Latent variable graphical model selection via convex optimization

Venkat Chandrasekaran, Pablo A. Parrilo, Alan S. WillskyAllerton 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for selecting graphical models when some variables are unobserved (latent). It leverages convex optimization to simultaneously infer the structure of the observed variables and the number of latent components, offering a more complete statistical model than traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world applications, we observe only a subset of relevant variables, with others being latent or unobserved. Traditional graphical model selection methods, which assume all variables are observed, struggle with this scenario. They cannot directly infer the number of latent variables or their influence on the observed data. This gap makes it difficult to build comprehensive statistical models for complex systems where unobserved factors play a crucial role. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a method that can identify latent structures and model dependencies among observed variables simultaneously.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in a convex optimization framework that decomposes the marginal concentration matrix of the observed variables into two parts: a sparse matrix representing the conditional graphical model among observed variables, and a low-rank matrix capturing the effect of latent variables. This decomposition is achieved using a regularized maximum-likelihood approach. Specifically, they employ a convex program that penalizes the $l_1$ norm of the sparse component (encouraging sparsity) and the nuclear norm of the low-rank component (encouraging low rank). This approach combines techniques from dimensionality reduction (principal component analysis) and graphical modeling. They also develop theoretical conditions for the identifiability of these components, ensuring that the decomposition is unique and meaningful.

Datasets

The paper uses synthetic data for experiments, generated from three different latent-variable graphical models:

  1. A 36-node conditional graphical model with a cycle structure and 2 latent variables.
  2. A 36-node conditional graphical model with a cycle structure and 3 latent variables.
  3. A 36-node conditional graphical model with a 6x6 grid structure and 1 latent variable.

Additionally, they apply their method to real-world stock return data from 84 companies in the S&P 100 index.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposition is Key: The marginal concentration matrix of observed variables can be viewed as a sum of a sparse matrix (conditional dependencies) and a low-rank matrix (effect of latent variables). This decomposition is fundamental to their approach.
  • Convexity for Latent Variables: Traditional methods for latent variable models often involve non-convex optimization, leading to local minima. By formulating the problem as a convex optimization problem, they ensure a globally optimal solution.
  • Identifiability Matters: For the decomposition to be meaningful, the latent variable structure must be identifiable from the observed data alone. The paper establishes conditions for this identifiability, relating it to the geometric properties of algebraic varieties of sparse and low-rank matrices.
  • Bridging PCA and Graphical Models: The method can be seen as a fusion of principal component analysis (for latent variable discovery) and graphical modeling (for capturing conditional dependencies).

Key Results

  • Algebraic Correctness: The proposed convex optimization method is shown to provide "algebraically correct" estimates, meaning it recovers the correct sparsity pattern of the conditional graphical model and the correct rank of the latent variable component with high probability.
  • Consistency in High Dimensions: The theoretical results demonstrate that the estimator is consistent even in high-dimensional settings where the number of observed and latent variables can grow with the number of samples.
  • Improved Model Fit: Experiments on synthetic data show that their method achieves higher probabilities of correct estimation compared to standard graphical model selection. On stock return data, their latent variable model achieved a significantly lower KL divergence (better fit) than a standard sparse graphical model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While the method is polynomial-time solvable, developing more efficient specialized solvers for massive datasets is suggested.
  • Non-Gaussian Variables: The current framework is limited to Gaussian variables. Extending it to non-Gaussian or categorical data is an interesting future direction.
  • Parameter Selection: While theoretical guidance is provided for choosing regularization parameters, practical selection might still require methods like cross-validation.
  • Identifiability Conditions: The paper focuses on sufficient conditions for identifiability. Investigating necessary and sufficient conditions, analogous to Lasso, would be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chandrasekaran2010latent,
  author = {Venkat Chandrasekaran and Pablo A. Parrilo and Alan S. Willsky},
  title = {{Latent variable graphical model selection via convex optimization}},
  booktitle = {Allerton},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1109/allerton.2010.5707106},
}
Figure