Lattice Simulations near the Semimetal-Insulator Phase Transition of Graphene

Wesley Armour, Simon Hands, Costas StrouthosarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present results from Monte Carlo simulations of a three dimensional fermionic field theory which can be derived from a model of graphene in which electrons interact via a screened Coulomb potential. For our simulations we employ lattice gauge theory methods used in elementary particle physics. We show that the theory undergoes a second order phase transition and we provide estimates for the critical exponents. The estimated value of the physical critical coupling implies that graphene in vacuum is an insulator. We also present the first results for the quasiparticle dispersion relation.

Introduction

Graphene is renowned for its unique electronic structure, specifically its "Dirac cones" where electrons behave as massless relativistic particles. A fundamental question in condensed matter physics is whether the strong Coulomb interactions between these electrons can induce a phase transition. If the interaction is sufficiently strong, electrons and holes may form pairs and condense, opening an energy gap and transforming the semimetallic graphene into an insulator. While graphene on substrates like silicon dioxide remains semimetallic, the behavior of freely suspended graphene in a vacuum has been a subject of intense theoretical debate. This study aims to identify the critical coupling point where this transition occurs.

Methodology

The research utilizes Monte Carlo simulations of a (2+1)-dimensional Thirring-like model, a field theory that captures the dynamics of graphene's electrons under a screened Coulomb potential. Given the strong interaction regime, standard perturbative methods are inapplicable. Instead, the authors adapt Lattice Gauge Theory techniques from high-energy physics, discretizing spacetime into a 3D grid.

Simulations were conducted on various lattice sizes ($24^2 \times 48$, $32^2 \times 48$, and $48^3$) to mitigate finite-size effects. The study focused on $N_f = 2$ fermion flavors, reflecting the physical degeneracy in graphene. Key parameters varied included the fermion bare mass ($m_0 \in [0.005, 0.025]$) and the coupling strength ($g^{-2} \in [0.4, 1.2]$). The primary order parameter measured was the "chiral condensate" ($\langle \bar{\psi}\psi \rangle$), which signals the onset of the insulating phase.

Results and Discussion

The simulations provide strong evidence for a continuous, second-order phase transition between the semimetal and insulator phases. The critical coupling was determined to be $g_c^{-2} = 0.607(5)$.

The chiral condensate as a function of the inverse coupling for various fermion masses.

By analyzing the scaling of the chiral condensate, the authors extracted critical exponents $\delta = 2.72(7)$ and $\beta = 0.68(2)$. These values are essential for categorizing the system's universality class. Crucially, the calculated physical critical coupling $\lambda_c = 2.54(2)$ is lower than the estimated coupling for graphene in vacuum ($\lambda_0 \approx 3.4$), suggesting that vacuum-suspended graphene is naturally an insulator.

Furthermore, the study presents the first results for the quasiparticle dispersion relation within this model. The energy-momentum data fits well with discretized free-field equations, validating the lattice approach.

Quasiparticle dispersion relation E(p) showing the energy-momentum relationship for different coupling strengths.

The dynamic critical exponent was estimated at $z \approx 0.89$. A value of $z < 1$ is physically significant as it implies that quasiparticle excitations are stable against decay into multiple particles. Additionally, the simulations indicate that the Fermi velocity ($v_F$) is renormalized by interactions rather than being a fixed constant.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that lattice gauge theory methods can effectively probe the strong-coupling physics of graphene. The findings predict an insulating state for graphene in vacuum and provide a detailed characterization of the phase transition. Future research will focus on larger lattices to improve momentum resolution and a more precise determination of the dynamic critical exponent $z$. These numerical benchmarks will be vital for comparison with future experimental measurements of suspended graphene.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present results from Monte Carlo simulations of a three dimensional fermionic field theory which can be derived from a model of graphene in which electrons interact via a screened Coulomb potential. For our simulations we employ lattice gauge theory methods used in elementary particle physics. We show that the theory undergoes a second order phase transition and we provide estimates for the critical exponents. The estimated value of the physical critical coupling implies that graphene in vacuum is an insulator. We also present the first results for the quasiparticle dispersion relation.
BibTeX
@misc{armour2009lattice,
  author = {Wesley Armour and Simon Hands and Costas Strouthos},
  title = {{Lattice Simulations near the Semimetal-Insulator Phase Transition of Graphene}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0908.0118},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0908.0118},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure