Knowledge Distillation Approaches for Accurate and Efficient Recommender System

SeongKu KangarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

As recommender systems (RS) evolve toward increasingly complex architectures like Deep Neural Networks and Graph Convolutional Networks, their deployment in real-time environments becomes constrained by computational and memory overhead. This research addresses the challenge of model compression in RS through novel Knowledge Distillation (KD) frameworks. By moving beyond simple output-matching and focusing on latent representations, ranking structures, and data topology, the proposed methods enable compact student models to achieve the accuracy of massive teacher models with significantly reduced resource requirements.

1. Introduction

Modern recommender systems are essential for navigating the vast information landscapes of platforms like Netflix, Amazon, and Kakao. However, the state-of-the-art models powering these platforms are often too heavy for real-time inference on mobile devices or low-latency servers. While Knowledge Distillation (KD) has been a successful paradigm in computer vision for transferring knowledge from a large "teacher" to a small "student," its application to recommendation tasks is non-trivial. Recommendation is fundamentally a ranking problem, not a classification problem, necessitating specialized distillation strategies that respect the relational and structural nature of user-item interactions.

2. The Challenges of Recommendation Distillation

Standard KD approaches often fail in recommendation contexts due to three primary factors:

  1. Niche Preferences: Traditional KD tends to prioritize popular items, often ignoring the "long tail" of user interests that define personalized recommendations.
  2. The Capacity Gap: A compact student model lacks the capacity to replicate the entire ranking order of millions of items known by the teacher. Attempting to do so introduces noise and degrades performance.
  3. Relational Topology: Recommendation relies on complex relationships between users and items. Simple score-matching ignores the underlying structural similarity between users that teacher models capture.

3. Proposed Methodology

This dissertation introduces a multi-faceted suite of KD techniques categorized by the type of knowledge transferred.

3.1 Latent Knowledge Distillation

These methods focus on the teacher’s internal representations rather than just the final output.

  • Distillation Experts (DE): This framework utilizes multiple specialized "expert" networks to bridge the representation gap. By assigning experts to specific user/item groups, the model prevents bias toward popular items.
  • Personalized Hint Regression (PHR): An advancement of DE, PHR employs a personalization network to generate unique mappings for every user, eliminating the need for manual hyperparameter tuning and improving the granularity of knowledge transfer.

3.2 Ranking Knowledge Distillation

These methods optimize the student’s ability to produce an accurate ranked list.

  • Relaxed Ranking Distillation (RRD): Recognizing that only the top-ranked items matter for user experience, RRD "relaxes" the constraints on lower-ranked, irrelevant items. This allows the student to focus its limited capacity on the items most likely to be consumed.
  • Item-side Ranking Regularization (IR): By incorporating an item-centric perspective (which users like this item?), this method provides a dual-view training signal that stabilizes the learning process.

3.3 Structural & Heterogeneous Distillation

  • Topology Distillation (HTD): HTD ensures that the student model preserves the "shape" of the teacher's latent space, maintaining the relative similarities between users and items.
  • HetComp: Designed for distilling from heterogeneous ensembles (e.g., GNNs and MLPs), HetComp uses a curriculum-based approach. It starts distillation from the teacher's early training states, gradually increasing complexity to avoid overwhelming the student.

4. Experimental Validation

The proposed frameworks were evaluated on several real-world datasets, including CiteULike, Foursquare, Amazon-music, and large-scale platforms like MovieLens 20M and Kakao Brunch.

4.1 Key Results

  • Efficiency: Student models achieved accuracy comparable to their teachers while utilizing only 10–50% of the parameters.
  • Inference Speed: Tests on the NeuMF architecture demonstrated significant reductions in latency, proving the models' readiness for production environments.
  • Accuracy Gains: The HetComp method reduced the ranking discrepancy between student and teacher by up to 39% compared to previous state-of-the-art KD methods.
  • Self-Distillation: The techniques proved effective even when the student and teacher were the same size, acting as a powerful regularizer to improve baseline performance.

5. Discussion and Insights

A critical takeaway from this research is that "less is more" in distillation. Forcing a student to mimic a teacher's entire ranking distribution is counterproductive; focusing on high-confidence, top-tier rankings yields better results. Furthermore, the use of Temporal Consistency (prioritizing teacher predictions that remain stable over time) and Curriculum Learning (starting with simpler teacher states) are vital for bridging the capacity gap between large and small models.

6. Conclusion and Future Work

This work provides a robust foundation for deploying high-performance recommender systems on resource-constrained devices. Future research will focus on extending these KD approaches to content-heavy, feature-based models and addressing algorithmic fairness to ensure that efficiency gains do not come at the cost of reinforcing data biases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite its breakthrough in classification problems, Knowledge distillation (KD) to recommendation models and ranking problems has not been studied well in the previous literature. This dissertation is devoted to developing knowledge distillation methods for recommender systems to fully improve the performance of a compact model. We propose novel distillation methods designed for recommender systems. The proposed methods are categorized according to their knowledge sources as follows: (1) Latent knowledge: we propose two methods that transfer latent knowledge of user/item representation. They effectively transfer knowledge of niche tastes with a balanced distillation strategy that prevents the KD process from being biased towards a small number of large preference groups. Also, we propose a new method that transfers user/item relations in the representation space. The proposed method selectively transfers essential relations considering the limited capacity of the compact model. (2) Ranking knowledge: we propose three methods that transfer ranking knowledge from the recommendation results. They formulate the KD process as a ranking matching problem and transfer the knowledge via a listwise learning strategy. Further, we present a new learning framework that compresses the ranking knowledge of heterogeneous recommendation models. The proposed framework is developed to ease the computational burdens of model ensemble which is a dominant solution for many recommendation applications. We validate the benefit of our proposed methods and frameworks through extensive experiments. To summarize, this dissertation sheds light on knowledge distillation approaches for a better accuracy-efficiency trade-off of the recommendation models.
BibTeX
@misc{kang2024knowledge,
  author = {SeongKu Kang},
  title = {{Knowledge Distillation Approaches for Accurate and Efficient Recommender System}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.13952},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.13952},
}
Figure