LangPro: Natural Language Theorem Prover

Lasha AbzianidzeEMNLP 2017

TL;DR

This paper introduces LangPro, an automated theorem prover for natural language that leverages a natural logic and an analytic tableau method. It aims to bridge the gap between formal logic and natural language by providing a transparent and deductive proof system, achieving state-of-the-art results on textual entailment tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of building automated systems that can reason about natural language. While formal logic has well-established proof systems, directly applying them to the nuances and complexities of natural language is difficult. The authors are inspired by the idea that natural languages might have their own inherent logical structure, a concept explored in "Natural Logic." Existing approaches to Natural Logic often involve translating natural language into formal logic, which can lose linguistic expressiveness. This paper proposes a system that keeps logical forms as close as possible to linguistic expressions, enabling more transparent and deductive reasoning.

Methods

LangPro is built upon an analytic tableau method, a proof procedure that searches for a model (a possible situation) satisfying a set of logical formulas. The core innovation is the use of a "natural tableau" method, specifically designed for a "natural logic" represented by Lambda Logical Forms (LLFs).

Key components of LangPro include:

  • LLF Generator (LLFgen): This module converts syntactic derivations from Combinatory Categorial Grammar (CCG) into LLFs. It handles quantifier scope ambiguity by generating multiple LLFs for a single sentence and includes steps for removing directionality from CCG trees, correcting semantically inadequate analyses, and type-raising quantified NPs.
  • Natural Logic Theorem Prover (NLogPro): This is the core prover that checks for consistency. It comprises:
  • Proof Engine: Applies tableau rules to build proofs.
  • Signature: Lists lexical terms with their algebraic properties (e.g., monotonicity, intersectivity).
  • Inventory of Rules: Contains inference rules, including both formal logic rules and linguistically motivated ones.
  • Knowledge Base: Based on WordNet, it stores semantic relations like hyponymy, hypernymy, similarity, and antonymy.
  • CCG Parser: LangPro can integrate with different CCG parsers (e.g., C&C, EasyCCG) to obtain the initial syntactic structures.

The system works by first obtaining LLFs for premises and a hypothesis, then collecting relevant rules and knowledge from the KB and IR. It then builds two proof trees: one to refute entailment and another to refute contradiction. If a tableau for a counterexample cannot be closed, the corresponding relation is considered proved.

Datasets

The paper mentions the following datasets:

  • FraCaS: Used for developing and evaluating the system, particularly for semantic competence.
  • SICK (Sentences Involving Compositional Knowledge): Used for evaluating the prover's performance, with specific mention of its use in determining efficiency criteria and for accuracy comparisons.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Formal Logic and Natural Language: The core idea is that natural language itself can be the basis for a logical system, avoiding the loss of information often associated with translation to formal logic.
  • Transparency of Proofs: The analytic tableau method, when applied to natural logic, results in deductive and transparent proofs, making it easier to understand why a conclusion is reached.
  • Handling Semantic Phenomena: The higher-order logic underpinning LangPro allows it to account for complex semantic phenomena like generalized quantifiers and subsective adjectives, which are challenging for first-order logic.
  • Quantifier Scope Ambiguity: The LLF generator explicitly handles quantifier scope ambiguity by producing multiple LLFs, allowing the prover to explore different interpretations.
  • Efficiency Criteria for Proof Search: The paper highlights the importance of defining efficiency criteria for tableau rules to guide the proof search effectively, leading to faster and more accurate results.

Key Results

  • LangPro achieves state-of-the-art semantic competence on the FraCaS dataset, with an accuracy of 87%.
  • On the SICK dataset, the prover obtains 82.1% accuracy, comparable to state-of-the-art systems (81-87%).
  • The system demonstrates high reliability, with less than 3% of its entailment and contradiction judgments being incorrect.
  • Given ready CCG derivations, LangPro can classify 100 SICK problems in an average of 3.5 seconds, indicating its speed.
  • The optional CCG term aligner can boost accuracy on SICK by 1% (or 2% with stronger alignment).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Lexical Items: Currently, the Signature (SG) lists about 20 lexical items, mostly generalized quantifiers. Scaling up to a wider vocabulary is a future challenge.
  • Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD): LangPro does not perform WSD, allowing multiple word senses for a lexical term.
  • Sentence Length: Scaling up for longer sentences (e.g., newswire text) is identified as a future challenge.
  • Automated Knowledge Acquisition: Expanding the knowledge base automatically is another area for future work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{abzianidze2017langpro,
  author = {Lasha Abzianidze},
  title = {{LangPro: Natural Language Theorem Prover}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure