LE-MDCAP: A Computational Model to Prioritize Causal miRNA-Disease Associations

Zhou Huang, Yu Han, Leibo Liu, Qinghua Cui, Yuan ZhouInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces LE-MDCAP, a novel computational model designed to distinguish between causal and non-causal miRNA-disease associations. By leveraging Levenshtein distance to capture diverse miRNA similarities, LE-MDCAP significantly improves the accuracy of identifying miRNAs directly involved in disease mechanisms, offering a more precise tool for understanding disease pathogenesis and developing targeted therapies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are small non-coding RNAs that play crucial roles in regulating gene expression and are increasingly implicated in a wide range of human diseases. While many computational models exist to predict general miRNA-disease associations, a significant gap remains in accurately identifying causal associations – those where a miRNA is directly involved in the disease's molecular mechanisms. Distinguishing these causal miRNAs from those that are merely differentially expressed (non-causal) is critical for gaining deep insights into disease pathogenesis and for developing effective therapeutic interventions. Existing models often struggle with this distinction, leading to a need for more specialized approaches.

Methods

The core innovation of LE-MDCAP lies in its enhanced similarity calculations and integration strategy. The model builds upon previous work by incorporating Levenshtein distance, a metric for quantifying the difference between two sequences, to measure miRNA similarities across multiple dimensions:

  • Sequence Similarity: Levenshtein distance is applied to pre-miRNA, mature miRNA, and seed sequences.
  • Expression Similarity: miRNA expression data across different cell types is represented as strings, and Levenshtein distance is used to quantify their similarity.
  • Functional Similarity: This is captured by analyzing the overlap of targeted biological processes and signaling pathways, also using Levenshtein distance on pathway enrichment data.

These Levenshtein-distance-based similarity matrices are then integrated with a disease semantic similarity matrix (derived from MeSH database) and known causal miRNA-disease associations. A matrix decomposition algorithm is employed to predict causal association scores. The final prediction score is a weighted sum of scores derived from the different similarity matrices, with the Levenshtein-based similarities playing a dominant role.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the HMDD v3.2 database, which contains experimentally verified causal miRNA-disease associations. For comparison and validation, the authors utilized a subset of this data, specifically focusing on 4228 causal associations between 535 miRNAs and 302 diseases. This dataset was divided into training and testing sets for cross-validation and independent testing. The study also references the miRBase database for miRNA sequence information and the MeSH database for disease semantic similarity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Levenshtein Distance is Key: The paper strongly suggests that Levenshtein distance is a powerful tool for capturing nuanced similarities between miRNAs, going beyond simple sequence matching to encompass expression patterns and functional roles.
  • Causality Matters: The distinction between causal and non-causal miRNA-disease associations is not trivial and requires specialized models. LE-MDCAP demonstrates that focusing on this distinction can lead to more biologically relevant predictions.
  • Multi-faceted Similarity is Crucial: Integrating various types of miRNA similarity (sequence, expression, function) provides a more comprehensive view of miRNA relationships, leading to improved predictive performance.
  • Prioritization is Possible: LE-MDCAP effectively prioritizes potential causal miRNAs, not only from a large pool of unassociated pairs but also from a set of non-causal associations, which is a significant advancement.

Key Results

LE-MDCAP demonstrated strong performance in predicting causal miRNA-disease associations:

  • 10-fold Cross-Validation: Achieved an Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUROC) of 0.911.
  • Independent Test: Achieved an AUROC of 0.906.
  • Distinguishing Causal vs. Non-Causal: This was a key focus, where LE-MDCAP significantly outperformed the previous MDCAP model, achieving an AUROC of 0.820 compared to MDCAP's 0.695. Statistical tests confirmed a significant difference in prediction scores between causal and non-causal groups.
  • Case Studies:
    • For diabetic retinopathy, 8 out of the top 15 predicted causal miRNA-disease associations were validated by recent literature not included in the training data.
  • For hsa-mir-361, 10 out of the top 15 predicted causal disease associations were also supported by recent experimental reports.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Limited Prediction Space: The model's prediction space is currently limited to diseases present in the causal miRNA-disease association dataset. It cannot predict associations for entirely new diseases without known causal links.
  • MDCAP Performance: While LE-MDCAP excels at distinguishing causal from non-causal associations, the paper notes that MDCAP achieved higher AUROC scores for the broader task of distinguishing causal from non-disease associations (0.928 vs. 0.906 for LE-MDCAP).
  • MiRNA-Gene Targeting Features: Incorporating miRNA-gene targeting information showed only marginal improvement in distinguishing causal from unrelated miRNA-disease pairs. However, the authors suggest this could be a promising avenue for future improvements.
  • Disease Semantic Similarity: Enhancing the disease semantic similarity matrix is proposed as another way to potentially improve model performance.
  • Literature Mining: Developing score functions that leverage literature mining could help extract additional features for causal miRNA-disease association prediction.

Summary updated

Abstract

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are associated with various complex human diseases and some miRNAs can be directly involved in the mechanisms of disease. Identifying disease-causative miRNAs can provide novel insight in disease pathogenesis from a miRNA perspective and facilitate disease treatment. To date, various computational models have been developed to predict general miRNA-disease associations, but few models are available to further prioritize causal miRNA-disease associations from non-causal associations. Therefore, in this study, we constructed a Levenshtein-Distance-Enhanced miRNA-disease Causal Association Predictor (LE-MDCAP), to predict potential causal miRNA-disease associations. Specifically, Levenshtein distance matrixes covering the sequence, expression and functional miRNA similarities were introduced to enhance the previous Gaussian interaction profile kernel-based similarity matrix. LE-MDCAP integrated miRNA similarity matrices, disease semantic similarity matrix and known causal miRNA-disease associations to make predictions. For regular causal vs. non-disease association discrimination task, LF-MDCAP achieved area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) of 0.911 and 0.906 in 10-fold cross-validation and independent test, respectively. More importantly, LE-MDCAP prominently outperformed the previous MDCAP model in distinguishing causal versus non-causal miRNA-disease associations (AUROC 0.820 vs. 0.695). Case studies performed on diabetic retinopathy and hsa-mir-361 also validated the accuracy of our model. In summary, LE-MDCAP could be useful for screening causal miRNA-disease associations from general miRNA-disease associations.
BibTeX
@article{huang2021le,
  author = {Zhou Huang and Yu Han and Leibo Liu and Qinghua Cui and Yuan Zhou},
  title = {{LE-MDCAP: A Computational Model to Prioritize Causal miRNA-Disease Associations}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms222413607},
}
Figure