Knowledge graph analytics platform with LINCS and IDG for Parkinson’s disease target illumination

Jeremy J. Yang, Christopher Gessner, Joel L. Duerksen, Daniel Biber, Jessica Binder, Murat Öztürk, Brian Foote, Robin McEntire, Kyle Stirling, Ying Ding, David WildbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces KGAP, a novel platform that integrates two large biological datasets (LINCS and IDG) using knowledge graph analytics to identify and prioritize potential drug targets for diseases like Parkinson's. By combining experimental gene expression data with curated knowledge, KGAP offers a powerful, interpretable approach to accelerate drug discovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Discovering new drug targets for complex diseases, such as Parkinson's disease (PD), is a significant challenge. Traditional methods often struggle to integrate the vast and diverse biological information available, leading to slow progress. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a system that can effectively leverage and connect disparate data sources to illuminate potential therapeutic targets. Specifically, they address the need for a robust method to identify and rank novel drug targets by integrating experimental systems biology data with curated knowledge bases.

Methods

The core of this work is the Knowledge Graph Analytics Platform (KGAP). KGAP utilizes a knowledge graph (KG) approach, which represents biological entities (like genes, drugs, and diseases) and their relationships in a structured, interconnected way. The platform integrates data from two major NIH initiatives:

  • LINCS (Library of Integrated Network-based Cellular Signatures): Provides experimental data on how cells respond to various perturbations (drugs, genetic changes) through gene and protein expression signatures.
  • IDG (Illuminating the Druggable Genome): Offers curated knowledge about genes, their potential as drug targets, their mechanisms of action, and their association with diseases.

KGAP builds a graph database (using Neo4j) that links LINCS expression signatures to drugs and genes, and then connects these to disease information from IDG. Graph analytics are then applied to traverse these interconnected paths, aggregating evidence to score and rank potential drug targets. A key aspect is the use of Stouffer's function for z-score aggregation to combine evidence from multiple paths, providing a robust scoring mechanism.

Datasets

The study leverages two primary datasets:

  • LINCS L1000 dataset: This includes differential gene expression data from various cell lines treated with different perturbagens (drugs or genetic modifications).
  • DrugCentral: A resource containing information on drugs, their indications, chemical structures, and associated targets.
  • IDG's Target Central Resource Database (TCRD): Provides gene properties, including target development level (TDL) and gene family information.
  • IDG's Target Importance and Novelty Explorer (TIN-X): Used for evaluating disease-target associations based on bibliometric measures from scientific literature.

The authors also used a curated dataset of known Parkinson's disease (PD) drug targets with elucidated mechanisms of action (MoA) from DrugCentral for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Experimental and Curated Data: The paper highlights the power of combining high-throughput experimental data (LINCS) with expertly curated knowledge (IDG) to uncover novel biological insights.
  • Knowledge Graphs as a Unifying Framework: KGAP demonstrates that knowledge graphs are an effective way to integrate diverse biological data, enabling complex queries and evidence aggregation that would be difficult with traditional methods.
  • Interpretable Drug Target Prioritization: The KGAP approach provides not only ranked lists of potential targets but also the evidence paths supporting these rankings, making the results interpretable for domain scientists.
  • Focus on Understudied Targets: By integrating with IDG, KGAP can specifically illuminate "dark" or understudied genes that might represent promising new therapeutic avenues.

Key Results

  • KGAP successfully identified and ranked 641 genes as potential PD targets, based on evidence paths connecting PD drugs, LINCS expression signatures, and genes.
  • The KGAP approach was validated against known PD drug targets, achieving Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) Area Under the Curve (AUC) values ranging from 0.64 to 0.74. This demonstrates consistent, independent validation of the method.
  • The study identified SYNGR3 (Synaptogyrin-3) as a highly ranked, novel, and plausible drug target for Parkinson's disease, supported by experimental evidence and existing literature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specificity of Classification: The authors acknowledge that while KGAP excels at aggregating evidence and identifying potential targets, its performance as a strict classification method is limited, particularly given the sparsity of known genes. The goal is not classification but rather evidence aggregation and enrichment.
  • Generalizability: While the paper focuses on Parkinson's disease as a proof of concept, the authors emphasize that the KGAP approach is generalizable and applicable to many other disease areas.
  • Future Work: The authors intend to apply KGAP more broadly to other diseases to further explore its utility in drug target illumination. They also aim to enhance the platform's downstream applications through integration with other KG-aligned resources.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background LINCS, “Library of Integrated Network-based Cellular Signatures”, and IDG, “Illuminating the Druggable Genome”, are both NIH projects and consortia that have generated rich datasets for the study of the molecular basis of human health and disease. LINCS L1000 expression signatures provide unbiased systems/omics experimental evidence. IDG provides compiled and curated knowledge for illumination and prioritization of novel drug target hypotheses. Together, these resources can support a powerful new approach to identifying novel drug targets for complex diseases, such as Parkinson’s disease (PD), which continues to inflict severe harm on human health, and resist traditional research approaches. Results Integrating LINCS and IDG, we built the Knowledge Graph Analytics Platform (KGAP) to support an important use case: identification and prioritization of drug target hypotheses for associated diseases. The KGAP approach includes strong semantics interpretable by domain scientists and a robust, high performance implementation of a graph database and related analytical methods. Illustrating the value of our approach, we investigated results from queries relevant to PD. Approved PD drug indications from IDG’s resource DrugCentral were used as starting points for evidence paths exploring chemogenomic space via LINCS expression signatures for associated genes, evaluated as target hypotheses by integration with IDG. The KG-analytic scoring function was validated against a gold standard dataset of genes associated with PD as elucidated, published mechanism-of-action drug targets, also from DrugCentral. IDG’s resource TIN-X was used to rank and filter KGAP results for novel PD targets, and one, SYNGR3 (Synaptogyrin-3), was manually investigated further as a case study and plausible new drug target for PD. Conclusions The synergy of LINCS and IDG, via KG methods, empowers graph analytics methods for the investigation of the molecular basis of complex diseases, and specifically for identification and prioritization of novel drug targets. The KGAP approach enables downstream applications via integration with resources similarly aligned with modern KG methodology. The generality of the approach indicates that KGAP is applicable to many disease areas, in addition to PD, the focus of this paper.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2021knowledge,
  author = {Jeremy J. Yang and Christopher Gessner and Joel L. Duerksen and Daniel Biber and Jessica Binder and Murat Öztürk and Brian Foote and Robin McEntire and Kyle Stirling and Ying Ding and David Wild},
  title = {{Knowledge graph analytics platform with LINCS and IDG for Parkinson’s disease target illumination}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.12.30.424881},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure