Laparoscopic hepatectomy for elderly patients

Ke Chen, Yu Pan, Hendi Maher, Bin Zhang, Xueyong ZhengMedicine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Laparoscopic hepatectomy (LH) is a safe and effective alternative to open hepatectomy (OH) for elderly patients, offering reduced postoperative morbidity and faster recovery. This meta-analysis of existing studies suggests that age should not be a contraindication for LH, as its benefits are comparable to those seen in younger patients.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global life expectancy increases, so does the proportion of elderly individuals requiring surgical interventions. Liver resections, particularly for cancer, are common, but the elderly population often presents with reduced physiological reserve and comorbidities, making them more vulnerable to the stresses of major surgery. While laparoscopic surgery (LS) generally offers advantages like less pain, faster recovery, and fewer complications compared to open surgery (OS), its specific application and benefits in the elderly liver surgery population remained unclear. This paper addresses the question of whether the advantages of LH over OH are maintained in elderly patients, and if LH is a safe and effective option for this demographic.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies comparing laparoscopic hepatectomy (LH) with open hepatectomy (OH) in elderly patients, as well as studies comparing LH in elderly versus non-elderly patients. They searched major medical databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science) for relevant articles published up to September 2017.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Inclusion Criteria: Studies comparing LH and OH in elderly patients, or comparing LH in elderly versus non-elderly patients.
  • Exclusion Criteria: Case reports, reviews, letters, editorials, and studies not involving liver surgery or including other major digestive surgeries.
  • Data Extraction: Two independent reviewers extracted data on operative time, blood loss, transfusion rates, conversion rates, length of hospital stay, morbidity (classified by Clavien-Dindo), mortality, margin status (R0), and long-term oncologic outcomes.
  • Quality Assessment: The Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale (NOS) was used to evaluate the quality of included observational studies.
  • Statistical Analysis: Meta-analysis was performed using fixed or random-effects models depending on heterogeneity. Dichotomous variables were analyzed using risk ratios (RR), and continuous variables using weighted mean differences (WMD), both with 95% confidence intervals (CI).

Datasets

This paper is a meta-analysis and does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesizes data from nine previously published studies that met the inclusion criteria. These studies collectively included 830 patients, with 388 undergoing LH and 442 undergoing OH. The studies originated from various international centers, including France, Italy, Japan, and China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LH is a Safe and Feasible Option for the Elderly: The primary takeaway is that LH is not only feasible but also a safe and beneficial alternative to OH for elderly patients undergoing liver resection.
  • Benefits of LH Persist in the Elderly: The well-established advantages of LH, such as reduced blood loss, lower complication rates, and shorter hospital stays, are largely retained in the elderly population.
  • Age is Not a Contraindication: The study strongly suggests that advanced age alone should not preclude patients from receiving the benefits of minimally invasive LH.
  • Comparable Oncological Outcomes: Crucially, LH did not compromise oncological outcomes, with comparable R0 resection rates and similar long-term survival rates between LH and OH.
  • Elderly LH Outcomes Mirror Non-Elderly LH: The safety and effectiveness of LH in elderly patients were found to be comparable to those in non-elderly patients, reinforcing the idea that LH is a broadly applicable technique.

Key Results

The meta-analysis revealed several significant findings when comparing LH to OH in elderly patients:

  • Operative Time: No significant difference in operative time (WMD = 1.15 minutes, P=.94).
  • Intraoperative Blood Loss: Significantly lower with LH (WMD = -0.71 mL, P=.01).
  • Transfusion Rate: Significantly lower with LH (RR = 0.61, P=.02).
  • R0 Resection Rate: Comparable between LH and OH (RR = 1.01, P=.70).
  • Postoperative Morbidity: Significantly lower with LH (RR = 0.61, P<.01), including both minor and major complications.
  • Mortality: A trend towards lower mortality with LH, though not statistically significant (RR = 0.25, P=.07).
  • Hospital Stay: Significantly shorter with LH (WMD = -3.22 days, P<.01).

When comparing elderly patients undergoing LH to non-elderly patients undergoing LH:

  • Conversion Rate: Similar (RR = 1.57, P=.13).
  • Operative Time: No significant difference (WMD = -22.96 minutes, P=.06).
  • Blood Loss: Similar (WMD = -0.13 mL, P=.26).
  • Transfusion Rate: Similar (RR = 0.72, P=.36).
  • R0 Rate: Similar (RR = 0.97, P=.61).
  • Morbidity: Similar (RR = 0.87, P=.33).
  • Mortality: Similar (RR = 0.76, P=.76).
  • Hospital Stay: Similar (WMD = -1.64 days, P=.16).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Absence of RCTs: The meta-analysis relied on observational studies, meaning a selection bias regarding surgical management choice is unavoidable. While propensity score matching was used in some studies, it doesn't fully replicate randomization.
  • Preoperative Risk Evaluation: The included studies did not consistently evaluate preoperative risk factors or use geriatric-specific scores, making it difficult to fully assess how patient frailty influenced surgical decisions.
  • Extreme Age Group: Data for patients over 80 years old were limited, and one study suggested that the advantages of LH might diminish in this very elderly subgroup, warranting further investigation.

Future work should focus on conducting large-scale, randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to provide higher-level evidence. Additionally, studies incorporating comprehensive geriatric assessments and focusing on specific age subgroups (e.g., octogenarians) would be valuable to refine our understanding of LH in the elderly population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our results indicate that LH is a feasible and safe alternative to OH in elderly patients, providing a lower rate of morbidity and favorable postoperative recovery and outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2018laparoscopic,
  author = {Ke Chen and Yu Pan and Hendi Maher and Bin Zhang and Xueyong Zheng},
  title = {{Laparoscopic hepatectomy for elderly patients}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000011703},
}
Figure