Krylov complexity and confinement

Xudong Jiang, Jad C. Halimeh, N. S. SrivatsaPhysical 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Krylov complexity as a novel and sensitive tool to detect and quantify "confinement" phenomena in quantum many-body systems, specifically using the transverse-field Ising model. They demonstrate that the characteristic suppression and oscillatory behavior of Krylov complexity directly reflect the presence of bound states (mesons) formed by confined excitations, providing a powerful new spectroscopic method.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Confinement, a fundamental concept in high-energy physics (like quarks being bound within protons), also appears in condensed matter systems. In these systems, elementary excitations can be bound together by an effective potential, preventing them from propagating freely. A prime example is the transverse-field Ising model with an added longitudinal field, where domain walls, normally free, become bound into "meson-like" states. While other measures like entanglement entropy can hint at confinement, they might not fully capture the dynamics. This paper aims to establish Krylov complexity, a measure of how quantum information spreads under Hamiltonian evolution, as a robust and quantitative probe for these confinement phenomena, offering a new perspective on their spectral signatures.

Methods

The core of the paper involves simulating the transverse-field Ising model with both transverse ($h_x$) and longitudinal ($h_z$) fields. They employ a quantum quench protocol, starting from a specific initial state (e.g., fully polarized ferromagnetic) and suddenly changing the Hamiltonian parameters. The key technique is the calculation of Krylov state complexity, $C_k(t)$. This is done by constructing an orthonormal basis (the Krylov subspace) using the Lanczos algorithm, which iteratively applies the Hamiltonian to the initial state. The time-evolved state is then expanded in this basis, and its complexity is defined as the sum of the squared coefficients. To extract spectral information, they compute the power spectrum of the Krylov complexity, $S_k(\omega)$, via a Fourier transform. This allows them to identify characteristic frequencies related to the system's excitations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations of a theoretical model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Krylov Complexity as a Confinement Fingerprint: The paper establishes that Krylov complexity's behavior is highly sensitive to confinement. In a confining regime, its growth is significantly suppressed, indicating a restricted spread of quantum information.
  • Distinguishing Confinement Regimes: The study clearly differentiates between quenches within the ferromagnetic (confining) phase, within the paramagnetic (non-confining) phase, and across the quantum critical point. Each regime exhibits distinct Krylov complexity dynamics.
  • Meson Spectroscopy from Complexity: A major breakthrough is the demonstration that the oscillations in Krylov complexity within the confining phase directly encode the masses of the emergent "meson-like" bound states. The power spectrum of $C_k(t)$ reveals peaks precisely at these meson masses, validated by semiclassical predictions.
  • Global Probe of Quantum Dynamics: Krylov complexity is presented as a global measure that is less susceptible to the arbitrary choices of partitions or operators, making it a more universal probe of quantum state evolution compared to measures like entanglement entropy.

Key Results

  • Ferromagnetic Phase Quenches: Introducing a longitudinal field ($h_z$) strongly suppresses Krylov complexity growth, with suppression increasing with $h_z$. This indicates arrested dynamics due to confinement.
  • Paramagnetic Phase Quenches: In contrast, increasing $h_z$ in the paramagnetic phase leads to enhanced Krylov complexity, suggesting a non-confining, more chaotic regime.
  • Critical Point Quenches: Quenches across the critical point result in orders-of-magnitude larger Krylov complexity, indicating strong delocalization, with hints of weak confinement at higher $h_z$.
  • Spectral Agreement: The power spectrum of Krylov complexity accurately reproduces the meson masses predicted by semiclassical analysis for the confined states in the ferromagnetic phase. For instance, at $h_x=0.25, h_z=0.2$, the predicted masses $m_1=4.025J$ and $m_2=4.702J$ are found in the complexity spectrum.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the observed "weak confinement" in the critical point quench regime is subdued, potentially due to the large quench amplitude affecting meson propagation velocities. Future work could explore Krylov complexity in lattice gauge theories where confinement arises from gauge constraints, investigate its behavior in finite-temperature systems, and extend its application to probe operator growth in Krylov space. The authors also suggest exploring how confinement affects other aspects of quantum dynamics, such as false-vacuum decay and string breaking.

Summary updated

Abstract

In high-energy physics, confinement denotes the tendency of fundamental particles to remain bound together, preventing their observation as free, isolated entities. Interestingly, analogous confinement behavior emerges in certain condensed matter systems, for instance, in the Ising model with both transverse and longitudinal fields, where domain walls become confined into meson-like bound states as a result of a longitudinal field-induced linear potential. In this work, we employ the Ising model to demonstrate that Krylov state complexity—a measure quantifying the spread of quantum information under the repeated action of the Hamiltonian on a quantum state—serves as a sensitive and quantitative probe of confinement. We show that confinement manifests as a pronounced suppression of Krylov complexity growth following quenches within the ferromagnetic phase in the presence of a longitudinal field, reflecting slow correlation dynamics. In contrast, while quenches within the paramagnetic phase exhibit enhanced complexity with increasing longitudinal field, reflecting the absence of confinement, those crossing the critical point to the ferromagnetic phase reveal a distinct regime characterized by orders-of-magnitude larger complexity and display trends of weak confinement. Notably, in the confining regime, the complexity oscillates at frequencies corresponding to the meson masses, with its power-spectrum peaks closely matching the semiclassical predictions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2026krylov,
  author = {Xudong Jiang and Jad C. Halimeh and N. S. Srivatsa},
  title = {{Krylov complexity and confinement}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1103/1gsg-zb8h},
}

Loading related content...

Figure