leading to suboptimal behavior. Regular Decision Processes (RDPs) were introduced to address this by allowing history-dependent dynamics, but crucially, this dependence is restricted to "regular" properties (like those expressible by regular expressions). While RDPs can be solved if their dynamics are known, learning them from data has been an open challenge. This paper tackles this challenge: how can we learn the complex, history-dependent rules of an RDP from observed interactions?
Methods
The core innovation of this paper lies in representing RDPs using Mealy Machines. A Mealy Machine is a type of finite-state transducer that emits an output based on its current state and input. In this context, the Mealy Machine's state captures relevant historical information, and its output provides the probability distribution over the next state and the associated reward. This representation is key because it allows the authors to leverage existing Mealy Machine learning algorithms (specifically, they use Flexfringe) to learn the RDP's dynamics from data.
The learning process involves several steps:
- Data Collection: Traces of states, actions, and rewards are collected by interacting with the environment.
- History Clustering: Similar histories are grouped together based on their empirical next-state distributions, using KL Divergence as a distance metric. This is crucial because many different histories might exhibit similar underlying dynamics due to the "regular" nature of RDPs.
- Mealy Machine Generation: The clustered histories and their associated distributions are used as input to a Mealy Machine learning algorithm, which learns a model that maps historical states (represented by the Mealy Machine's state) and actions to output distributions and rewards.
- MDP Transformation and Solving: The learned Mealy Machine is then combined with the RDP's state space to form an explicit MDP. This MDP can then be solved using standard techniques, or more directly, Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS), adapted for RDPs, can be used to find an optimal policy.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, they create three variations of two synthetic domains to evaluate their algorithm:
- Non Markovian Multi-Arm Bandit (MAB): Three variations (Rotating MAB, Malfunction MAB, Cheat MAB) where reward probabilities depend on the history of actions and rewards, making them two-state RDPs.
- Rotating Maze: A grid-world navigation task where agent orientation changes regularly based on history, affecting action outcomes.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Mealy Machines as a Unifying Representation: The paper's central insight is that RDPs can be elegantly represented by Mealy Machines. This bridges the gap between complex, history-dependent dynamics and established machine learning techniques for learning finite-state transducers.
- History Clustering is Crucial: Directly learning from every individual history is infeasible due to sparsity and noise. Clustering similar histories based on their empirical distributions is essential for generalizing and learning robust dynamics.
- Model-Based RL for Non-Markovian Domains: By learning a model (the Mealy Machine) of the RDP, the approach falls under the umbrella of model-based RL, which is generally more sample-efficient than model-free methods.
- Smart Sampling Improves Learning: The "Smart Sampling" strategy, which biases exploration towards actions that are less explored or have potentially higher rewards based on the partially learned model, significantly outperforms pure random exploration, especially in more complex domains.
Key Results
The proposed algorithm, S3M (Sample, Merge, Mealy Machine), was evaluated on the synthetic domains.
- Near-Optimal Policies: Both "Random Sampler" and "Smart Sampler" versions of S3M were able to learn near-optimal policies, outperforming a baseline RMax algorithm that incorrectly assumes Markovian dynamics.
- Smart Sampler Advantage: The "Smart Sampler" consistently achieved better performance and faster convergence, especially in the more complex "Cheat MAB" domain, demonstrating the benefit of informed exploration.
- RMax Baseline Failure: The RMax algorithm, which treats RDP states as MDP states, performed poorly, highlighting the necessity of handling non-Markovian dependencies.
- Correlation between Sampling and Policy Quality: The authors observed a strong correlation between the quality of samples collected during exploration and the quality of the learned policy.
Limitations and Future Work
- Synthetic Domains: The evaluation was conducted on synthetic domains. Future work should explore real-world applications to further validate the approach.
- Sampling and Aggregation: The authors acknowledge that there is "much room for improvement, especially in methods for better sampling and better aggregation of histories." Developing more sophisticated exploration strategies and history clustering techniques could enhance performance.
- Scalability: While the approach shows promise, the scalability to very large state spaces or extremely long histories is not explicitly addressed.
- LDLf Formulas: The paper simplifies the exposition by referring to regular expressions instead of the full Linear Dynamic Logic on Finite Traces (LDLf) used in RDP definitions. A deeper integration with LDLf could offer more expressive power and finer-grained control.
Summary updated