Lattice Calculation of the Intrinsic Soft Function and the Collins-Soper Kernel

Lattice Parton Collaboration, Min-Huan Chu, Jin-Chen He, Jun Hua, Jian Liang, Xiangdong Ji, Andreas Schäfer, Hai-Tao Shu, Yushan Su, Lisa Walter, Wei Wang, Ji-Hao Wang, Yi-Bo Yang, Jun Zeng, Qi-An ZhangarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We calculate the soft function using lattice QCD in the framework of large momentum effective theory incorporating the one-loop perturbative contributions. The soft function is a crucial ingredient in the lattice determination of light cone objects using transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) factorization. It consists of a rapidity-independent part called intrinsic soft function and a rapidity-dependent part called Collins-Soper kernel. We have adopted appropriate normalization when constructing the pseudo-scalar meson form factor that is needed in the determination of the intrinsic part and applied Fierz rearrangement to suppress the higher-twist effects. In the calculation of CS kernel we consider a CLS ensemble other than the MILC ensemble used in a previous study. We have also compared the applicability of determining the CS kernel using quasi TMDWFs and quasi TMDPDFs. As an example, the determined soft function is used to obtain the physical TMD wave functions (WFs) of pion and unpolarized iso-vector TMD parton distribution functions (PDFs) of proton.

Introduction

Understanding the internal 3D structure of hadrons, such as protons and pions, is a central goal of modern nuclear physics. Transverse-Momentum-Dependent (TMD) distributions provide the necessary framework to describe the 3D momentum of quarks and gluons, which is vital for interpreting high-energy collider data from the LHC and the future Electron-Ion Collider (EIC).

However, calculating these distributions from first principles using Lattice QCD is challenging. Lattice simulations are performed in Euclidean space (static), whereas TMD physics occurs on the light cone. The Large Momentum Effective Theory (LaMET) bridges this gap by relating "quasi-distributions" calculable on the lattice to physical light-cone distributions. A critical, yet historically elusive, component of this bridge is the soft function. This function accounts for non-canceling low-energy gluon radiation, and its precise determination is essential for converting lattice data into physical TMDs.

Methodology

The researchers calculated the two primary components of the soft function: the intrinsic soft function ($S_I$) and the Collins-Soper (CS) kernel ($K$).

Several technical advancements were implemented to improve precision:

  1. One-loop Matching: The study incorporates one-loop perturbative contributions, moving beyond tree-level approximations to better connect lattice results to the physical continuum.
  2. Fierz Rearrangement: By applying Fierz transformations to the operators, the team successfully suppressed "higher-twist" effects—theoretical noise that typically contaminates signals at lower energies.
  3. Operator Normalization: A robust normalization scheme was adopted for the pseudo-scalar meson form factors used to extract the intrinsic soft function.
Schematic representation of the operator structure used in the lattice calculation of the soft function.

The study also compared the effectiveness of using quasi-TMD Wave Functions (WFs) versus quasi-TMD Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) to extract the CS kernel. The results indicate that WFs provide more stable "plateaus" in the data, making them a more reliable probe for future studies.

Lattice Setup and Datasets

To ensure the universality of the results, the team utilized multiple lattice ensembles from different collaborations. This approach allows for a better estimation of systematic uncertainties related to discretization and finite volume effects.

Summary of the lattice ensembles used in this study, including CLS and MILC configurations.

The ensembles include:

  • CLS Ensembles (X650, A654): Generated with 2+1 flavors of dynamical clover fermions, used primarily to investigate spatial volume effects.
  • MILC Ensembles (a12m130, a12m310): Generated with 2+1+1 flavors of Highly Improved Staggered Quarks (HISQ).

The consistency of the intrinsic soft function across these different setups reinforces its status as a universal property of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD).

Key Results and Discussion

The extracted Collins-Soper kernel shows strong agreement with 3-loop perturbative QCD calculations at small transverse distances ($b_\perp$). Interestingly, at larger distances, the lattice results exhibit a slight tension with some recent global fits of experimental data (e.g., MAP22), suggesting that lattice QCD can provide valuable constraints to refine experimental models.

As a proof of concept, the calculated soft function was applied to determine:

  • Physical TMD wave functions for the pion.
  • Unpolarized iso-vector TMD PDFs for the proton.

These results demonstrate the expected mild dependence on energy scales ($\zeta$ and $\mu$), validating the theoretical framework.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While this work represents a significant step forward, certain limitations remain. At very small transverse separations ($b_\perp$), lattice discretization effects become prominent, necessitating future simulations with even finer lattice spacings. Additionally, the LaMET approach faces challenges at the extreme edges of momentum fraction ($x \to 0$ or $x \to 1$). Future research will also focus on using physical quark masses to eliminate the current reliance on heavier valence quarks, further improving the accuracy of the 3D proton map.

Summary updated

Abstract

We calculate the soft function using lattice QCD in the framework of large momentum effective theory incorporating the one-loop perturbative contributions. The soft function is a crucial ingredient in the lattice determination of light cone objects using transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) factorization. It consists of a rapidity-independent part called intrinsic soft function and a rapidity-dependent part called Collins-Soper kernel. We have adopted appropriate normalization when constructing the pseudo-scalar meson form factor that is needed in the determination of the intrinsic part and applied Fierz rearrangement to suppress the higher-twist effects. In the calculation of CS kernel we consider a CLS ensemble other than the MILC ensemble used in a previous study. We have also compared the applicability of determining the CS kernel using quasi TMDWFs and quasi TMDPDFs. As an example, the determined soft function is used to obtain the physical TMD wave functions (WFs) of pion and unpolarized iso-vector TMD parton distribution functions (PDFs) of proton.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2023lattice,
  author = {Lattice Parton Collaboration and Min-Huan Chu and Jin-Chen He and Jun Hua and Jian Liang and Xiangdong Ji and Andreas Schäfer and Hai-Tao Shu and Yushan Su and Lisa Walter and Wei Wang and Ji-Hao Wang and Yi-Bo Yang and Jun Zeng and Qi-An Zhang},
  title = {{Lattice Calculation of the Intrinsic Soft Function and the Collins-Soper Kernel}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2306.06488},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06488},
}
Figure