Landau discriminants

Sebastian Mizera, Simon TelenJournal of High Energy Physics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and computes the Landau discriminant, a geometric object that precisely defines the singularity locus of Feynman integrals in quantum field theory. By leveraging advanced algebraic geometry techniques, the authors provide a computational framework to tackle previously intractable problems, offering new insights into the analytic structure of scattering amplitudes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum field theory, scattering amplitudes are complex functions of particle energies and momenta. Their analytic properties, crucial for understanding physical phenomena, are intimately linked to the singularities of Feynman integrals. These singularities arise from the solutions to a system of nonlinear polynomial equations known as Landau equations. Determining the conditions under which these equations have solutions, and thus identifying the singularity locus, has been a long-standing computational challenge. This paper addresses this by introducing the Landau discriminant as a precise algebraic-geometric object and developing methods to compute it.

Methods

The authors employ two primary approaches:

  • Symbolic Elimination Theory: This involves using computational algebra systems (like Macaulay2) to define ideals generated by derivatives of the Symanzik polynomials and then saturating and eliminating variables to obtain the defining polynomial of the Landau discriminant. This is a classical approach but can become computationally prohibitive for complex diagrams.
  • Numerical Sampling via Homotopy Continuation: This is the paper's main computational thrust. It involves sampling points on the Landau discriminant using numerical methods (specifically, homotopy continuation) and then interpolating these points to reconstruct the discriminant's defining polynomial. This approach is implemented in the Julia package Landau.jl and is shown to be effective for more complex diagrams.

The paper also introduces Landau polytopes as a tool to study degenerate limits of Landau equations and bound the degree of the discriminant.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical computations and algorithmic development applied to various Feynman diagrams, rather than training on or evaluating against empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Landau Discriminant as a Geometric Object: Formalizing the singularity locus of Feynman integrals as a subvariety in kinematic space provides a powerful new lens for analysis.
  • Bridging Physics and Pure Mathematics: The paper demonstrates how advanced tools from algebraic geometry (like homotopy continuation and polytope theory) can directly address fundamental problems in theoretical physics.
  • Computational Tractability for Complex Diagrams: The development of numerical methods allows for the computation of Landau discriminants for diagrams that were previously computationally intractable, opening up new avenues for research.
  • Landau Polytopes as Discriminant Bounds: The introduction of Landau polytopes provides a theoretical framework for bounding the degree of the Landau discriminant, connecting combinatorial properties of diagrams to algebraic properties of their discriminants.

Key Results

  • The Landau discriminant is proven to be an irreducible, proper subvariety of the projectivized kinematic space.
  • The authors successfully computed Landau discriminants for Feynman diagrams up to 3 loops, including complex examples like the envelope diagram (degree 45) and the penta-box diagram (degree 125-fold).
  • A numerical algorithm based on homotopy continuation is presented and implemented in the Landau.jl package, demonstrating its efficiency.
  • The paper provides a method for counting master integrals using connections to algebraic statistics and Morse theory.
  • Bounds on the degree of the Landau discriminant are derived using polytope theory.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the numerical methods are more efficient than symbolic ones, computations can still become time-consuming for very complex diagrams. The paper notes that symbolic methods struggle with larger examples.
  • Genericity Assumptions: Many results rely on assumptions of "generic" kinematic parameters (masses, Mandelstam invariants). Degenerate cases, where these assumptions are violated, require further investigation.
  • Physical Relevance of Singularities: While the Landau discriminant identifies potential singularities, determining which ones are physically relevant (e.g., lie on the physical sheet) requires further analysis, such as the Coleman-Norton analysis presented for the envelope diagram.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the asymptotic behavior of Landau discriminants for large kinematic invariants, investigating massless cases, and extending the analysis to more complex diagrams and subleading Landau singularities. They also highlight the potential for further applications of the developed techniques in areas like intersection theory of twisted cohomologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract Scattering amplitudes in quantum field theories have intricate analytic properties as functions of the energies and momenta of the scattered particles. In perturbation theory, their singularities are governed by a set of nonlinear polynomial equations, known as Landau equations , for each individual Feynman diagram. The singularity locus of the associated Feynman integral is made precise with the notion of the Landau discriminant , which characterizes when the Landau equations admit a solution. In order to compute this discriminant, we present approaches from classical elimination theory, as well as a numerical algorithm based on homotopy continuation. These methods allow us to compute Landau discriminants of various Feynman diagrams up to 3 loops, which were previously out of reach. For instance, the Landau discriminant of the envelope diagram is a reducible surface of degree 45 in the three-dimensional space of kinematic invariants. We investigate geometric properties of the Landau discriminant, such as irreducibility, dimension and degree. In particular, we find simple examples in which the Landau discriminant has codimension greater than one. Furthermore, we describe a numerical procedure for determining which parts of the Landau discriminant lie in the physical regions. In order to study degenerate limits of Landau equations and bounds on the degree of the Landau discriminant, we introduce Landau polytopes and study their facet structure. Finally, we provide an efficient numerical algorithm for the computation of the number of master integrals based on the connection to algebraic statistics. The algorithms used in this work are implemented in the open-source Julia package Landau.jl available at https://mathrepo.mis.mpg.de/Landau/ .
BibTeX
@article{mizera2022landau,
  author = {Sebastian Mizera and Simon Telen},
  title = {{Landau discriminants}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep08(2022)200},
}

Loading related content...

Figure