Landscape Ecological Risk Assessment of Kriya River Basin in Xinjiang and Its Multi-Scenario Simulation Analysis

Jinbao Li, Xuemin He, Pengcheng Huang, Zizheng Wang, Ranran WangWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study assesses landscape ecological risk (LER) in the arid Kriya River Basin (KRB) by analyzing land use changes from 2000-2020 and simulating future scenarios. It reveals that human activities are increasingly driving LER, with significant variations expected under different development pathways, highlighting the need for tailored ecological management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Arid regions, characterized by their sensitivity to climate change and intense human activity, face significant ecological risks. Understanding the spatial and temporal evolution of these risks is crucial for effective environmental management and ecological security. The Kriya River Basin (KRB) in Xinjiang, a representative arid inland river basin, is experiencing rapid development, leading to land use changes that impact its fragile ecosystem. This paper aims to quantify these ecological risks, identify their drivers, and project future LER under various development scenarios to inform sustainable planning.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Landscape Ecological Risk Assessment (LERA): This methodology quantifies ecological risk by considering landscape disturbance and vulnerability factors. It uses a Landscape Ecological Risk Index (LERI) calculated based on landscape fragmentation, separation, and dominance.
  • PLUS Model (Patch-generating Land Use Simulation): This advanced model is used to simulate future land use and land cover (LULC) changes. It integrates natural and socioeconomic drivers and utilizes a random forest algorithm for driver contribution analysis, allowing for more accurate spatial predictions.
  • Multi-Scenario Simulation: The PLUS model is used to forecast LULC changes for the year 2030 under three distinct scenarios:
  • Natural Development Scenario (NDS): Assumes land use change rates observed between 2010-2020.
  • Cropland Protection Scenario (CPS): Prioritizes cropland protection, allowing conversion to cropland from other land types except construction land.
  • Ecological Priority Scenario (EPS): Focuses on preserving ecological land, prohibiting conversion of forest and water bodies.
  • Spatial Character Analysis (SCA): This includes global and local Moran's I index analysis to understand spatial autocorrelation and clustering of LER.
  • GeoDetector Model: Used to identify and quantify the influence of various natural and socioeconomic factors on LER.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Land Use and Land Cover (LULC) data: Globeland30 global land cover database for the years 2000, 2010, and 2020, with a 30m spatial resolution.
  • Environmental and Socioeconomic Data:
    • Soil type, GDP, population, temperature, and precipitation data from the Scientific Data Center for Resources and Environment of Chinese Science.
  • Distance variables (to rivers, railways, highways, government, trunk roads) derived from OpenStreetMap.
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM) data from the geospatial data cloud.
  • Derived Data: Slope, slope direction, and topographic relief data calculated from the DEM using ArcGIS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Human activities are increasingly dominant drivers of ecological risk: While natural factors were more influential in the early 2000s, socioeconomic factors like GDP, population, and temperature have become increasingly significant drivers of LER by 2020. This highlights the growing impact of human development on the fragile arid ecosystem.
  • The Kriya River Basin is a mosaic of low-risk areas: The study area is predominantly characterized by grassland and unused land, which are generally low-risk. However, the spatial distribution of risk is not uniform.
  • Daryaboyi is a persistent hotspot of vulnerability: This specific area within the basin consistently emerges as a focal point of maximum ecological vulnerability across different scenarios, underscoring its unique ecological sensitivity.
  • Future development pathways significantly alter ecological risk: The simulated scenarios for 2030 show notable differences in LER. The Cropland Protection Scenario (CPS) appears most effective in reducing overall risk and increasing low-risk areas, suggesting that targeted land use policies can mitigate ecological threats.
  • Spatial clustering of LER is intensifying: The study found a positive and significant spatial correlation in LER over the past two decades, with this clustering becoming more pronounced over time. This suggests that ecological risks are not randomly distributed but tend to concentrate in specific areas.

Key Results

  • LULC Changes (2000-2020):
    • Grassland and unused land, comprising over 97% of the total area, have shown a decreasing trend.
  • Cropland, forest, water, and construction land have generally increased.
  • Cropland area increased by 354.88 km², and construction land grew fastest (172% increase between 2010-2020).
  • A significant transformation involves grassland and unused land converting to cropland, forest, and construction land.
  • LER Trends (2000-2020):
    • Overall LER indices showed a slight downward trend: 0.1721 (2000), 0.1714 (2010), and 0.16696 (2020).
  • LER exhibited strong positive spatial correlations and increasing autocorrelations over time.
  • Low and lower risk areas dominate, covering over 97% of the total area. High and highest risk areas are concentrated along the Kriya River system, particularly in Daryaboyi.
  • Future LER Scenarios (2030):
    • NDS: Overall LERI of 0.1682.
  • CPS: Overall LERI of 0.0933, showing the highest proportion of low-risk areas.
  • EPS: Overall LERI of 0.0903, also demonstrating significant risk reduction.
  • The Daryaboyi site remains a high-risk area across all scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scale Effects: The study acknowledges that landscape pattern indices can exhibit scale effects, potentially introducing bias into the calculation of landscape pattern indices and thus the LER assessment.
  • Driving Factor Complexity: The intricate nature of driving factors behind LULC changes means that the selection of factors in this study, while comprehensive, may not capture all influential elements. This limits the precision of future land use pattern predictions.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Conducting multi-scale comprehensive assessments to emphasize the scale effects of diverse influencing factors.
  • Exploring additional quantitative driving analysis indicators tailored to the specific conditions of the KRB.
  • Developing more precise LULC simulation models by incorporating a wider range of factors and refining existing ones.
  • Further investigation into the specific mechanisms driving LER in arid zones and the development of targeted ecological risk early warning systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

To comprehend the potential impacts of both natural phenomena and human activities on ecological risk, a thorough examination of the spatial and temporal evolution characteristics of Landscape Ecological Risk (LER) in arid river basins is imperative. This investigation holds paramount importance for the proactive prevention and mitigation of LER, as well as for the preservation of ecological security within these basins. In this scholarly inquiry, the Kriya River Basin (KRB) serves as the focal point of analysis. Leveraging three historical land use and land cover (LULC) images and incorporating a diverse array of drivers, encompassing both natural and anthropogenic factors, the study employs the PLUS model to forecast the characteristics of LULC changes within the basin under three distinct scenarios projected for the year 2030. Concurrently, the research quantitatively assesses the ecological risks of the basin through the adoption of the Landscape Ecological Risk Assessment (LERA) methodology and the Spatial Character Analysis (SCA) methodology. The results showed the following: (1) The study area is primarily composed of grassland and unused land, which collectively account for over 97% of the total land. However, there has been a noticeable rise in cropland and considerable deterioration in grassland between 2000 and 2020. The key observed change in LULC involves the transformation of grassland and unused land into cropland, forest, and construction land. (2) The overall LER indices for 2000, 2010, and 2020 are 0.1721, 0.1714, and 0.16696, respectively, showing strong positive spatial correlations and increasing autocorrelations over time. (3) Over time, human activities have come to exert a greater influence on LER compared to natural factors between 2000 and 2020. (4) In the natural development scenario (NDS), cropland protection scenario (CPS), and ecological priority scenario (EPS), the LER of KRB experienced notable variations in the diverse 2030 scenarios. Notably, the CPS exhibited the highest proportion of low-risk areas, whereas Daryaboyi emerged as the focal point of maximum vulnerability. These findings offer theoretical and scientific support for sustainable development planning in the watershed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023landscape,
  author = {Jinbao Li and Xuemin He and Pengcheng Huang and Zizheng Wang and Ranran Wang},
  title = {{Landscape Ecological Risk Assessment of Kriya River Basin in Xinjiang and Its Multi-Scenario Simulation Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15244256},
}
Figure