TL;DR
Achieving the ambitious 1.5°C Paris climate target might require so much land-use change for carbon removal (like BECCS) that it could lead to net carbon loss from the land. Forest-based mitigation, like conservation and reforestation, appears more effective for atmospheric CO2 removal than BECCS when high-carbon ecosystems are replaced by bioenergy crops.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Paris Agreement aims to limit global warming to well below 2°C, ideally 1.5°C, above pre-industrial levels. Many climate mitigation scenarios rely heavily on land-based strategies to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, primarily through afforestation/reforestation, avoided deforestation, and Biomass Energy with Carbon Capture and Storage (BECCS). However, there's a critical question: do these land-use changes, especially for more ambitious targets like 1.5°C, actually lead to net carbon sequestration, or could they inadvertently release more carbon than they capture? This paper investigates the complex interactions between land-use change, climate change, and the terrestrial carbon cycle to assess the effectiveness of these mitigation strategies.
Methods
The study employs a sophisticated modeling approach using the Joint UK Land Environment Simulator (JULES), a dynamic global vegetation model, coupled with the Integrated Assessment Model (IAM) IMAGE.
- IMAGE Model: Used to generate scenarios for land-use change (food production, bioenergy crops, afforestation/reforestation) under different climate targets (1.5°C and 2°C).
- JULES Model: Simulates the terrestrial carbon cycle (vegetation and soil carbon) in response to these land-use and climate scenarios. It also models the carbon captured through BECCS.
- IMOGEN Model: Used to emulate climate change patterns from 34 different Earth System Models (ESMs) to account for climate variability and uncertainty.
- Scenario Design: The core of the study compares two main scenarios:
- 1.5°C_IM1.9: A scenario aiming for ~1.5°C warming by 2100, driven by significant land-use change (IM1.9).
- 2°C_IM2.6: A scenario aiming for ~2°C warming by 2100, driven by less intensive land-use change (IM2.6).
- Additional experiments were run to isolate the effects of land-use change, climate change, and CO2 fertilization.
- Model Validation: JULES's ability to simulate natural vegetation and soil carbon dynamics was validated against observational data.
Datasets
- IMAGE Scenario Data: Land-use projections from the IMAGE model for different Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) and Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs), specifically IM1.9 and IM2.6, were used. These are available from KNMI.
- CMIP5 Earth System Models (ESMs): Data from 34 CMIP5 ESMs were used to generate regional climate change patterns via the IMOGEN model.
- Observational Data: Used for validating JULES's simulation of vegetation and soil carbon, including data on vegetation carbon, turnover times, above/below-ground biomass carbon, NPP, and global soil carbon datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The 1.5°C Target's Double-Edged Sword: The very land-use changes needed to achieve a 1.5°C target, particularly for BECCS, might paradoxically lead to a net release of carbon from the land. This is a critical finding that challenges the assumption that increased land-use for mitigation automatically means more carbon sequestration.
- BECCS Effectiveness is Highly Sensitive: The effectiveness of BECCS is not a given. It hinges critically on assumptions about the type of biomass used, what happens to the initial above-ground biomass, and how much fossil fuel emissions are truly offset.
- Ecosystem Replacement Matters: Replacing high-carbon ecosystems (like forests) with bioenergy crops for BECCS can lead to significant losses of stored carbon, potentially negating the carbon captured by BECCS itself.
- Forests as a More Reliable Sink: In cases where bioenergy crops replace carbon-dense ecosystems, forest conservation and reforestation emerge as more efficient and reliable methods for atmospheric CO2 removal.
- Climate vs. Land-Use Impact: While land-use change has a significant impact, the study suggests that the climate itself (i.e., the difference between 1.5°C and 2°C warming) can have a larger effect on vegetation carbon, particularly in high latitudes.
Key Results
- The 1.5°C_IM1.9 scenario resulted in a net change of +47 ± 18 GtC in total land carbon storage from 2000 to 2100.
- In contrast, the 2°C_IM2.6 scenario showed a larger net change of +102 ± 25 GtC.
- There was a loss of 30 ± 6 GtC vegetation carbon in the 1.5°C_IM1.9 scenario, compared to almost no change in the 2°C_IM2.6 scenario.
- Soil carbon increased in both scenarios, but more significantly in the 2°C_IM2.6 scenario (+81 ± 17 GtC vs. +46 ± 12 GtC for 1.5°C_IM1.9).
- BECCS geological storage in JULES was significantly lower than in IMAGE (e.g., 30 ± 1 GtC for 1.5°C_IM1.9 in JULES vs. 130 GtC in IMAGE by 2100).
- In grid cells where land-use differed, BECCS was found to be more successful at accumulating carbon than forest preservation or recovery in only 27% of cases under the default JULES configuration.
Limitations and Future Work
- Model Dependency: The study acknowledges that different modeling frameworks and assumptions can lead to varying conclusions. They compared JULES with five other DGVMs, which generally supported the finding that IM2.6 leads to higher land carbon storage than IM1.9.
- BECCS Efficiency Assumptions: The study highlights that BECCS efficiency assumptions (e.g., harvest to storage) significantly impact results. JULES's lower efficiency compared to IMAGE contributes to the discrepancy in BECCS carbon capture.
- Exclusion of Other Factors: The study primarily focuses on carbon cycle implications. It notes that other important factors like emissions of other greenhouse gases (N2O, CH4), biophysical changes (albedo, ET), and impacts on water resources, food security, and biodiversity are not fully accounted for.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should focus on a more integrated assessment of land-use change, considering all greenhouse gases and biophysical impacts. They also emphasize the need for careful consideration of sustainability constraints when implementing BECCS and a cautious approach to land-use change fluxes. The potential for BECCS could be improved by doubling its predicted carbon storage in JULES, but even then, forest-based mitigation remains more effective in many scenarios.
Summary updated