Lattice QCD in Rotating Frames

Arata Yamamoto, Yuji HironoPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully formulated and executed the first lattice QCD simulations in a rotating reference frame. By using a "Euclidean rotation" technique to bypass the notorious numerical sign problem, they were able to calculate the angular momentum density of gluons and quarks in the QCD vacuum for the first time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how matter behaves under extreme rotation is crucial for several areas of physics. In astrophysics, the cores of rapidly rotating neutron stars (pulsars) are thought to contain superfluid QCD matter. In high-energy physics, off-central heavy-ion collisions at facilities like RHIC or the LHC create a "quark-gluon plasma" with enormous angular momentum.

However, simulating these systems from first principles using Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is difficult. You cannot simply "add a rotation field" to a standard simulation. One solution is to perform the calculation in a rotating reference frame. The challenge here is that in standard "Minkowskian" (real-time) space, rotation introduces complex terms into the math that lead to a "sign problem," making standard Monte Carlo simulations impossible.

Methods

The authors propose a framework to study rotating QCD by transforming the coordinates to a rotating frame within the lattice formulation.

  • Euclidean Rotation: To solve the sign problem, the authors define the rotation in "Euclidean" space (imaginary time). By performing the spatial rotation after the Wick rotation ($t \to -i\tau$), the resulting action remains real, allowing for standard Monte Carlo techniques.
  • Rotational Metric: They incorporate a specific metric ($g_{\mu\nu}$) into the gluon and quark actions to account for the non-inertial frame.
  • Lattice Discretization: The continuum actions are discretized on a hypercubic lattice. This requires using "clover-type" and "chair-type" Wilson loops to construct the gluon field strength terms that arise from the rotation.
  • Simulation Setup: They performed a quenched SU(3) simulation (where the gluon vacuum is generated without dynamical quark loops) on a $13 \times 13 \times 12 \times 12$ lattice.

Datasets

The paper does not use external datasets. Instead, it generates its own configurations using Monte Carlo importance sampling. The simulation parameters included:

  • Lattice Spacing ($a$): $\approx 0.10$ fm.
  • Lattice Size: $N_x \times N_y \times N_z \times N_\tau = 13 \times 13 \times 12 \times 12$.
  • Boundary Conditions: Dirichlet in the $x$ and $y$ directions (to define a finite rotating volume) and standard periodic/anti-periodic conditions in $z$ and $\tau$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vacuum Response: The "empty" QCD vacuum actually has a physical response to rotation. When the frame rotates, the vacuum acquires a finite angular momentum density.
  • Classical Analogy: The vacuum behaves similarly to a collection of classical particles. In the rotating frame, the vacuum appears to rotate in the opposite direction (negative angular momentum), which is the state of minimum energy.
  • Decomposition of Momentum: The authors successfully separated the quark angular momentum into orbital and spin components.
  • Spatial Scaling: They found that orbital angular momentum (for both gluons and quarks) scales with the square of the distance from the rotation axis ($r^2$), while the spin component is intrinsic and independent of the distance.

Key Results

  • Moment of Inertia: The authors calculated the "moment of inertia" for the constituents of the QCD vacuum.
  • Linear Scaling with $\Omega$: For small angular velocities ($\Omega$), the angular momentum density $J$ increases linearly with $\Omega$.
  • Quantitative Densities: They extracted numerical coefficients for the angular momentum densities:
  • Gluon: $J_G \propto -0.94 \cdot r^2\Omega$
    • Quark Orbital: $J_{FL} \propto -0.60 \cdot r^2\Omega$
    • Quark Spin: $J_{FS} \propto -0.17 \cdot \Omega$
  • Sign Problem Avoidance: The study proves that Euclidean rotation is a viable numerical tool for studying rotating systems without encountering the sign problem, provided the results can be analytically continued back to real physics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Renormalization: The authors acknowledge that rotation might affect the physical scale and renormalization constants of the theory, a complex issue not fully addressed in this initial work.
  • Boundary Effects: The use of Dirichlet boundary conditions in the $x-y$ plane is necessary but may introduce artifacts near the edges of the lattice.
  • Quenched Approximation: This study used the "quenched" approximation (ignoring dynamical quarks in the vacuum generation). Future studies with "full" QCD (unquenched) are needed for higher precision.
  • High Rotation Limits: The simulation was restricted to small $\Omega$. Exploring very high rotation speeds—where the local velocity approaches the speed of light—remains a theoretical and numerical challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

We formulate lattice QCD in rotating frames to study the physics of QCD matter under rotation. We construct the lattice QCD action with the rotational metric and apply it to the Monte Carlo simulation. As the first application, we calculate the angular momenta of gluons and quarks in the rotating QCD vacuum. This new framework is useful to analyze various rotation-related phenomena in QCD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yamamoto2013lattice,
  author = {Arata Yamamoto and Yuji Hirono},
  title = {{Lattice QCD in Rotating Frames}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.111.081601},
}

Loading related content...

Figure