l1-norm constrained multi-block sparse canonical correlation analysis via proximal gradient descent

Leying GuanOpenReview 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel algorithm, msCCA, for analyzing complex, multi-block datasets by finding sparse relationships across data sources. It addresses the challenge of high dimensionality by using a proximal gradient descent approach with decaying sparsity constraints, proving its theoretical optimality and demonstrating competitive performance against existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world datasets consist of multiple, distinct blocks of information (e.g., gene expression, clinical data, imaging). Multi-block Canonical Correlation Analysis (mCCA) aims to find linear relationships that explain coherent variations across these blocks, effectively reducing dimensionality and uncovering shared patterns. However, a significant challenge arises when dealing with high-dimensional data (where the number of features is much larger than the number of samples). In such cases, standard mCCA can overfit and produce unreliable results. This paper tackles this by proposing a sparse mCCA approach that specifically handles high-dimensional data by identifying only the most relevant features, thus improving interpretability and robustness. While sparse mCCA has been explored, a rigorous theoretical understanding for the $l_1$-norm constrained formulation, which is practically useful, has been lacking.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a new algorithm called msCCA (multi-block sparse canonical correlation analysis). It frames the mCCA problem as finding leading generalized eigenvectors and solves it using a proximal gradient descent algorithm. The key innovation lies in the use of a decaying sequence of $l_1$-norm constraints over proximal iterations. This approach allows the algorithm to adaptively find sparse solutions. The authors also propose an easy-to-implement deflation procedure to sequentially estimate multiple mCCA directions, which is crucial for capturing more complex relationships. The theoretical underpinnings are strengthened by proofs of rate-optimality for the proposed estimates under suitable assumptions.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its proposed methods using:

  • Simulated datasets: Designed to mimic scenarios with and without informative blocks, and varying levels of sparsity and sample size.
  • TCGA breast cancer data: A real-world dataset comprising methylation, miRNA, and mRNA data from 989 patients, along with two artificially generated "non-informative" blocks to test robustness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decaying $l_1$-norm constraints are powerful: By iteratively relaxing the sparsity constraint, the algorithm can find optimal sparse solutions that are theoretically rate-optimal, a significant advancement for $l_1$-constrained mCCA.
  • Deflation is crucial for multiple directions: The proposed sequential deflation method effectively allows for the estimation of multiple mCCA directions, building upon the initial leading direction.
  • Practical performance matters: The msCCA algorithm not only has strong theoretical guarantees but also demonstrates competitive or superior performance compared to existing methods in both simulations and a real-world cancer dataset.
  • Sparsity is key for interpretability: The $l_1$-norm constraint naturally leads to sparse solutions, making the identified relationships more interpretable and actionable.

Key Results

  • The proposed msCCA algorithm is shown to be rate-optimal under suitable assumptions, meaning it achieves the best possible statistical accuracy for estimating the leading mCCA direction.
  • In simulations, msCCA1 (the proposed method with deflation) consistently outperforms other methods like pma, rgcca, and sgcca, especially in scenarios with non-informative blocks or weaker signals.
  • On the TCGA breast cancer dataset, msCCA1 achieved the highest mCCA correlations and provided directions that were more informative for predicting cancer subtypes, demonstrating its utility in complex biological data integration.
  • The deflation procedure was effective in estimating multiple components, and msCCA1 showed comparable or better performance than other methods in terms of achieved correlations and residual variances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational cost: While the proposed method is designed to scale better than some alternatives, initialization can still be computationally expensive for very large datasets.
  • Choice of parameters: The paper mentions that cross-validation is recommended for selecting iteration numbers in practice, implying that parameter tuning can still be a factor for optimal finite-sample performance.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that the sequential deflation procedure can be adapted for different sparsity levels and allows for easy addition of new directions, hinting at potential extensions for more complex multi-block scenarios. The theoretical framework could also be extended to other types of sparsity constraints.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-block CCA constructs linear relationships explaining coherent variations across multiple blocks of data. We view the multi-block CCA problem as finding leading generalized eigenvectors and propose to solve it via a proximal gradient descent algorithm with constraint for high dimensional data. In particular, we use a decaying sequence of constraints over proximal iterations, and show that the resulting estimate is rate-optimal under suitable assumptions. Although several previous works have demonstrated such optimality for the constrained problem using iterative approaches, the same level of theoretical understanding for the constrained formulation is still lacking. We also describe an easy-to-implement deflation procedure to estimate multiple eigenvectors sequentially. We compare our proposals to several existing methods whose implementations are available on R CRAN, and the proposed methods show competitive performances in both simulations and a real data example.
BibTeX
@misc{guan2024l,
  author = {Leying Guan},
  title = {{l1-norm constrained multi-block sparse canonical correlation analysis via proximal gradient descent}},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=S1hZaTk1pk},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}
Figure