Label-retention expansion microscopy

Xiaoyu Shi, Qi Li, Zhipeng Dai, Arthur A. Tran, Siyu Feng, Alejandro Ramirez, Zixi Lin, Xiaomeng Wang, Tracy T. Chow, Jiapei Chen, Dhivya Kumar, Andrew McColloch, Jeremy F. Reiter, Eric J. Huang, Ian B. Seiple, Bo HuangbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Label-Retention Expansion Microscopy (LR-ExM), a novel technique that significantly reduces fluorescence signal loss during expansion microscopy by using specialized trifunctional anchors. This advancement enables high-efficiency labeling and allows for unprecedented molecular-scale imaging when combined with super-resolution microscopy techniques like STORM.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Expansion Microscopy (ExM) is a powerful technique that physically expands biological samples, allowing conventional microscopes to achieve higher resolution. However, a major limitation of existing ExM methods is significant loss of fluorescent signal during the sample preparation process, specifically during hydrogel polymerization and proteinase digestion. This signal loss, which can exceed 50%, hinders molecular-scale imaging and is exacerbated when aiming for higher resolutions or using sensitive super-resolution techniques. The authors address this by developing a method that retains labels more effectively, thereby preserving spatial information and improving signal intensity.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the development of Label-Retention Expansion Microscopy (LR-ExM). The workflow involves five key steps:

  1. Labeling with trifunctional anchors: The key component is a set of trifunctional anchors. These molecules have three distinct functional groups:
  2. An NHS ester (or similar reactive group) for conjugation to antibodies.
  3. A methacrylamide (MA) group for covalent anchoring to the hydrogel matrix during polymerization.
  4. Two orthogonal reporter handles (e.g., biotin and digoxigenin) for post-expansion labeling with fluorescent dyes.
  5. Alternatively, anchors with benzylguanine (BG) or benzylcytosine (BC) groups are used for direct labeling of SNAP and CLIP protein tags, respectively.
  6. In situ hydrogel formation: The labeled sample is embedded in a swellable hydrogel.
  7. Proteinase digestion: The hydrogel is digested to allow for isotropic expansion.
  8. Post-expansion fluorescence staining: After expansion, the reporter handles (biotin/digoxigenin) are labeled with fluorescent dyes. For SNAP/CLIP tags, the BG/BC groups are labeled with their respective fluorescent ligands.
  9. Expansion: The hydrogel is expanded in water to achieve the final, larger sample size.

This approach differs from standard ExM by directly anchoring the labels (or tags that bind labels) to the hydrogel matrix via the trifunctional anchors, making them resistant to digestion and polymerization-induced damage. This contrasts with methods that rely on less stable anchoring or indirect labeling.

Datasets

The paper utilizes various cell lines and biological samples for imaging and validation, including:

  • U2OS cells
  • HeLa cells
  • HEK 293T cells
  • Mouse brain tissue slices
  • Primary cilia of Retinal Pigment Epithelium (RPE) cells
  • Mouse embryonic stem cells (mESC)

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing biological structures were imaged and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct anchoring is key to label retention: The trifunctional anchors directly crosslink labels (or tags) to the hydrogel, making them robust against the harsh conditions of ExM processing (digestion and polymerization). This is a significant improvement over methods relying on less stable interactions.
  • SNAP and CLIP tags are ideal for molecular resolution: The small size and high labeling efficiency of SNAP and CLIP tags, when used with LR-ExM, are crucial for achieving true molecular-scale resolution, outperforming traditional antibody labeling.
  • LR-ExM is highly versatile: The method is compatible with both antibody-based immunofluorescence and enzymatic tag labeling, and can be integrated with various ExM protocols.
  • Significant signal enhancement: LR-ExM demonstrates a substantial increase in fluorescence signal (up to 5.8-fold) compared to standard ExM protocols, directly addressing the signal loss problem.
  • Robustness and reproducibility: The direct anchoring mechanism makes LR-ExM less dependent on digestion conditions, leading to more consistent and reproducible results.

Key Results

  • Improved fluorescence intensity: LR-ExM achieved a 5.8 ± 0.8 fold increase in fluorescence signal compared to standard ExM using Alexa Fluor 488 (AF488) conjugated antibodies.
  • Reduced label loss: The authors estimate that standard ExM loses ~83% of labels, with ~15% attributed to polymerization and ~68% to digestion. LR-ExM significantly mitigates this loss.
  • High resolution imaging:
    • LR-ExM combined with confocal microscopy achieved an effective resolution of 71 ± 1.6 nm.
  • LR-ExSIM (LR-ExM + SIM) achieved a resolution of 34 nm.
  • LR-ExSTORM (LR-ExM + STORM) achieved effective localization precision of ~4 nm, comparable to the size of a typical protein molecule, and resolved clathrin lattice structures with ~20 nm spacing.
  • Demonstrated multicolor imaging: The method successfully enabled two-color imaging of various subcellular structures, including microtubules and clathrin-coated pits (CCPs), nuclear lamina and nuclear pore complexes (NPCs), and synaptic markers in mouse brain tissue.
  • Successful enzymatic labeling: LR-ExM with SNAP and CLIP tags provided high-quality imaging of CCPs and mitochondria, showcasing the advantage of small, efficient labels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genetic modification for enzymatic tags: The enzymatic approach requires genetic modification to fuse SNAP or CLIP tags to target proteins, which may not always be feasible or desirable. The authors recommend matching expression levels to endogenous levels to avoid artifacts.
  • Potential for distortion: While LR-ExM aims for isotropic expansion, nanoscale hydrogel distortion and label size can still introduce uncertainty in measurements, especially at the highest resolutions.
  • Mounting medium for STORM: The STORM mounting medium's high ionic strength can slightly reduce the expansion ratio for LR-ExSTORM.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that LR-ExM's versatility can be extended to other ExM protocols targeting nucleic acids, lipids, and other cellular components. They also propose developing new trifunctional anchors with more small chemical reporters to enable even higher multiplexity. The potential for LR-ExM to be integrated with other advanced imaging techniques is highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Expansion microscopy (ExM) increases the effective resolving power of any microscope by expanding the sample with swellable hydrogel. Since its invention, ExM has been successfully applied to a wide range of cell, tissue and animal samples. Still, fluorescence signal loss during polymerization and digestion limits molecular-scale imaging using ExM. Here we report the development of label-retention ExM (LR-ExM) with a set of trifunctional anchors that not only prevent signal loss but also enable high-efficiency labeling using SNAP and CLIP tags. We have demonstrated multicolor LR-ExM for a variety of subcellular structures. Combining LR-ExM with super-resolution Stochastic Optical Reconstruction Microscopy (STORM), we have achieved molecular resolution in the visualization of polyhedral lattice of clathrin-coated pits in situ .
BibTeX
@misc{shi2019label,
  author = {Xiaoyu Shi and Qi Li and Zhipeng Dai and Arthur A. Tran and Siyu Feng and Alejandro Ramirez and Zixi Lin and Xiaomeng Wang and Tracy T. Chow and Jiapei Chen and Dhivya Kumar and Andrew McColloch and Jeremy F. Reiter and Eric J. Huang and Ian B. Seiple and Bo Huang},
  title = {{Label-retention expansion microscopy}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/687954},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure