Lactic Acid Bacteria and Cellulase Improve the Fermentation Characteristics, Aerobic Stability and Rumen Degradation of Mixed Silage Prepared with Amaranth and Rice Straw

Jian Ma, Xue Fan, Tingting Wu, Jiaxin Zhou, Haozhan Huang, Tianzhen Qiu, Zhewei Xing, Zhihui Zhao, Fuquan Yin, Shangquan GanFermentation 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that combining lactic acid bacteria (LAB) and cellulase significantly improves the fermentation quality, aerobic stability, and ruminal degradability of mixed silage made from amaranth and rice straw. This approach offers a promising strategy to enhance the nutritional value of underutilized agricultural byproducts for ruminant feed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ruminant farming relies heavily on high-quality roughage. However, conventional feed sources like corn silage can be scarce or have limitations in certain regions. Amaranth and rice straw are abundant agricultural byproducts with potential as roughage, but amaranth has high moisture and low water-soluble carbohydrates (WSC), while rice straw is rich in cellulose and has low natural lactic acid bacteria populations, hindering efficient ensiling. This leads to poor fermentation, spoilage, and reduced nutritional value. The paper addresses the challenge of effectively preserving and enhancing the nutritional quality of mixed amaranth and rice straw silage to make it a viable and valuable feed source for ruminants.

Methods

The researchers prepared mixed silage from amaranth and rice straw (76:24 ratio) and tested four treatment groups:

  • CON: Control (no additives)
  • LAB: Lactic acid bacteria (5 mg/kg fresh matter)
  • CEL: Cellulase (2 mg/kg fresh matter)
  • LBC: Lactic acid bacteria (5 mg/kg) + Cellulase (2 mg/kg)

The silages were fermented for 60 days. Key analyses included:

  • Fermentation Quality: Measuring pH, lactic acid, acetic acid, propionic acid, butyric acid, and ammonia nitrogen/total nitrogen ratio.
  • Chemical Composition: Determining dry matter (DM), organic matter (OM), crude protein (CP), WSC, neutral detergent fiber (NDF), and acid detergent fiber (ADF).
  • Microbial Population: Counting lactic acid bacteria, mold, aerobic bacteria, yeast, and coliform bacteria.
  • Aerobic Stability: Assessing the time it took for the silage to increase in temperature by 2°C after exposure to air.
  • Rumen Degradability: Using the nylon bag method in Holstein cattle to measure the in situ degradation of DM, CP, NDF, and ADF over time, and calculating degradation parameters (a, b, c, a+b, effective degradability).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized fresh amaranth and rice straw as raw materials for silage preparation and analyzed the resulting silage samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effect of LAB and Cellulase: The most significant finding is that the combined application of LAB and cellulase (LBC group) yielded superior results across multiple parameters compared to individual additives or the control. This suggests a synergistic interaction where cellulase breaks down structural carbohydrates, providing more WSC for LAB to ferment, and LAB, in turn, create an acidic environment that inhibits spoilage.
  • Improved Fermentation and Reduced Spoilage: The LBC group showed a significantly lower pH and ammonia nitrogen/total nitrogen ratio, indicating better fermentation and reduced proteolysis. Crucially, it also had the lowest counts of harmful microorganisms like mold, aerobic bacteria, and coliform bacteria, directly contributing to improved silage quality and reduced spoilage potential.
  • Enhanced Nutrient Availability: The LBC treatment led to increased DM and CP content in the silage and a significant reduction in NDF and ADF. This means the final silage product is more nutrient-dense and the structural carbohydrates are more digestible, making nutrients more accessible to ruminants.
  • Boosted Rumen Degradability: The LBC silage demonstrated significantly higher ruminal degradation rates for DM, CP, NDF, and ADF. This is a critical indicator of how well ruminants can utilize the feed, suggesting that the LBC treatment makes the nutrients more bioavailable in the rumen.

Key Results

  • Fermentation: The LBC group had the highest lactic acid content (32.12% higher than CON) and the lowest pH (significantly reduced compared to CON and CEL). It also had the lowest acetic and propionic acid concentrations.
  • Nutrient Content: DM content was significantly increased in LAB and LBC groups. CP tended to be higher in the LBC group. NDF and ADF were significantly reduced by cellulase and further reduced in the LBC group.
  • Microbial Load: LAB significantly increased lactic acid bacteria counts. The CON group had significantly higher mold and aerobic bacteria counts. The LBC group had significantly lower coliform bacteria counts than CON and CEL.
  • Aerobic Stability: The LBC group showed significantly improved aerobic stability time, indicating better resistance to spoilage upon exposure to air.
  • Rumen Degradability: The LBC group showed significantly increased ruminal degradation of DM, CP, NDF, and ADF at various time points, with higher effective degradability for all measured components compared to the CON group.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Aerobic Stability Nuance: While the LBC group showed improved aerobic stability time, the paper notes that the time was lower (p < 0.05) than other groups, which seems contradictory to the statement that it lengthened aerobic stability time. This might be a typo or requires clarification. The authors speculate that reduced yeast counts contribute to improved aerobic stability.
  • Microbial Mechanism: The underlying mechanisms of how LAB and cellulase interact to improve silage quality and rumen degradability are complex. The authors suggest that future research should investigate microbial composition and function using metagenomics technology to gain a deeper understanding.
  • Nitrogen Conversion: The paper notes that the reduction in NH3-N/total nitrogen in the LBC group might be due to synergistic effects on nitrogen conversion. Further studies are recommended to explore the influence of different silage additives on nitrogen conversion during ensiling.
  • Animal Performance: While rumen degradability is a strong indicator, direct studies on animal performance (e.g., feed intake, milk production, growth rate) using this specific silage would be valuable to fully validate its efficacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this experiment is to investigate the effects of lactic acid bacteria and cellulase on the fermentation quality, chemical composition, aerobic stability and ruminal degradation characteristics of mixed silage prepared with amaranth and rice straw. Lactic acid bacteria and cellulase were used as silage additives, and the four treatments were as follows: control group (CON, no additive), lactic acid bacteria group (LAB, additive amount was 5 mg/kg fresh matter), cellulase group (CEL, 2 mg/kg) and lactic acid bacteria and cellulase group (LBC, additive amount was the same as in the individual treatments). All treatments were ensiled for 60 days. The dry-matter, crude-protein, neutral-detergent-fiber and acid-detergent-fiber ruminal degradability of silage were analyzed utilizing the nylon bag method. Compared with the CON group, the inoculation of lactic acid bacteria and cellulase individually promoted the fermentation of mixed silage to a certain degree. The combined inoculation of mixed silage significantly increased (p &lt; 0.05) the concentrations of lactic acid and dry matter, while it reduced (p &lt; 0.05) the pH and ammonia nitrogen/total nitrogen, harmful microorganism counts and contents of acetic acid, neutral detergent fiber and acid detergent fiber. In addition, the aerobic stability time of the LBC group was lower (p &lt; 0.05) than that of the other groups. The ruminal degradation rate of dry matter, crude protein, neutral detergent fiber and acid detergent fiber in the LBC group was significantly increased (p &lt; 0.05) compared to the CON group. Overall, the addition of the additives mentioned earlier improved the quality of mixed silage composed of amaranth and rice straw, and the best results were obtained by combining the inoculation of lactic acid bacteria and cellulase.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2023lactic,
  author = {Jian Ma and Xue Fan and Tingting Wu and Jiaxin Zhou and Haozhan Huang and Tianzhen Qiu and Zhewei Xing and Zhihui Zhao and Fuquan Yin and Shangquan Gan},
  title = {{Lactic Acid Bacteria and Cellulase Improve the Fermentation Characteristics, Aerobic Stability and Rumen Degradation of Mixed Silage Prepared with Amaranth and Rice Straw}},
  booktitle = {Fermentation},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/fermentation9090853},
}
Figure