Latent Profile Analysis of Technophobia and Its Network Associations with Health Self-Care Behaviors among Older Adults in Rural China

Yao Sun, Shasha Li, Xiaofang Song, Yun Bao, Chao Ren, Mengxue Shi, Xinyu Yang, Guojing Guo, Sheng BiResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Introduction

As digital health technologies—ranging from wearable health monitors to telehealth platforms—become increasingly integrated into modern healthcare, a significant "digital divide" has emerged. This gap is particularly pronounced among older adults in rural areas, where technophobia—the irrational fear or avoidance of new technology—acts as a formidable barrier to health self-management. While previous research has often treated technophobia as a uniform condition, this study investigates its inherent heterogeneity. By identifying specific psychological profiles and mapping the network of connections between digital anxiety and health behaviors, researchers aim to provide a foundation for more precise, stratified interventions.

Methods

This cross-sectional study involved 466 older adults from rural regions in Huzhou City, Zhejiang Province, China. The research team employed a dual-methodological approach:

  1. Latent Profile Analysis (LPA): This person-centered technique was used to identify distinct subgroups (profiles) based on participants' responses to the Technophobia Scale, which measures three dimensions: technology tension, technology fear, and privacy/security concerns.
  2. Network Analysis: A variable-centered approach was used to visualize and quantify the complex interconnections between technophobia symptoms and health self-care behaviors. This identified "core symptoms" (central nodes) and "bridge symptoms" (links connecting fear to behavior).
Demographic characteristics and baseline technophobia scores of the study participants.

Key Findings: Five Profiles of Technophobia

The analysis revealed that technophobia is not a monolithic experience. Instead, five distinct profiles emerged among the rural elderly population:

  • Moderate tension–low fear (25.11%): Individuals who feel some pressure using technology but do not experience significant fear.
  • Low tension–moderate fear (20.17%): Those with low technical pressure but higher levels of underlying anxiety regarding technology.
  • Moderate tension–fear (34.33%): The largest group, experiencing both moderate tension and significant fear.
  • High tension–moderate fear (12.23%): Individuals facing high technical pressure and moderate fear.
  • High tension–low fear (8.15%): A smaller group that feels intense pressure but relatively low fear.

Notably, privacy and security concerns remained consistently high across all five profiles, suggesting that data safety is a universal concern for this demographic.

Detailed mean scores for the three dimensions of technophobia across the five identified latent profiles.

Network Structure and Health Behaviors

The network analysis highlighted how these psychological profiles interact with health self-care behaviors. Core symptoms were primarily found in health maintenance, belief formation, and medical resource utilization.

Specific "bridge symptoms" were identified as critical intervention targets because they connect the domain of technophobia to actual health actions:

  • In the "moderate tension–low fear" group, media health information (HBB1) served as a key bridge.
  • In the "low tension–moderate fear" group, acceptance (HBD7) was the primary bridge.
  • In the "moderate tension–fear" group, online health information (HBB3) linked fear to behavior.

Conclusion and Implications

Technophobia among rural older adults is highly heterogeneous. The identification of five distinct profiles and specific bridge symptoms suggests that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to digital health education is likely to be ineffective. Instead, interventions should be stratified:

  • For those with high privacy concerns: Focus on data security education and building trust in digital platforms.
  • For those with high tension: Simplify user interfaces and provide hands-on technical support.
  • Targeting Bridge Symptoms: Interventions focusing on specific behaviors like seeking online health information or fostering general acceptance could have a cascading positive effect on overall health self-care.

By addressing the specific psychological barriers unique to each profile, healthcare providers can better support rural seniors in navigating the digital health landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background This study aimed to identify heterogeneous latent profiles of technophobia among rural older adults and to explore the network structure linking technophobia and health self-care behaviors. Methods From August to October 2025, a total of 466 participants were recruited. Latent profile analysis was conducted using the Technophobia Scale, and the optimal model was determined based on fit indices and likelihood ratio tests. Network analysis was then employed to construct both overall and subgroup networks of technophobia and health self-care behaviors, identifying core and bridge symptoms. Network accuracy and stability were assessed through bootstrap procedures. Results Five subgroups were identified: “moderate tension–low fear,” “low tension–moderate fear,” “moderate tension–fear,” “high tension–moderate fear,” and “high tension–low fear.” Core symptoms were primarily distributed across three dimensions: health maintenance behavior, health belief formation behavior, and medical resource utilization behavior. Bridge symptoms varied across subgroups: HBB1 ( <italic>media health information</italic> ) in the “moderate tension–low fear” group; HBD7 ( <italic>acceptance</italic> ) in the “low tension–moderate fear” group; and HBB3 ( <italic>online health information</italic> ) in the “moderate tension– fear” group. Conclusions Technophobia among rural older adults exhibits distinct heterogeneity and forms specific network structures with health self-care behaviors. These findings provide a theoretical foundation for precision, stratified behavioral intervention strategies targeting diverse technophobia profiles in rural elderly populations. Trial registration Registered in the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry on 10/30/2025(ChiCTR2500111399)
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2025latent,
  author = {Yao Sun and Shasha Li and Xiaofang Song and Yun Bao and Chao Ren and Mengxue Shi and Xinyu Yang and Guojing Guo and Sheng Bi},
  title = {{Latent Profile Analysis of Technophobia and Its Network Associations with Health Self-Care Behaviors among Older Adults in Rural China}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-8067377/v1},
}
Figure