L1448-MM OBSERVATIONS BY THE HERSCHEL KEY PROGRAM, “DUST, ICE, AND GAS IN TIME” (DIGIT)

Jinhee Lee, Jeong‐Eun Lee, Seokho Lee, Joel D. Green, Neal J. Evans, Minho Choi, L. E. Kristensen, O. Dionatos, J. K. Jørgensen, the Digit teamThe Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents detailed observations of the Class 0 protostar L1448-MM using the Herschel/PACS instrument, revealing a rich tapestry of molecular and atomic emission lines. By analyzing the spatial distribution and physical conditions of these emissions, the study suggests that the observed molecular lines are primarily produced by shocks, while atomic lines like [O I] indicate a more extended emission possibly from multiple shock components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the physical and chemical processes occurring in the earliest stages of star formation is crucial for comprehending how stars and planetary systems form. Class 0 protostars, like L1448-MM, are deeply embedded within their natal envelopes, making them difficult to observe. Their outflows are powerful engines that drive shocks, heat the surrounding gas, and influence the chemical evolution of the material. However, disentangling the contributions of different physical processes (e.g., shocks vs. UV radiation) and identifying the spatial extent and origin of various emission lines has been challenging. This paper aims to provide a detailed spectral and spatial analysis of L1448-MM to better understand the energy budget and excitation mechanisms in such environments.

Methods

The study utilizes observations from the Herschel Space Observatory's PACS instrument to obtain spectra across a wide wavelength range (50-210 µm). The data reduction involved standard pipelines, with modifications to account for the complex source structure of L1448-MM, which is known to host multiple embedded sources.

Key analysis techniques include:

  • Rotational Diagram Analysis: This standard method is used to estimate the excitation temperature and column density of molecules by fitting the intensities of various rotational transitions.
  • Non-LTE Large Velocity Gradient (LVG) Code (RADEX): This code is employed to model the physical conditions (kinetic temperature, H₂ density, column density) of the gas by comparing observed line ratios to theoretical predictions. The LVG model was upgraded to handle potential convergence issues and to incorporate radiative pumping from the central source.
  • Shock Models: The observed line fluxes are compared to theoretical calculations from shock models (Flower & Pineau des Forêts 2010) to determine the type (C-shock vs. J-shock), speed, and density of the shocks responsible for the emission.
  • Spatial Mapping: The spatial distribution of emission lines is analyzed to understand where different molecules and atoms are located relative to the protostar and its outflow.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this paper consists of Herschel/PACS observations of L1448-MM. The paper also incorporates archival data from Spitzer/IRS, Spitzer/IRAC, and Spitzer/MIPS for comparison and to provide a broader spectral energy distribution (SED). Additionally, SRAO CO J=2-1 observations are included.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shock-dominated emission: The study strongly suggests that the molecular line emission (CO, H₂O, OH) from L1448-MM is primarily driven by shocks, rather than UV heating from the protostar. This is supported by the high kinetic temperatures derived from LVG models and the good agreement with shock model predictions.
  • Multiple shock components: While molecular emission is well-explained by C-shocks, the atomic emission ([O I] from PACS and [Si II] from Spitzer/IRS) is not fully consistent with a single C-shock model, pointing towards the presence of multiple shock components, possibly including J-shocks.
  • Spatial segregation of emission: Lines from low-energy levels tend to be distributed along the outflow direction, while high-energy level lines peak at the central spatial pixel. [O I] emission is notably more extended than other molecular lines.
  • Water as a dominant coolant: H₂O is identified as the major line coolant in the PACS wavelength range for L1448-MM, contributing significantly to the overall energy budget.
  • Complex source structure: L1448-MM is confirmed to be a multiple-source system, with MM(A) and MM(B) being distinct YSOs, likely in a common envelope. MM(A) appears more embedded and is likely the primary outflow source.

Key Results

  • Spatial distribution: Low-energy CO, OH, and H₂O lines are extended along the outflow, while high-energy lines are concentrated centrally. [O I] emission is significantly more extended.
  • Temperature and density: LVG models suggest kinetic temperatures exceeding 1000 K for CO and H₂O, indicative of shocks. For component (A), temperatures are generally higher than for component (B).
  • Shock model fits: C-shock models with high densities (2x10⁵ cm⁻³) and velocities (40 km s⁻¹) best fit the CO and H₂O emission for component (A). For component (B), a C-shock model with lower density (2x10⁴ cm⁻³) and velocity (20 km s⁻¹) or a J-shock model also provides reasonable fits.
  • [O I] flux discrepancy: The observed [O I] flux is significantly larger than what C-type shock models can reproduce, suggesting the need for multiple shock components or a larger emitting region.
  • Luminosity contributions: CO and H₂O contribute the majority of the FIR line luminosity (50-80%), with H₂O being the dominant coolant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial resolution: While PACS offers improved spatial resolution compared to previous instruments like ISO, it still may not fully resolve the complex kinematics and multiple components within L1448-MM. The paper acknowledges that the PACS spectrum does not resolve complex kinematics.
  • Shock model simplicity: The shock models used are planar and may not fully capture the three-dimensional nature of the outflow and shock interactions in L1448-MM. The authors suggest the need for more sophisticated multi-dimensional shock models.
  • Data limitations: The number of OH lines for component (B) was not sufficient for a meaningful fitting. Some lines were excluded due to unusual line shapes.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that more sophisticated multi-dimensional shock models with different initial conditions are needed to explain the relative emission of each species in this complicated region. Further investigation into the role of dissociative shocks, indicated by [Si II] emission, is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present Herschel/PACS observations of L1448-MM, a Class 0 protostar with a prominent outflow. Numerous emission lines are detected at 55 < lambda < 210 micrometer including CO, OH, H2O, and [O I]. We investigate the spatial distribution of each transition to find that lines from low energy levels tend to distribute along the outflow direction while lines from high energy levels peak at the central spatial pixel. Spatial maps reveal that OH emission lines are formed in a relatively small area, while [O I] emission is extended. According to the rotational diagram analysis, the CO emission can be fitted by two (warm and hot) temperature components. For H2O, the ortho-to-para ratio is close to 3. The non-LTE LVG calculations suggest that CO and H2O lines could instead be formed in a high kinetic temperature (T > 1000 K) environment, indicative of a shock origin. For OH, IR-pumping processes play an important role in the level population. The molecular emission in L1448-MM is better explained with a C-shock model, but the atomic emission of PACS [O I] and Spitzer/IRS [Si II] emission is not consistent with C-shocks, suggesting multiple shocks in this region. Water is the major line coolant of L1448-MM in the PACS wavelength range, and the best-fit LVG models predict that H2O and CO emit (50-80)% of their line luminosity in the PACS wavelength range.
BibTeX
@article{lee2013l,
  author = {Jinhee Lee and Jeong‐Eun Lee and Seokho Lee and Joel D. Green and Neal J. Evans and Minho Choi and L. E. Kristensen and O. Dionatos and J. K. Jørgensen and the DIGIT team},
  title = {{L1448-MM OBSERVATIONS BY THE <i>HERSCHEL</i> KEY PROGRAM, “DUST, ICE, AND GAS IN TIME” (DIGIT)}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1088/0067-0049/209/1/4},
}
Figure