Laboratory and Field Studies of Poly(2,5-bis(N-methyl-N-hexylamino)phenylene vinylene) (BAM-PPV): A Potential Wash Primer Replacement for Army Military Vehicles

Peter Zarras, Christopher W. Miller, Cindy Webber, Nicole Anderson, John D. Stenger‐SmithCoatings 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates Poly(2,5-bis(N-methyl-N-hexylamino)phenylene vinylene) (BAM-PPV) as a non-toxic, electroactive polymer alternative to traditional hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI))-based wash primers for Army vehicles. Laboratory and field tests demonstrate that BAM-PPV offers comparable adhesion and corrosion inhibition, meeting military performance requirements and paving the way for safer, more environmentally friendly coatings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The U.S. Army currently relies on a wash primer (DOD-P-15328D) that utilizes hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)). While effective for surface preparation, adhesion promotion, and corrosion inhibition on various metal substrates (steel, aluminum, etc.), Cr(VI) is a known toxic and carcinogenic material. Increasingly stringent environmental regulations and a focus on worker safety necessitate the development of alternative coating systems that can reduce or eliminate the use of Cr(VI) without compromising performance. This paper addresses the critical need for a viable, high-performance replacement for Cr(VI)-based wash primers in military applications.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach combining laboratory testing and field trials:

  • Synthesis and Characterization: BAM-PPV was synthesized and characterized using standard techniques like NMR and FTIR to confirm its structure and properties.
  • Coating Application: BAM-PPV solutions were prepared and applied to various metal substrates (4130 steel, AA 6061-T6, AA 5083-H116, AA 2024-T3) using air brush or HVLP spray techniques, mimicking industrial application methods. These were then coated with standard Army primers (MIL-DTL-53022) and topcoats (MIL-DTL-53039, MIL-DTL-64159).
  • Laboratory Testing:
    • Pull-Off Adhesion (ASTM D 4541): This test measured the adhesive strength of the BAM-PPV pretreatment and subsequent coating layers to the metal substrates.
  • Neutral Salt Spray (NSS) Exposure Testing (ASTM B 117): Coated coupons were exposed to a corrosive salt spray environment for extended periods (up to 2016 hours for aluminum, 432 hours for steel) to evaluate corrosion resistance. Performance was assessed based on blistering, adhesion loss, undercutting, pitting, and corrosion build-up, using ASTM D 1654 ratings.
  • Field Testing: A Bradley vehicle headlight cover, a representative Army aluminum component, was coated with the BAM-PPV system and subjected to a one-year outdoor weathering test at the Aberdeen Test Center (ATC). This involved exposure to various environmental conditions and periodic inspections for corrosion, adhesion, peeling, and blistering.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized prepared metal coupons and a specific vehicle component for testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BAM-PPV as a Viable Cr(VI) Alternative: The core finding is that BAM-PPV, an electroactive polymer, can effectively replace Cr(VI)-based wash primers in military coating systems, offering comparable performance without the associated toxicity.
  • Mechanism of Corrosion Inhibition: While not deeply explored in this paper, the abstract mentions BAM-PPV's potential for corrosion inhibition via a surface passivation mechanism, similar to other electroactive polymers.
  • Surface Preparation Matters: The study investigated both as-received and grit-blasted steel surfaces. While BAM-PPV showed acceptable adhesion on both, slight improvements were noted on grit-blasted surfaces, which mimic Army depot de-painting and cleaning processes.
  • Integrated System Performance: The success of BAM-PPV is not just in its standalone properties but in its integration with standard Army epoxy primers and CARC topcoats, demonstrating that it can be a drop-in replacement within existing coating schemes.
  • Field Validation is Crucial: The one-year field test on a vehicle component provided critical real-world validation, showing no delamination and only minor corrosion at chip sites, confirming its durability under harsh conditions.

Key Results

  • Adhesion: BAM-PPV pretreatment with MIL-DTL-53022 primer and CARC topcoats provided acceptable adhesion on both as-received and grit-blasted 4130 steel coupons, with average pull-off strengths ranging from 801 to 917 psi.
  • NSS Testing (Steel): BAM-PPV military coating systems showed similar corrosion protection to the control DOD-P-15328D (Cr(VI)-based) wash primer at 124 hours of NSS exposure. After 432 hours, the BAM-PPV system with MIL-DTL-53022 primer and MIL-DTL-64159 topcoat performed best, with no evidence of delamination on scribed or non-scribed steel coupons.
  • NSS Testing (Aluminum): Non-scribed aluminum coupons coated with BAM-PPV systems lasted through 2016 hours of NSS exposure with no delamination. Scribed areas showed some corrosion, but the performance was comparable to or better than some control systems.
  • Field Test (Bradley Headlight Cover): After one year of outdoor exposure, the BAM-PPV coated headlight cover showed no significant corrosion, blistering, or undercutting. Minor corrosion was observed only at chip sites where all coatings were removed, which was deemed acceptable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper notes that the PATTI adhesion test results are comparative and do not provide pass/fail criteria for specific applications.
  • While BAM-PPV showed comparable performance to the Cr(VI) control, the study focused on specific Army coating systems. Further investigation into its compatibility with a wider range of primers and topcoats might be beneficial.
  • The field test was conducted on a single vehicle component; broader testing on different vehicle types and components would strengthen the findings.
  • Future Work:
    • The abstract mentions that toxicology testing was performed and found BAM-PPV to be non-toxic, non-dermal irritant, and not a sensitizer. This is a crucial aspect for its adoption and could be further elaborated upon.
  • The study focused on adhesion and corrosion inhibition. Further research into the long-term durability, UV resistance, and other environmental factors impacting BAM-PPV's performance would be valuable.
  • Exploring the precise electrochemical mechanisms behind BAM-PPV's corrosion inhibition could lead to further optimization of its formulation and application.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, an electroactive polymer (EAP), poly(2,5-bis(N-methyl-N- hexylamino)phenylene vinylene) (BAM-PPV), was tested as an alternative to current hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI))-based Army wash primers. BAM-PPV was tested in both laboratory and field studies to determine its adhesive and corrosion-inhibiting properties when applied to steel and aluminum alloys. The Army Research Laboratory (ARL) tests showed that BAM-PPV combined with an epoxy primer and the Army chemical agent-resistant coating (CARC) topcoat met Army performance requirements for military coatings. After successful laboratory testing, the BAM-PPV was then field tested for one year at the Aberdeen Test Center (ATC). This field testing showed that BAM-PPV incorporated into the Army military coating survived with no delamination of the coating and only minor corrosion on the chip sites.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zarras2014laboratory,
  author = {Peter Zarras and Christopher W. Miller and Cindy Webber and Nicole Anderson and John D. Stenger‐Smith},
  title = {{Laboratory and Field Studies of Poly(2,5-bis(N-methyl-N-hexylamino)phenylene vinylene) (BAM-PPV): A Potential Wash Primer Replacement for Army Military Vehicles}},
  booktitle = {Coatings},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/coatings4030687},
}
Figure