Abstract
We synthesize and study single crystals of the layered honeycomb lattice Mott insulators ${\mathrm{Na}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$ and ${\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$ with magnetic ${\mathrm{Ru}}^{4+}(4{d}^{4})$ ions. The newly found ${\mathrm{Na}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$ features a nearly ideal honeycomb lattice and orders antiferromagnetically at 30 K. Single crystals of ${\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$ adopt a honeycomb lattice with either $C2/m$ or more distorted $P{2}_{1}/m$ below 300 K, depending on detailed synthesis conditions. We find that ${\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$ in both structures hosts a well-defined magnetic state, in contrast to the singlet ground state found in polycrystalline ${\mathrm{Li}}_{2}{\mathrm{RuO}}_{3}$. A phase diagram generated based on our results uncovers a new, direct correlation between the magnetic ground state and basal-plane distortions in the honeycomb ruthenates.
Introduction
The honeycomb lattice is a cornerstone of modern condensed matter physics, serving as a platform for exotic quantum states like the Kitaev spin liquid. While honeycomb iridates have been extensively studied, their ruthenate counterparts, such as Li$_2$RuO$_3$, have presented a puzzle. Previous studies on polycrystalline samples of Li$_2$RuO$_3$ (powders) reported a non-magnetic "singlet" ground state due to extreme structural dimerization, where magnetic moments cancel each other out. This research investigates whether this state is intrinsic or a byproduct of synthesis, by examining high-quality single crystals of Li$_2$RuO$_3$ and the newly synthesized Na$_2$RuO$_3$.
Methods
The researchers synthesized single crystals using a self-flux method at 1250°C, significantly higher than the 950°C typically used for polycrystalline powders. This temperature difference proved crucial for crystal quality and preventing the extreme lattice distortions seen in previous studies. Structural characterization was performed via X-ray diffraction to determine space groups ($C2/m$ vs. $P2_1/m$) and measure specific Ru-Ru bond distances. Magnetic susceptibility ($\chi$) and specific heat ($C(T)$) measurements were used to identify phase transitions. Additionally, Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations (LDA and GGA+U) provided insight into the electronic structure and the interplay of spin-orbit coupling (SOC) and Coulomb repulsion.
Results and Discussion
The study reveals a direct correlation between lattice distortion and magnetic stability. Na$_2$RuO$_3$ was found to possess a nearly ideal honeycomb lattice with minimal distortion and serves as the ideal reference material for this family. It exhibits a sharp antiferromagnetic transition at $T_N = 30$ K. In contrast, single crystals of Li$_2$RuO$_3$ (phases C and P) showed magnetic ordering at 9 K and 4 K, respectively, which was previously absent in powder samples.
The structural analysis in Table 1 shows that the "basal-plane distortion"—quantified by the ratio between long and short Ru-Ru bonds—is a critical tuning parameter. As this distortion increases, the magnetic ordering temperature $T_N$ drops. The sensitivity of these materials arises from a competition of energy scales: in $4d^4$ ions, spin-orbit coupling, crystal field splitting, and exchange interactions all reside around the 0.1 eV range. This parity makes the magnetic ground state exceptionally responsive to small structural changes.
Table 2 summarizes the magnetic characteristics of the synthesized crystals. Notably, the effective magnetic moment for the Li$_2$RuO$_3$ (C) phase was measured at 2.77 $\mu_B$/Ru, consistent with an $S=1$ system. This confirms that high-quality synthesis "unlocks" magnetic states by preventing the extreme dimerization seen in powders, where the distortion reached 18.6%.
Conclusion
By establishing a new phase diagram, the authors demonstrate that the magnetism of $4d^4$ ruthenates is highly tunable via subtle lattice distortions. While the exact spin configuration (e.g., zigzag order) remains to be determined by future neutron diffraction studies, this work provides a definitive link between structural symmetry and the emergence of magnetic order in honeycomb lattices. The discovery of magnetic ordering in Li$_2$RuO$_3$ single crystals suggests that the previously reported singlet state is a result of structural instability rather than an intrinsic property of the honeycomb ruthenate system.
Summary updated