Latent Time-Adaptive Drift-Diffusion Model

Gabriele Cimolino, François RivestarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Latent Time-Adaptive Drift-Diffusion Model (LTDDM), a novel neural network architecture designed to excel at learning temporal patterns in sequential data, particularly those with rhythmic structures. LTDDM significantly outperforms traditional recurrent neural networks like LSTMs in learning timing and duration of events, achieving this much faster by focusing on timing error rather than just prediction accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Animals possess a remarkable ability to learn the timing of events, even when those events occur over long or variable intervals, a property known as timescale invariance. Traditional deep learning models, especially recurrent neural networks (RNNs) like LSTMs, struggle with this. They often require an exponential increase in training data or time to learn long-term temporal dependencies, a significant limitation for tasks requiring precise timing. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a model that can learn temporal sequences with the efficiency and adaptability observed in animal learning.

Methods

The core innovation is the Latent Time-Adaptive Drift-Diffusion Model (LTDDM), an extension of the existing Time-Adaptive Drift-Diffusion Model (TDDM). The key enhancements are:

  • Latent Layer: LTDDM introduces a hidden layer of "timed latent variables." These act as intermediate representations that capture temporal features, allowing the model to learn more complex patterns than the original TDDM, which was limited to linear solutions.
  • Bi-stable Units: Unlike basic TDDM units that produce instantaneous events, LTDDM units are bi-stable (ON/OFF) and have accumulators for both ON and OFF states. This allows them to learn not just the timing but also the duration of events, crucial for rhythmic sequences.
  • Timing Error Gradient: LTDDM focuses on minimizing "timing error" (the difference between predicted and actual event times) rather than just instantaneous prediction error. This is achieved through a novel gradient descent approach that propagates timing error gradients through the network.
  • Hidden Unit Correction: The model incorporates a mechanism to correct hidden units based on the output layer's timing error. This allows the latent representations to adapt and better serve the downstream layers.

Datasets

The models were evaluated on three distinct time series datasets:

  • Heartbeat: Digital electrocardiogram signals, characterized by sparse events.
  • Music: A musical piece ("Die Naehterin's sass a Naehterin und sie naeht") parsed into tone indices and durations, representing a rhythmic sequence.
  • Stock: Daily closing prices of NASDAQ-100 companies, discretized to indicate price jumps.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Timing Error is Key for Temporal Learning: The paper strongly suggests that for tasks requiring precise temporal understanding, minimizing timing error directly is more effective than minimizing amplitude error at each time step.
  • LSTMs Struggle with Sparsity and Rhythm: LSTMs, while powerful, tend to "shut down" or replicate input when faced with sparse events or complex rhythmic structures, failing to learn meaningful temporal patterns.
  • LTDDM Learns Faster by Focusing on Timing: The LTDDM's ability to learn timing and duration, coupled with its timing error minimization strategy, allows it to converge significantly faster than LSTMs on temporal tasks.
  • Latent Representations Enhance Temporal Modeling: The introduction of latent timed variables is crucial for capturing complex, long-range temporal dependencies that are beyond the reach of simpler models.

Key Results

  • Faster Learning: LTDDM learned target sequences orders of magnitude faster than LSTM. For example, on the Heartbeat dataset, LTDDM converged in ~9,720 epochs, while LSTM took over 2.9 million epochs.
  • Superior Timing Accuracy: LTDDM demonstrated significantly better timing accuracy, especially on the Heartbeat dataset, where LSTM's performance was abysmal.
  • Mixed Performance on Amplitude Accuracy: While LTDDM excelled in timing, its statistical (amplitude) accuracy was sometimes lower than LSTM's, particularly on the stock dataset. This highlights the trade-off and the importance of choosing the right evaluation metric for temporal tasks.
  • LSTM's Reactive Behavior: On the Music dataset, LSTM exhibited a "reactive" behavior, essentially replicating input rather than learning the underlying timing, leading to surprisingly low STE despite its precision.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalization Not Fully Explored: The paper notes that generalization to other sequences was not investigated for LTDDM.
  • Statistical Accuracy Trade-off: The authors acknowledge the disconnect between LTDDM's strong timing accuracy and sometimes weaker statistical accuracy, suggesting this is an area for further investigation.
  • LSTM's Limitations: The paper raises questions about whether LSTMs can ever truly learn complex timing tasks like music generation if they struggle with basic rhythmic sequences.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this work could form the basis for deep learning models for animal timing, and further exploration of LTDDM's capabilities on more complex temporal tasks is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Animals can quickly learn the timing of events with fixed intervals and their rate of acquisition does not depend on the length of the interval. In contrast, recurrent neural networks that use gradient based learning have difficulty predicting the timing of events that depend on stimulus that occurred long ago. We present the latent time-adaptive drift-diffusion model (LTDDM), an extension to the time-adaptive drift-diffusion model (TDDM), a model for animal learning of timing that exhibits behavioural properties consistent with experimental data from animals. The performance of LTDDM is compared to that of a state of the art long short-term memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network across three timing tasks. Differences in the relative performance of these two models is discussed and it is shown how LTDDM can learn these events time series orders of magnitude faster than recurrent neural networks.
BibTeX
@misc{cimolino2021latent,
  author = {Gabriele Cimolino and François Rivest},
  title = {{Latent Time-Adaptive Drift-Diffusion Model}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2106.02742},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.02742},
}

Loading related content...

Figure